NFL ROOKIE of the Year

[patmoran2006]

BAsed on who went where and who's likely to contribute the most, who do ya'll forecast to the NFL Rookie of the Year?

[patmoran2006]

Defense: AJ Hawk, GB
Offense: Vernon Davis, SF

[YardRat]

Laurence Maroney, New England. Williams and Davis have a shot also.

[patmoran2006]

Good pick Yard, I thought of Maroney, I think he's gonna get a LOT Of time in NE with Dillon back there.

[Amare]

Rookie of the Year Offense= Chad Jackson
Rookie of the Year Defense= Kamerion Wimbley

[Mudflap1]

Who dares to be the first soul to suggest Whitner?

Jon

[Amare]

I don't see why he couldn't be.....

[Tinboy]

Offense: DeAngelo Williams
Defense: A.J. Hawk

[R. Rich]

Offensive rookie of the year: Joseph Addai, RB, Indianapolis (He can run, catch, and block well)

Defensive rookie of the year: Manny Lawson, LB, San Fransisco (Could be this year's Shawne Merriman)

[Goobylal]

No way either Maroney OR Jackson get ROTY. Maroney will be splitting time with Dillon (who WILL become a cancer if he doesn't get the rock enough) and Jackson will be another in the long line of Florida WR busts I'm betting, and at least will have trouble picking-up the Patriots' offense as a rookie.

I agree on Addai and Hawk. The Colts will be featuring Addai and have the O-line and Hawk will be NEEDING to make a ton of tackles on the Packers' depleted defense.

[BuffaloBillsStampede]

Offense- Maroney
Defense- Whitner or Hawk

[BuffaloBillsStampede]

I also wouldn't count out Micheal Huff either they had an interview with one of the raiders news people out there on NFL radio yesterday and she said he has looked fantastic.

[OpIv37]

Rod Woodson said on NFL Network a few days ago that he thought it would be Lendale White.

Rod Woodson is a moron.

[patmoran2006]

I also wouldn't count out Micheal Huff either they had an interview with one of the raiders news people out there on NFL radio yesterday and she said he has looked fantastic.
ya and he'll start from day one..
On paper, this looks like a really deep rookie class.

Seeing this Bunkley crap going on in Philly, I am SO glad we didnt take him.. and I was a fan of his pre-draft.

[justasportsfan]

Who dares to be the first soul to suggest Whitner?

Jonwhoever picks him has got to be a major homer


My pick: Nance

[Jan Reimers]

Homers for Whitner, Unite! Seriously, since we have a real need at SS, and arguably a perfect defensive system for his talents, why isn't it very possible?

[Jan Reimers]

whoever picks him has got to be a major homer


My pick: Nance
Perfect, for offensive ROY. And Whitner on D.

[Shasta McNasty]

Bush and Hawk.

[Philagape]

Addai, Bobby Carpenter

[OpIv37]

Homers for Whitner, Unite! Seriously, since we have a real need at SS, and arguably a perfect defensive system for his talents, why isn't it very possible?

Because he plays in Buffalo. Whitner could finish the year with slightly better stats than Huff but still lose defensive RoY to him because Huff plays for a higher profile tieam.

Don't believe me? Look how that punter from Oakland beats out Moorman for the Pro Bowl every year. Moorman is without a doubt the best punter in the league, but as long as he's on the Bills, no one will notice.

also, lack of a pass rush will make our secondary look a lot worse than it is.

[R. Rich]

Rod Woodson said on NFL Network a few days ago that he thought it would be Lendale White.

Rod Woodson is a moron.
Like Woodson would know anything about what makes a good NFL player. What a moron.

[patmoran2006]

Like Woodson would know anything about what makes a good NFL player. What a moron.

Woodson is going to the Hall of Fame.. He's knows plenty about being a good player.

But concerning his selection of Lendale White for ROY, your right on the mark.

[Devin]

Demeco Ryans
Chad Jackson

[R. Rich]

Woodson is going to the Hall of Fame.. He's knows plenty about being a good player.


Yeah, but can he whine about anything under the sun while on a message board?

What a moron.

[OpIv37]

Like Woodson would know anything about what makes a good NFL player. What a moron.

Lendale White wasn't even the best player on his college team. He showed up to USC media day 17 lbs over his playing weight. And he's already been injured once since the college season ended. No way this guy is ROY.

[patmoran2006]

Yeah, but can he whine about anything under the sun while on a message board?

What a moron.
I cant stand WOodson, I remember when Kelly lit him up when we played them in Buffalo...

I'm just saying he is a lot more qualified to talk about other players than most of the other NFL analysts.. He's been there, done that.

[patmoran2006]

Lendale White wasn't even the best player on his college team. He showed up to USC media day 17 lbs over his playing weight. And he's already been injured once since the college season ended. No way this guy is ROY.
He wasnt even the best RUNNING back on his college team.

[R. Rich]

Lendale White wasn't even the best player on his college team. He showed up to USC media day 17 lbs over his playing weight. And he's already been injured once since the college season ended. No way this guy is ROY.


We know that, Bryan. He's LenDale.

[R. Rich]

I cant stand WOodson, I remember when Kelly lit him up when we played them in Buffalo...

I'm just saying he is a lot more qualified to talk about other players than most of the other NFL analysts.. He's been there, done that.

He's not qualified to say anything about anyone. It's not like he was some great player in his day or anything.

[patmoran2006]

He's not qualified to say anything about anyone. It's not like he was some great player in his day or anything.
I'm assuming you're joking.

[justasportsfan]

I'm assuming you're joking.:ugly:


Hey Rich, tell ICe we miss him. Especially Pat.

[R. Rich]

Someone keeps bringing his name up in threads where he obviously doesn't start the discussion.

I'll bet that person, whoever they may be, really misses him.

[justasportsfan]

Someone keeps bringing his name up in threads where he obviously doesn't start the discussion.

I'll bet that person, whoever they may be, really misses him.as annoying as ICe was, he had a sense of humor and can tell if a poster was being sarcastic.

[Billsrock4life]

Offense: Vernon Davis
Defense: A.J. Hawk

[bigbub2352]

Mario Williams DE
Vernon Davis TE

[ublinkwescore]

whoever picks him has got to be a major homer


My pick: Nance

I was gonna put Offense: Nance

Defense: Whitner

[John Doe]

Offense: Matt Leinart

Defense: A. J. Hawk

[DraftBoy]

offense: Davis
defense: Huff

[HHURRICANE]

Offense: DeAngelo Williams
Defense: A.J. Hawk

I think it was AJ Hawk who was a monster in his mini camp!! That's a good pick!!

[HHURRICANE]

I think it was AJ Hawk who was a monster in his mini camp!! That's a good pick!!

My bad, it was Williams!!