Rate the Rookies!

[Tinboy]

So what's the verdict?

[Mr. Cynical]

Re: Rate the Rookies!

Maroney was great.

[Devin]

Re: Rate the Rookies!

Whitner was 50-50. Stat wise he was great though lol.

Seriously he wasnt bad just a rookie, he is gonna be great the more he plays. Got burned on a few plays.

[MTBillsFan]

Re: Rate the Rookies!

Whitner jumped the route he was covering one on one and got the pick! The kid is the real deal.
Ko Simpson stepped in and played alright as well.
I thought the rooks played well. On one drive, we had rooks up the middle of the D. We held NE to a field goal.

[jamze132]

Re: Rate the Rookies!

I am not going to give Maroney all the props since our DB's didn't feel the need to tackle him. But he looks like the real deal.

I was impressed with Kyle Williams.

Did Whitner "REACH" for that pick/TD/stupid Royal block in the back penalty?

Ko Simpson played very well, especially against the run.

Did McCargo suit up?

I saw Keith Ellison in on a couple of plays as well.

[Ebenezer]

Re: Rate the Rookies!

Too much rookie play. The amount of rookie play really shows the level of depth from last year's team.