2004 QB Draft Class

[Mr. Cynical]

2004 QB Draft:

Eli
Rivers
Ben
JP

Discuss....

[Devin]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

uh....so?

[Devin]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

do 2003 next.

[Devin]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

Actually I really feel a need to chat about the 1999 draft class.

Riveting stuff.

[tat2dmike77]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

Still to early to break this class down.

Eli is getting better

Ben just keep his team in the game. But we will see how he does without bettis.

Rivers um held the clipboard really good

JP looked like **** last year. Was decent yesterday.

[tat2dmike77]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

do 2003 next.

Lets talk about 2006 while were at it

[Mr. Cynical]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

Actually I really feel a need to chat about the 1999 draft class.

Riveting stuff.

Kinda funny that you've posted 3 times in a thread you deem useless.

[Devin]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

its late.

[Mr. Cynical]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

Watching Rivers playing tonight got me thinking about that class and how JP stacks up in that class. That's all.

[Ebenezer]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

the jury is way out on all of them...The Steelers win regardless who plays at what position...Manning and Rivers were touted as the #1 overall...many gurus and teams didn't even have JP in the 1st round...any more than that goes out on a limb.

[Mr. Cynical]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

I agree - its way early. I just felt like posting...

I think Ben and Rivers looked more poised in the pocket in their first outings than did Eli and JP. Eli has matured since taking his lumps, so hopefully JP does as well. This class could be pretty special...

[Devin]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

Course if we had a stout offensive line, LT and Antonio Gates along with a stellar Defense JP might look "poised" as well.

[Jan Reimers]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

Big Ben is good, and is surrounded by great coaching and talent. So far, he's at the head of the class.

With the other 3, it's too early to tell. Rivers won a game last night thanks to a superb running game and a ferocious defense. Eli has had a coach who believes in him and has given him 25 or 26 starts already. He's looking better, but I don't think he's a top flight QB as yet.

JP finally has a good coach, but we lack the overall talent level of the Steelers, Chargers and Giants, which really help the other 3.

[X-Era]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

2004 QB Draft:

Eli
Rivers
Ben
JP

Discuss....

One of the stronger classes in the past decade, not to the McNabb draft level bujt its gonna be pretty close.

Its a prediction not a fact.

[Jan Reimers]

Re: 2004 QB Draft Class

I think JP has more physical ability than the other 3. But only time will tell if that translates to success on the field. Both Peyton Manning and Ryan Leaf had physical ability, too - and Leaf may have had more.