OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Everyone needs to apologize to Marv. Stat.

[Mr. Miyagi]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

I never said it was a bad pick.

But yes I'm sold on Whitner too.

[ICE74129]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

Everyone needs to apologize to Marv. Stat.

No. I will appologise a couple to three years from now when he has performed at this level or better consistantly for a few years. THEN is when you determine if a draft/ draft pick was good.

Does he look good so far? Sure, but was it him or Ko that gave up that TD over the middle? The kid still has a ways to go

[Mr. Miyagi]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

No. I will appologise a couple to three years from now when he has performed at this level or better consistantly for a few years.

Not sure if Ralph will still be around in three years.

[ICE74129]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

Not sure if Ralph will still be around in three years.

dude with his health issues, I say next year is a reach. But EE did say appologise to marv.

[OpIv37]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

No. I will appologise a couple to three years from now when he has performed at this level or better consistantly for a few years. THEN is when you determine if a draft/ draft pick was good.

Does he look good so far? Sure, but was it him or Ko that gave up that TD over the middle? The kid still has a ways to go

I think it was him but I'm not sure. Either way, he came right back and knocked away the ball on the 2 pt attempt. So at least he recovered and didn't get phased by the mistake.

I never thought Whitner was a bad player- the debate was over the manner in which he was acquired. But if he continues to play well, it's irrelevant.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

No. I will appologise a couple to three years from now when he has performed at this level or better consistantly for a few years. THEN is when you determine if a draft/ draft pick was good.

Does he look good so far? Sure, but was it him or Ko that gave up that TD over the middle? The kid still has a ways to go

Do they have a Ways to go or just a little bit to go?

[Dr. Lecter]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

No. I will appologise a couple to three years from now when he has performed at this level or better consistantly for a few years. THEN is when you determine if a draft/ draft pick was good.

Does he look good so far? Sure, but was it him or Ko that gave up that TD over the middle? The kid still has a ways to go

Take a step back Ice.

You crticize one of those kids for making one mistake, but when somebody criticizes JP for making one mistake, you get kinda testy.

Mistakes happen. Whitner is not only starting, but callng the defense out there as well. He is exceeding any reasonable expectations.

This guy will be a star.

And EE, not everybody needs to apologize to Marv.

[LtBillsFan66]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

I don't need to apologize. I liked the pick.

[BillsFever21]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

He's played good for a rookie but it's not like he's been lights out and like Ed Reed. If he continues to progress then he could be a great player.

He got beat a lot against the Patriots last week that lead to us blowing the lead. For a rookie he's looked pretty good so far though.

John McCargo hasn't done squat so far though. Just like with Whitner though it's too early to tell. A career isn't made in 2 games.

[Dr. Lecter]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

McCargo might never put up big numbers. That is not his role.

[Meathead]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

Everyone needs to apologize to Marv. Stat.

what we white man

[L.A. Playa]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

what we white man

???

[ICE74129]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

I think it was him but I'm not sure. Either way, he came right back and knocked away the ball on the 2 pt attempt. So at least he recovered and didn't get phased by the mistake.

I never thought Whitner was a bad player- the debate was over the manner in which he was acquired. But if he continues to play well, it's irrelevant.

Hey the only gripe I think any of us had was WHERE he was picked. But like I said I want to see how he is in about 2 more years. I think the kid will be all pro, but time will tell

[Mr. Miyagi]

Re: OK, I'm sold on Whitner.

dude with his health issues, I say next year is a reach. But EE did say appologise to marv.

Oh yeah, Marv is much younger.