Non-Bills question....

[Jeff1220]

If for some reason Donovan McNabb is released (due to injury history & the sudden resurgence of Jeff Garcia, who could handle duty until a draft pick could take over), who do you see getting him. McNabb is a great QB when on the field, but the injuries over the past few seasons make him somewhat of a liability. Due to his 'Cuse roots, I'm a big fan, but JP has obviously cemented himself as the starter for another year (and I am happy with that), so what team could make a play for one of the better NFL QBs of the past 10 years?

[RockStar36]

Re: Non-Bills question....

There is no way McNabb gets released in favor of 36 year old Jeff Garcia. If Garcia is smart he would just stay in Philly.

[BILLSROCK1212]

Re: Non-Bills question....

dude this will never happen there is no argument.......that wud be one of the worst moves in NFL history....srry bud dream's over

[Devin]

Re: Non-Bills question....

However if Garcia gets released I could see him going someplace where a rookie is drafted to "coach for a year" perhaps Oakland.

[Typ0]

Re: Non-Bills question....

yeah JP is playing better...and if we already have next season penciled in as him and KH as backup we are nuts. teams need two quality qbs on the squad plus JP needs the competition...unless his fragile ego can't take it.

[clumping platelets]

Re: Non-Bills question....

McNabb is going no where......

[Lexwhat]

Re: Non-Bills question....

McNabb is the face of sports in Philadelphia, especially since Iverson just left. Matter of fact, he even has enough power to drive TO off the team...haha.

[PECKERWOOD]

Re: Non-Bills question....

Yeah, I can't see this happening.. But if it did happen, I could see: Miami, Houston, Cleveland, Green Bay, Carolina, Tampa Bay and Kansas City all making efforts at signing him.. I don't think Philly would be stupid enough to release him though.. Unless, his injury is worst than we all thought it was.

[Jeff1220]

Re: Non-Bills question....

dude this will never happen there is no argument.......that wud be one of the worst moves in NFL history....srry bud dream's over

Who's dream? I was just trying to bring up a hypothetical situation, as there are a lot of 'Cuse fans on this board. As I said in my post, with JP playing as well as he is, there is no need or reason for any QB outside of a b/u.
As far as McNabb leaving Philly, stranger things have happened. As I said before, he hasn't completed 16 games in quite a while. If Garcia takes them deep (no Garcia innuendo intended there) into the playoffs, who says they don't use him as stop gap with a young guy? Maybe it's not likely, but watching Garcia play the other night...he was playing really good ball. Again, stranger things have happened.

[gr8slayer]

Re: Non-Bills question....

We are set at QB for alot of years to come.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Re: Non-Bills question....

Exactly Jeff. You weren't dreaming about anything. Just bringing up a hypothetical situation. While I find it hard to believe they would get rid of Mcnabb if somehow Garcia won the superbowl who knows what could happen.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Re: Non-Bills question....

We are set at QB for alot of years to come.

Right he didn't say the Bills would be the team getting Mcnabb.

[gr8slayer]

Re: Non-Bills question....

But hey, if Garcia wins a SB how can they not start him going into next year.

[Kerr]

Re: Non-Bills question....

Hypothetically speaking, I could see Mcnabb heading to detriot and getting a big payday playing for Martz' offense.

[RockStar36]

Re: Non-Bills question....

However if Garcia gets released I could see him going someplace where a rookie is drafted to "coach for a year" perhaps Oakland.

Didn't he already try that in Cleveland and Detroit?

I heard that he was offered a deal from Philly and Houston and chose Philly because he wanted to be on a winning team. I can't imagine him taking off to go play for a **** team next year.