The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

[Mr. Miyagi]

The Culpepper over Brees thing sparked the idea. What other ones can you think of?

I got Williams over Bush by Houston last year.

RJ over Flutie maybe?

[gr8slayer]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

The Culpepper over Brees thing sparked the idea. What other ones can you think of?

I got Williams over Bush by Houston last year.

RJ over Flutie maybe?

Can I just say the Miami Dolphins? Or do I have to break down every single one of their **** ups?

[jamze132]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

Maybe drafting Mike Williams 4th overall?

Drafting Tim Couch #1

[RockStar36]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

Making Nate Clements the highest paid defensive player in NFL history.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

The Hershel Walker trade.

The OJ trade.

[Dr. Lecter]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

The Culpepper over Brees thing sparked the idea. What other ones can you think of?

I got Williams over Bush by Houston last year.

RJ over Flutie maybe?

RJ over Flutie is not even close. (Whether it is the playoff game or the off-season move)

Ryan Leaf #2 overall. Alvin Harper's big deal with Tampa. TO to Philly. San Fran's trade fo OJ. NO trading their entire draft for Ricky.

[patmoran2006]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

For the Bills, its hiring Mularkey..

He took a playoff worthy team and made them into scrubs.. Almost any coach in the NFL gets that team in the playoffs.. twice

[Mr. Miyagi]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

What about Atlanta trading up to get Vick when San Diego slid down to #5 and got Tomlinson? Vick isn't a complete bust just yet but LT would've been much much better.

[Mr. Miyagi]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

For the Bills, its hiring Mularkey..

He took a playoff worthy team and made them into scrubs.. Almost any coach in the NFL gets that team in the playoffs.. twice

Which reminds me of Steve Spurrier.

[Jan Reimers]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

Tony Mandarich.
Brian Bosworth.

[patmoran2006]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

What about Atlanta trading up to get Vick when San Diego slid down to #5 and got Tomlinson? Vick isn't a complete bust just yet but LT would've been much much better.

SD also took Brees in round two that year.. so they coulda had both

[OpIv37]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

Dolpins and Culpepper may be on that list soon.

What about McGahee over Larry Johnson and keeping him over Travis Henry? It may not be worst in NFL history but it was definitely a bad one.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

Tony Mandarich.
Brian Bosworth.

Tom Cousineau
Tom Ruud
Al Cowlings

[Romes]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

Ryan Leaf comes to mind.

Wasn't Unitas traded to colts in the begining of his career?

[Earthquake Enyart]

Re: The Worst Personnel Decisions in NFL history

I think Unitas was cut. So was Jack Kemp.