PDA

View Full Version : This years draft



kernowboy
04-29-2007, 04:47 PM
A brief synopsis of each pick by Pete Fiutak at MSN Foxsports

Ironically he is most critical of the Lynch pick, but on reflection it was as good a choice as we could have made under the circumstances

However the 7b pick is an absolute dog ... Dan Mozes, Travarous Bain etc would all have been better and of greater need - lets hope they remain undrafted so we can pick them up.

Overall this is a A+ draft IMHO

Read below

R1. Marshawn Lynch, RB, California
He's not the sure-thing many are going to want him to be. In a lousy year for running backs, he's everyone's number two behind Adrian Peterson with great speed, tremendous cutting ability, and is a good blocker. Is he a workhorse? When he's gotten significant carries, he's been banged up. He'll have "wow' games when he tears off big plays and cranks out big numbers, but don't expect him to do it for a full 16-game season.

R2. Paul Posluzny, SLB, Penn St
Ultra-productive, if slightly overrated as a college player, he's a straight up football player who'll make the defense his in a big hurry. He's always around the ball and always making plays, even though he can get pushed around a little bit when a big lineman gets a hat on him. He'll have to work on being better in pass coverage, but that'll come. He'll be a ten-year rock.

R3. Trent Edwards, QB, Stanford
A pure physical specimen, he has the NFL body ... for an outside linebacker. He never got much time to work behind a porous line and got banged up year after year. He looks the part and could shine once he gets a good line, and NFL skill players, to work with.

R4. Dwayne Wright, RB/FB, Fresno St
An ideal backup running back who'll be great to wear down defenses on a drive here and there, he's a strong, tough runner who could turn into a whale of a goal line specialist. Not fast, a bit old, and with no more room for improving much, what you see is what you get.

R6. John Wendling, S, Wyoming
Big, fast and athletic, he's a shockingly unknown commodity among the NFL types. He's been a fantastic producer for the last three years with good tackling skills and All-America ability that flew under the radar. If he can amp up the intensity a bit and make a few big hits early on in camp, everyone will realize what a steal he is.

R7a, Derek Schouman, TE, Boise St
A fantastic athlete who can block a little bit, he was great at making short running plays big ones with one key block. He has the ability to become a better pass catcher than he showed on a consistent basis at Boise State. Yeah, he can block, but he's not going to bury anyone.

R7b CJ Ah You, DE,
He should've been an amazing college player and it just didn't happen. He has size, speed, and can get to the quarterback if everything breaks the right way, but he didn't come remotely close to playing up to his potential. He's an old rookie (25 at draft time) and may have already hit his ceiling.

YardRat
04-29-2007, 04:51 PM
Starter, starter, back-up, situational specialist, back-up, practice squad, camp fodder.

ShadowHawk7
04-29-2007, 06:10 PM
We could have completely allieviated our depth problem at LB had we just selected Siler instead of A-choo or whatever. :mad:

historypete
04-29-2007, 06:47 PM
I really like his comments about Poz. It might be a big steal getting him in the 2nd, when he was considered a 1st rounder, albeit later 1st round.

YardRat
04-29-2007, 06:52 PM
We could have completely allieviated our depth problem at LB had we just selected Siler instead of A-choo or whatever. :mad:

Yeah, I agree. Draft Siler and bring in Ah You as an UDFA and you have both in camp.

Jan Reimers
04-29-2007, 07:13 PM
Why did Siler's stock drop so much?

He was regarded by many as one of the top LBs in the draft and a first day pick.

The Spaz
04-29-2007, 07:17 PM
Yeah, I agree. Draft Siler and bring in Ah You as an UDFA and you have both in camp.

Yet nobody drafted him until the 7th.

YardRat
04-30-2007, 05:30 AM
Yet nobody drafted him until the 7th.

My point wasn't one of us taking him earlier in the draft...Since he dropped so far, we could have used one of our sevenths on him. I'd prefer to use late picks to take a chance on someone like Siler as opposed to Ya Hoo.

As I said earlier...we could've had both.

LifetimeBillsFan
04-30-2007, 07:39 AM
Why did Siler's stock drop so much?

He was regarded by many as one of the top LBs in the draft and a first day pick.

I can't recall where I read it, but I saw an article when I was reading around (CNNSI, Msn.foxsports, ESPN, CBSSportsline, SportingNews, etc.) that said the big concern about Siler was whether he had the size to play in the middle or the speed to play outside (apparently he's not considered a sideline-to-sideline LB) and also it said that "he's a jerk". I was rather shocked when I read that because I hadn't seen anything like that in any of the previous stuff I had read about him. Maybe that is something that came out when teams started talking with him at The Combine and, then, in interviews with his teammates. Given the climate these days, I can see why teams might shy away from someone who might be considered "a jerk", especially if there are also questions about whether he has the speed/size ratio needed to be a fit for a NFL team.

Prior to the draft I would have been delighted to see the Bills end up with either Siler or his teammate Earl Everett--who went undrafted. But, there are a lot of things that come up that the NFL teams know about regarding players that often the fans and even the "gurus" never find out about.

HHURRICANE
04-30-2007, 07:45 AM
I heard that he needed another year in college. Plus he has skinnier legs than me and he's a linebacker. Let the scouts do there job.

Wendling could be another LB for us.

Dr. Lecter
04-30-2007, 07:47 AM
We could have completely allieviated our depth problem at LB had we just selected Siler instead of A-choo or whatever. :mad:

Based on what?

Maybe SIler is not what many of thought. Most NFL teams aren't high on him

Why is a 7th round pick better depth than Stamer or Haggan?

EDS
04-30-2007, 08:23 AM
I heard that he needed another year in college. Plus he has skinnier legs than me and he's a linebacker. Let the scouts do there job.

Wendling could be another LB for us.

I was thinking that Wendling was a candidate for LB once he puts on a few pounds.

ShadowHawk7
05-03-2007, 01:45 PM
Based on what?

Maybe SIler is not what many of thought. Most NFL teams aren't high on him

Why is a 7th round pick better depth than Stamer or Haggan?
Marv has proved that he'll go BPA if the opportunity presents itself right? So are you telling me that OBD ranked Ah-choo ahead of Brandon Siler on it's draft board? If so, that's absurd. I don't care if it's 1st or 7th round, this pick should get blasted because we ignored both need AND BPA at the same time and drafted a player at one of our strongest positions on the team.

tampabay25690
05-03-2007, 10:35 PM
I like are draft in all...

alohabillsfan
05-04-2007, 05:57 AM
I don't know why many of you want to bring in a LB that just does not "fit" the system! You just can't plug a LB into this defense it has to be the right type. Not to mention that Siler played behind an insane defensive line with 4+ dlinemen getting drafted!

Night Train
05-04-2007, 06:08 AM
The comments above by the Fox writer are pretty fair.

I think Lynch can give us some big plays and having A.Thomas and Wright on the roster reduces the worry of injury or capable backups. Drafting 2 RB's makes sense, after making the effort to upgrade the OL. Pass protection was part of the equation but the primary purpose was to improve the run blocking.

Other areas are still a little thin in depth, such as LB and CB. I believe we''ll make some moves there, prior to the opener.

TigerJ
05-04-2007, 08:07 AM
I heard that he needed another year in college. Plus he has skinnier legs than me and he's a linebacker. Let the scouts do there job.

Wendling could be another LB for us.

Ironically enough, one of the major knocks on Shane Conlan when he came out of Penn State was that he had skinny legs. Anyone else recall that?

POZ
05-04-2007, 08:18 AM
A brief synopsis of each pick by Pete Fiutak at MSN Foxsports

Ironically he is most critical of the Lynch pick, but on reflection it was as good a choice as we could have made under the circumstances

However the 7b pick is an absolute dog ... Dan Mozes, Travarous Bain etc would all have been better and of greater need - lets hope they remain undrafted so we can pick them up.

Overall this is a A+ draft IMHO

Read below

R1. Marshawn Lynch, RB, California
He's not the sure-thing many are going to want him to be. In a lousy year for running backs, he's everyone's number two behind Adrian Peterson with great speed, tremendous cutting ability, and is a good blocker. Is he a workhorse? When he's gotten significant carries, he's been banged up. He'll have "wow' games when he tears off big plays and cranks out big numbers, but don't expect him to do it for a full 16-game season.

R2. Paul Posluzny, SLB, Penn St
Ultra-productive, if slightly overrated as a college player, he's a straight up football player who'll make the defense his in a big hurry. He's always around the ball and always making plays, even though he can get pushed around a little bit when a big lineman gets a hat on him. He'll have to work on being better in pass coverage, but that'll come. He'll be a ten-year rock.

R3. Trent Edwards, QB, Stanford
A pure physical specimen, he has the NFL body ... for an outside linebacker. He never got much time to work behind a porous line and got banged up year after year. He looks the part and could shine once he gets a good line, and NFL skill players, to work with.

R4. Dwayne Wright, RB/FB, Fresno St
An ideal backup running back who'll be great to wear down defenses on a drive here and there, he's a strong, tough runner who could turn into a whale of a goal line specialist. Not fast, a bit old, and with no more room for improving much, what you see is what you get.

R6. John Wendling, S, Wyoming
Big, fast and athletic, he's a shockingly unknown commodity among the NFL types. He's been a fantastic producer for the last three years with good tackling skills and All-America ability that flew under the radar. If he can amp up the intensity a bit and make a few big hits early on in camp, everyone will realize what a steal he is.

R7a, Derek Schouman, TE, Boise St
A fantastic athlete who can block a little bit, he was great at making short running plays big ones with one key block. He has the ability to become a better pass catcher than he showed on a consistent basis at Boise State. Yeah, he can block, but he's not going to bury anyone.

R7b CJ Ah You, DE,
He should've been an amazing college player and it just didn't happen. He has size, speed, and can get to the quarterback if everything breaks the right way, but he didn't come remotely close to playing up to his potential. He's an old rookie (25 at draft time) and may have already hit his ceiling.
If only that was in your own words!