Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

[Mad Bomber]

I read every thread on this board every day. You may notice that I give feedback (, Thanks, or as appropriate), but I don't post unless I feel strongly about things.

I just want to post something to put a little moderation on things.

Yes, Trent Edwards had a really good game vs. the Jests.

I'm not ready to anoint him as Messiah just yet.

JP was very disappointing in the first two games; I don't have a lot of confidence in him. He looked clueless against some very good defenses. He looked like he had regressed compared to the last half of last year...that deer in the headlights look. Couldn't hit the short route....is it possible that the same receivers that Trent was hitting last Sunday were actually open and he didn't see them? I don't know...

Trent Edwards had a great game against the very overrated Jets. I would love to see him have a great game against the Cowboys. That would go a long way toward me believing that he may be the future. But the knee-jerk posts of some people (I won't name names) that have him as the next Joe Montana are just, IMHO, a little premature. He could very well come out and stink up the place on Monday night. As a Bills fan, I hope he SHINES.

No matter who the QB is, I ALWAYS hope that they play well and lead the Bills to victory.

We need to show a little restraint and tone the TE vs. JP arguments down just a little bit.

...just my :

[LtFinFan66]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

Who are JP and Trent never heard of them

[Dr. Lecter]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

Nicely said MB.

Too many people are more concerned with being "right" about the QB than they are the Bills doing well and winning.

[Mr. Pink]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

JP Edwards and Trent Losman are two swell guys!

Craig Nall could be our QB as long as we're winning games.

[Billscusey]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

Uh, ok.....except that this is a DISCUSSION board! I'd say debating the quarterback situation of our favourite football team is EXACTLY what we should be doing here!

[X-Era]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

I read every thread on this board every day. You may notice that I give feedback (, Thanks, or as appropriate), but I don't post unless I feel strongly about things.

I just want to post something to put a little moderation on things.

Yes, Trent Edwards had a really good game vs. the Jests.

I'm not ready to anoint him as Messiah just yet.

JP was very disappointing in the first two games; I don't have a lot of confidence in him. He looked clueless against some very good defenses. He looked like he had regressed compared to the last half of last year...that deer in the headlights look. Couldn't hit the short route....is it possible that the same receivers that Trent was hitting last Sunday were actually open and he didn't see them? I don't know...

Trent Edwards had a great game against the very overrated Jets. I would love to see him have a great game against the Cowboys. That would go a long way toward me believing that he may be the future. But the knee-jerk posts of some people (I won't name names) that have him as the next Joe Montana are just, IMHO, a little premature. He could very well come out and stink up the place on Monday night. As a Bills fan, I hope he SHINES.

No matter who the QB is, I ALWAYS hope that they play well and lead the Bills to victory.

We need to show a little restraint and tone the TE vs. JP arguments down just a little bit.

...just my :

Completely agree. It was one game. I liked everything that I saw from him except for a few bad throws. JP has been bad this year so far. Thats the facts. But, does that mean we should give the team to the rookie? based on one game? I cant say that. Does that mean Trent is the next Joe Montana? Its foolish to even go there at this point. I think the key is what he does in this game. If he can play lights out again, win or lose, I think the job is his. But lets not forget Trent also looked pretty bad against NE. If he regresses, Im not sure we should stick with Trent. JP had some good games too.

[YardRat]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

I wouldn't expect Edwards to shine Monday Night...I just hope he plays well enough to help the team pull out a W.

[casdhf]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

favourite

[churchinski]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

We need to show a little restraint and tone the TE vs. JP arguments down just a little bit.

...just my :

Hah

I don't see a reason, let alone a need, to have anyone restrain their opinion on something like who is the better QB on a football team.

How could there possible be a need for something like that ?

Just what do you think will happen if people continue to freely speak thier opinion ?

Do you expecting an arrest or some sort of natural catastrophe ?

[TacklingDummy]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

Who compares Trent to Montana already?

That's about ******ed as the Lickers comparing JP to Steve Young, Manning, Montana, Favre, Kelly etc...

[SquishDaFish]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

Great posting MB. Totally agree I dont even come in here much lately because of that reason.

[Philagape]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

Too many attention whores want to have their own thread.

[Jan Reimers]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

May the best man win the job. I want them both to do well, and don't care who is the starter.

I just want the Bills to. win.

[mybills]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

May the best man win the job. I want them both to do well, and don't care who is the starter.

I just want the Bills to. win.

[Tatonka]

Re: Wow, SO many Trent vs. JP threads

my biggest concern with trent is that when he came out of college, he had an injury bug. i hope that is not the case, but a good qb who is always hurt doesnt help anyone either.