Your thoughts on Willis McGahee

[RedEyE]

McGahee's agent is reporting him completely healthy. So healthy infact, that Nike has signed him to a promotinal and endorsement deal worth nearly $100,000. That deal maybe the largest offered to a draft prospect.

Draft gurus: When is McGahee projected to go in the draft? Is he worth a gamble?

IMO, if he is available in the 3rd round - suck him up. He was a great back in Miami and was originally projected to be drafted high in the first round prior to his unfortunate injury against Ohio State. He may end up becoming the story of the year next season and could provide quality trade material or backup in 2004.



http://espn.go.com/nfl/columns/pasquarelli_len/1527197.html

[Pride]

If you are talking about a replacement for TH, forget it. I do not want another RB by commitee approach here. Pick a back, run him 3 downs, then bring in GASH on 4th and 1! LOL

[SABURZFAN]

mcgahee is a good RB but i'm satisfied with henry.we have other needs to tend to.

[Mr. Miyagi]

Didn't anyone see the way he screwed up his knee? NOBODY with an injury like that ever comes back 100% (of course his agent says he is).

NO NO NO!!!!!

[NC-BILLS44]

I agree with RedEye. If he is available in the 3rd round, take him. You just never know what will happen during the course of a season.

[Ebenezer]

Damaged Goods. Pass.

[don137]

He blew out a knee in high school too. His NFL career will most likely be short and uneventful.

[clumping platelets]

No thanks!!

Bills will probably draft a RB on day two

RB Cecil Sapp from Colorado St is a player I like :)

[BillsMan80]

I'd take him the 2nd Round...Great talent. Likely will work his way back to 100% by halfway through the season and a better back than Clinton Portis. Will also be better in the Pros. Backup RB is quite possibly our biggest need too. McGahee is bigger and faster than Portis. Yes on McGahee.

[Mr. Miyagi]

Originally posted by BillsMan80
I'd take him the 2nd Round...Great talent. Likely will work his way back to 100% by halfway through the season and a better back than Clinton Portis. Will also be better in the Pros. Backup RB is quite possibly our biggest need too. McGahee is bigger and faster than Portis. Yes on McGahee.
Everything you said applies only to the PRE-BLOWN-OUT-KNEE McGahee. Not the one who'll be available next month.

Anyone who's broken a bone or a serious injury like his can tell you that it's not something you'll recover from in a year, or even two or three. You'll always be a little bit less in performance and a little more scared mentally. Hell I broken my leg in high school 14 years ago and it still hurts every once in a while when it rains or something.

PASS.

[colin]

Is he still fast?

Who is fast in the rounds 1-4 range this year?

We need a fast back.

[BillsMan80]

He's 6-2, 225, and runs a 4.2-4.3 40...and believe me, I broke my ankle seriously, with surgery and it only took me 6-7 months to be back to 100%.

[TedMock]

He's great and if he's healthy he'll be a great pro back. We need a backup. If he's 100% he's fighting for a starting spot at least by year 2 and we don't need controversy. I like him quite a bit but I don't see a reason to bring him in. If he's starting caliber then he or Henry sits the bench and becomes disgruntled. That's doing nothing for our team nor for their careers.

[The Spaz]

Originally posted by BillsMan80
He's 6-2, 225, and runs a 4.2-4.3 40...and believe me, I broke my ankle seriously, with surgery and it only took me 6-7 months to be back to 100%.

The guy tore ligaments in his knee he didn't break his ankle. He tore his ACL, MCL, PCL. I'm telling you now he will not play until 2004. If he does try to go this year he will tear one of those again no doubt. Go Bills!

[Bert102176]

what great running back was it that we drafted that helped us get to 4 straight superbowls that blew out his knee oh yeah does the name Thurman Thomas come to mind.

[BillsMan80]

I'll guarantee you he'll be back this season. He will be playing by midseason. He injured his knee on January 3rd. That is a lot of time to recover.

[The Spaz]

Originally posted by Bert102176
what great running back was it that we drafted that helped us get to 4 straight superbowls that blew out his knee oh yeah does the name Thurman Thomas come to mind.

Your right but heh didn't tear all of those ligaments in his knee. I'm just telling you that I am a person trainer and I see all types of injuries everyday and help them go through physical therapy. People have a hard enough time coming back from an acl or an mcl but to have all three ACL, MCL, PCl torn your dealing with something totally different. If he comes back good for him but I wouldn't count on him until 2004. The guy better be looking toward his future not cash. Go Bills!