Rank Your Bills Starters

[patmoran2006]

Let's play a little game. This will give us an idea of who we think are the best Bills players on the team (sorry, but Moorman and Lindell are disqualified).

The following are all of the Bills starters, rank them in order of who you think is the best, with the best player getting 22 points, and the worst getting 1 point. (We don't really have a starting FB, so I added a third WR in Parrish)

Each person gets only one vote.. At the conclusion, I'll add up the points and make a list on the consensus of the board.

Here are the Starters
Offense
JP Losman
Marshawn Lynch
Lee Evans
Josh Reed
Roscoe Parrish
Robert Royal
Jason Peters
Derrick Dockery
Melvin Fowler
Brad Butler
Langston Walker

Defense
Larry Tripplett
Kyle Williams
Aaron Schobel
CHris Kelsay
ANgelo Crowell
John DiGiorgio
Keith Ellison
Jabrari Greer
Terrence McGee
George Wilson
Donte Whitner

[patmoran2006]

Let's play a little game. This will give us an idea of who we think are the best Bills players on the team (sorry, but Moorman and Lindell are disqualified).

The following are all of the Bills starters, rank them in order of who you think is the best, with the best player getting 22 points, and the worst getting 1 point. (We don't really have a starting FB, so I added a third WR in Parrish)

Each person gets only one vote.. At the conclusion, I'll add up the points and make a list on the consensus of the board.

Here are the Starters
Offense
JP Losman-
Marshawn Lynch-
Lee Evans-
Josh Reed-
Roscoe Parrish-
Robert Royal-
Jason Peters-
Derrick Dockery-
Melvin Fowler-
Brad Butler-
Langston Walker-

Defense
Larry Tripplett-
Kyle Williams-
Aaron Schobel-
CHris Kelsay-
ANgelo Crowell-
John DiGiorgio-
Keith Ellison-
Jabrari Greer-
Terrence McGee-
George Wilson-
Donte Whitner-
I'll go first

Offense
JP Losman-14
Marshawn Lynch- 22
Lee Evans- 21
Josh Reed-8
Roscoe Parrish-11
Robert Royal-3
Jason Peters- 20
Derrick Dockery-17
Melvin Fowler-1
Brad Butler-2
Langston Walker-10

Defense
Larry Tripplett-5
Kyle Williams-7
Aaron Schobel-18
CHris Kelsay- 16
ANgelo Crowell- 19
John DiGiorgio-9
Keith Ellison-6
Jabrari Greer-13
Terrence McGee-12
George Wilson-4
Donte Whitner-15

[djjimkelly]

Offense
JP Losman-18
Marshawn Lynch-20
Lee Evans-22
Josh Reed-5
Roscoe Parrish-13
Robert Royal-4
Jason Peters-19
Derrick Dockery-15
Melvin Fowler-3
Brad Butler-8
Langston Walker-9

Defense
Larry Tripplett-7
Kyle Williams-6
Aaron Schobel-16
CHris Kelsay-14
ANgelo Crowell-21
John DiGiorgio-2
Keith Ellison-10
Jabrari Greer-11
Terrence McGee-12
George Wilson-1
Donte Whitner-17

[Mahdi]

Offense
JP Losman-13
Marshawn Lynch-20
Lee Evans-19
Josh Reed-11
Roscoe Parrish-11
Robert Royal-11
Jason Peters-20
Derrick Dockery-18
Melvin Fowler-9
Brad Butler-11
Langston Walker-18

Defense
Larry Tripplett-14
Kyle Williams-16
Aaron Schobel-16
CHris Kelsay-16
ANgelo Crowell-19
John DiGiorgio-17
Keith Ellison-14
Jabrari Greer-15
Terrence McGee-17
George Wilson-13
Donte Whitner-16

Where;s the love for Walker,,, guy has been solid,,,,

[djjimkelly]

madhi i dont think your supposed to use same number twice.

worst to first!

[YardRat]

Offense
JP Losman-4
Marshawn Lynch-22
Lee Evans-21
Josh Reed-13
Roscoe Parrish-12
Robert Royal-7
Jason Peters-19
Derrick Dockery-16
Melvin Fowler-1
Brad Butler-2
Langston Walker-11

Defense
Larry Tripplett-6
Kyle Williams-5
Aaron Schobel-15
CHris Kelsay-10
ANgelo Crowell-20
John DiGiorgio-9
Keith Ellison-8
Jabrari Greer-14
Terrence McGee-18
George Wilson-3
Donte Whitner-17<!-- / message --><!-- sig -->

[Yasgur's Farm]

Offense
JP Losman-17
Marshawn Lynch-21
Lee Evans-22
Josh Reed-9
Roscoe Parrish-8 (As a WR... not ST)
Robert Royal-7
Jason Peters-15
Derrick Dockery-16
Melvin Fowler-1
Brad Butler-6
Langston Walker-10

Defense
Larry Tripplett-3
Kyle Williams-12
Aaron Schobel-13
Chris Kelsay-14
Angelo Crowell-19
John DiGiorgio-18
Keith Ellison-2
Jabrari Greer-4
Terrence McGee-11 (As a CB... not ST)
George Wilson-5
Donte Whitner-20

[Philagape]

Offense
JP Losman-7
Marshawn Lynch-22
Lee Evans-19
Josh Reed-14
Roscoe Parrish-9
Robert Royal-6
Jason Peters-21
Derrick Dockery-17
Melvin Fowler-2
Brad Butler-1
Langston Walker-10

Defense
Larry Tripplett-5
Kyle Williams-8
Aaron Schobel-12
Chris Kelsay-13
Angelo Crowell-20
John DiGiorgio-11
Keith Ellison-4
Jabari Greer-18
Terrence McGee-16
George Wilson-3
Donte Whitner-15

[The last buffalo fan]

Lee Evans- 22
Marshawn Lynch- 21
Angelo Crowell- 20
Donte Whitner-19
Terrence McGee-18
Jabrari Greer-17
McCargo- 16
JP Losman-15
Jason Peters- 14
Chris Kelsay- 13
John DiGiorgio-12
Josh Reed-11
Roscoe Parrish-10
Aaron Schobel-09
Derrick Dockery-08
Langston Walker-07
Keith Ellison-06
George Wilson-05
Brad Butler-04
Melvin Fowler-03
Robert Royal-02
Larry Tripplett-01

[Yasgur's Farm]

This is a very good thread Pat. It shows us clearly where we need to focus in free agency and the draft.

1) C
2) CB
3) RG
4) TE
5) WR

LB - Poz's return and Wire's play is enough + add depth
DT - McCargo starting over Tripplett is enough
FS - Ko Simpson's return is enough

[Mitchy moo]

* Trent Edwards - #1

The rest are just fill in's........





J / K.

[Mahdi]

madhi i dont think your supposed to use same number twice.

worst to first!
O woops,,,, thanks for pointing that out.