Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • trapezeus
    Legendary Zoner
    • Oct 2004
    • 19525

    Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

    this kid hasn't progressed either. and he has more receivers, a weaker league, and a better running game. Perhaps losman would be better in a weaker NFC division.

    Manning also has gilbride as his QB coach, so that says something.
  • raphael120
    Jason Peters rigorous at home training regiment
    • Oct 2005
    • 5152

    #2
    Re: Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

    interesting question...if JP had burress and shockey, would he be doing the same thing?

    Comment

    • The Answer
      The Plagiarist
      • Mar 2007
      • 2633

      #3
      Re: Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

      Originally posted by trapezeus
      this kid hasn't progressed either. and he has more receivers, a weaker league, and a better running game. Perhaps losman would be better in a weaker NFC division.

      Manning also has gilbride as his QB coach, so that says something.
      No Manning has been to the playoffs 2 times already, and will likely make it 3 straight years despite the Giants latest nov/dec meltdown. He'll never be his brother, but he'll most certainly have a job in this league a lot longer than Losman.

      Losman is the bust of the 2004 draft and there's no doubt about that anymore given the success of the other 3 QB's drafted ahead of him that year. Big Ben already has a ring and Rivers is also a good QB despite his ups and downs early on in his career.

      ~The Answer

      Comment

      • trapezeus
        Legendary Zoner
        • Oct 2004
        • 19525

        #4
        Re: Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

        as much as i've lost faith in Losman, he's always been neck and neck with manning, with less talent around him. and losman throws out some dud games against good teams, but he would not have been schooled like that at home against the vikings.

        Sure he might struggle, but when he struggled at home, the games were always close. And as bad as he is, he's never thrown 3-4 picks with TD's attached to them.

        Maybe JP's life after buffalo would be best suited in the NFC where he can thrive off beating weak teams.

        Comment

        • Forward_Lateral
          Registered User
          • Mar 2004
          • 29895

          #5
          Re: Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

          Eli is a dolt.

          Comment

          • Mr. Pink
            Peterman Sucks!
            • Mar 2006
            • 35303

            #6
            Re: Is Eli Manning the same as Losman except in a weaker division?

            Eli has good games against quality opposition and has lead the Gints into the playoffs. That's anti-Losman right there.

            End of debate. You can thank me later.

            Comment

            Working...
            X