Vote for Most Recent Bills Draft Bust

[LtBillsFan66]

Who among these three busts is the worst?

JP Losman
Mike Williams
Erik Flowers

[mysticsoto]

This shouldn't even be a contest. Do you know how much we paid Mike Williams as a #4 pick??? And what he produced in comparison? He was never even able to move to LT...

[Ed]

I don't think (at least I hope) that we'll ever have a bigger draft bust then Mike Williams.

[Devin]

Mike Williams no question

[DraftBoy]

Mike Williams

[trapezeus]

i voted JP. We all knew that Mike williams was a bust by season 2 and they were trying to get him help. And to be fair the entire line sucked. but the JP experiment went on for 4 years. no one could get him to step it up to a consistant basis. and now a rookie jumped in and has performed much better.

that's a big bust when you trade multiple picks for the marque position.

[justasportsfan]

not even close. At least JP has helped us win games. MW didn't.

[The King]

Williams was a projected top 5 pick who never materialized into anything.

JP was a mediocre college QB and we took a chance. It didnt work.

[TigerJ]

Granted, the Bills invested more in Mike Williams than the other two, but I think I can make a case that Erik Flowers contributed less to the Bills than Williams or Losman.

[Gunzlingr]

Williams.

Top 5 picks aren't supposed to be out of the league completely in 4 years.

[mybills]

i don't recognize the 1st name on the list. i know they drafted a kid named losman, but who's that guy you listed?

[bigbub2352]

Williams is the biggest bust in the last 10yrs in the NFL, he was a big fat pussy, and now will live the rest of his life a big fat pussy millionare just cause he is huge

[ajsdx]

MW. I almost voted for Flowers just on the basis that he got faked out of his underwear by Chad Pennington, a guy most of the people on this board could bring down one-on-one.

[bigbub2352]

MW. I almost voted for Flowers just on the basis that he got faked out of his underwear by Chad Pennington, a guy most of the people on this board could bring down one-on-one.
that was eddie robinson a brilliant FA move from the TD greg williams area

[RockStar36]

No question. Mike Williams.

[raphael120]

Mike Williams situation ruined our line for years to come (considering we FINALLY have a respectable line now), he ate up more money than JP Losman ever did. But at the same time...who was more to blame for losses? A linemen or a QB?

[TheGhostofJimKelly]

This isn't even close to being a debate, Mike Williams should be the easy and obvious answer.

[jamze132]

Uh... Mike Williams was easily the biggest bust from that list. How can someone that big and talented be such a pussy? You have to have a mean streak to be effective on either line. He was usually one of the biggest guys on the either team to take field yet had the heart of a cowardly lion... or should I say PUSSY cat.

[trapezeus]

i'd like to see Mike Williams on America's biggest loser on NBC. Celebrity biggest loser.

[The Answer]

This shouldn't even be a contest. Do you know how much we paid Mike Williams as a #4 pick??? And what he produced in comparison? He was never even able to move to LT...

Actually it is a contest - we gave up a lot to get Losman - 1st, 2nd and 5th round picks, epsecially when he was considered a 'project' by a lot of scouts and expert analysts.

Now that he is officially busted - at least in Buffalo, it is a much worse than the Mike Williams pick. Also not to defend Donablow - but most other GM's would have taken the unmotivated slob in the top 5 as well given his raw athletic talent.

~The Answer

[mybills]

Williams.

[Jan Reimers]

Flowers was a pansy and Losman a loser, but Williams was a world class weenie.

[Mr. Miyagi]

I still don't think JP is a complete bust. He's certainly not living up to his expectations but he still has something to offer.

Mike Williams couldn't even hold a roster spot on any team.

[billsfanone]

Where is Whitner?

[tat2dmike77]

D) They all equally suck in thier own special way

[Lexwhat]

Depends on what you meant when you asked this question.

Mike Williams was horrible, and a top 5 draft pick. We expected a lot out of him and he didn't deliver.

But I think the JP pick hurt our team more overall.

[SeatownBillsFan21]

As much as id like to say JP he was not the 4th overall pick