Are you ready to write off Trent?

[Ebenezer]

It's a given that TE has looked pretty bad in bad weather. After the last two weeks are you ready to write off TE?

[TacklingDummy]

Are the Browns ready to write off Anderson?

[YardRat]

No way. I'm glad he's getting the experience of playing in bad weather his rookie year, it gives him more experience to build on for the future.

It's much better to suffer through the growing pains right now than three or four years down the road.

[shelby]

HE IS A ROOKIE.

[mybills]

I voted for - No. Way to early to tell if he will be bad or good

I don't care about the weather.

[Jan Reimers]

Trent still looks poised in the pocket. One of his interceptions was the result of Evans' misplay, and he had a few dropped.

He actually played better than Eli Manning, who the Giants are not giving up on.

[Bill Brasky]

:rofl: after two games, as a rookie?! you people are HILARIOUS! :rofl:

[njsue]

Trent Edwards is a "rookie" with a small amount of game experience.

He has shown the ability to make good decisions and put's the ball on the money.

This guy has great potential to be top QB in the NFL.

[Don't Panic]

15-0 right now... as much as people bash him, at least no one's willing to right him off just yet.

[Johnny Bugmenot]

OK, I'll bite. Yes, I've written him off.


HE IS A ROOKIE.

HE IS A CALIFORNIAN!!

[Dr. Lecter]

OK, I'll bite. Yes, I've written him off.



HE IS A CALIFORNIAN!!

So?

Tom Brady is a Californian too.

(Note: Not a comparison folks, calm down.)

[Mahdi]

It's a given that TE has looked pretty bad in bad weather. After the last two weeks are you ready to write off TE?
Not at all.... I think he has all the tools. However he has nothing to work with. Put some real talent around Trent and he will play much better.

[losman420]

uuummmm no......for 1 the guy is a rookie, we are lucky he has played well at all this year, and 2 one of those bad games was in a friggin blizzard, its hard for anyone to play well in those conditions. also i know he played at stanford, but isn't he also a cali native?? He will get better at these kinds of games with exp. I cant believe some people voted yes on this, im glad some of you arn't working as the Bills GM's, because i would like the Bills to find there QB before we lose another decade looking.

[MikeInRoch]

I'm curious who the people who will vote 'yes' are, so I know who I can safely put on ignore and not miss anything.

[Mahdi]

I'm curious who the people who will vote 'yes' are, so I know who I can safely put on ignore and not miss anything.
check the poll results....

[Billzz]

djjimkelly, Johnny Bugmenot, Wys Guy

Should already have them on ignore, not sure you need to make any adjustments.

[paladin warrior]

Let him pratice in the freezer put him in 5 below zero. Until he gets better..

[Bill Brasky]

Let him pratice in the freezer put him in 5 below zero. Until he gets better..

:rofl: wow

[djjimkelly]

djjimkelly, Johnny Bugmenot, Wys Guy

Should already have them on ignore, not sure you need to make any adjustments.


thanks for the support :)

[Mr. Pink]

Let him pratice in the freezer put him in 5 below zero. Until he gets better..

Put a fan in there too, to simulate windchill and breeze...make him throw wads of paper into a trash bin as well!

[feelthepain]

It's a given that TE has looked pretty bad in bad weather. After the last two weeks are you ready to write off TE?

Way, way too early to tell.

[Losman4Life]

Losman is a starting QB and Edwards will never be more than a career 3rd stringer like Todd Collins!

We could have been a playoff team or threatened the pats for the division title if losman started all 16 games like he was supposed to. This coaching staff is the laughing stock of the league right now.

[shelby]

Really? Seems to me that the talk througout the NFL is that Jauron is deserving of COTY honors.

i like Losman but he proved beyond a doubt that he didn't have what it takes to be the starting QB of this team.

It's a dead horse but people keep beating it....

[Losman4Life]

Really? Seems to me that the talk througout the NFL is that Jauron is deserving of COTY honors.

i like Losman but he proved beyond a doubt that he didn't have what it takes to be the starting QB of this team.

It's a dead horse but people keep beating it....

He was a top 10 QB in the league in 2006 and on his way to a probowl season in 2007 before he was benched for a california pansy that can't throw a 3 yard pass in the wind because of his weak noodle arm.

Seriously we are going to be worse shape than the dolphins if we don't cut edwards and give losman another chance.

[shelby]

i disagree, but thanks for sharing your opinion.

[MikeInRoch]

He was ... on his way to a probowl season in 2007 ...

Welcome to the list of posters who post such garbage it's not worth reading.

[DraftBoy]

Not really an answer for the poll that suits me

[justasportsfan]

He was a top 10 QB in the league in 2006 and on his way to a probowl season in 2007.
while I've been hard on the Trent fans, this post is a douche.

[Crisis]

OK, I'll bite. Yes, I've written him off.



HE IS A CALIFORNIAN!!


you know losman is from cali too right

[Losman4Life]

Welcome to the list of posters who post such garbage it's not worth reading.

How do you know what would have happened this year if he played all 16 games? JP has superstar potential and why some of you don't understand that is baffling!

[justasportsfan]

How do you know what would have happened this year if he played all 16 games? JP has superstar potential and why some of you don't understand that is baffling!
now you're trolling.

[MikeInRoch]

How do you know what would have happened this year if he played all 16 games? JP has superstar potential and why some of you don't understand that is baffling!

Because I understand football. Anyone who thinks JP can be a superstar in this league is either dumb, or related to him. Or both.

[Michael82]

Not really an answer for the poll that suits me
That's the best post. I am not ready to write off Trent yet. But I also would like to see a QB drafted next April. I am not sure if he is our QB of the future yet and what I have seen from him in big games, and bad weather games makes me very nervous.

[Johnny Bugmenot]

you know losman is from cali too right

Yes. Edwards has potential if he were to play in a domed stadium, but the weather here is just too much for him and it shows. You know as much as I that Buffalo will never tolerate a dome (even if it does bring the Super Bowl to town).

[Johnny Bugmenot]

How do you know what would have happened this year if he played all 16 games?
Because he played all 16 games last year too and it got us to pretty much the same point we're at now.


JP has superstar potential and why some of you don't understand that is baffling!

So did Jim Druckenmiller and Tommy Maddox... both became superstars... in the XFL. Too bad the XFL doesn't exist anymore.

[Crisis]

Yes. Edwards has potential if he were to play in a domed stadium, but the weather here is just too much for him and it shows. You know as much as I that Buffalo will never tolerate a dome (even if it does bring the Super Bowl to town).

I was mainly talking to the guy who thanked your post :)

[BillsFever21]

I don't have much faith in him. I see him as probably being only average. His first few games he just dumped the ball off which gave him a good completion percentage. The last few games they have him being more aggressive and he can't even complete 50% of his passes and has looked horrible.

I don't have a lot of faith in him but I am not ready to write him off yet. I feel if an opportunity came to pick somebody else up I wouldn't hesitate on it though. That won't happen and the Bills will continue to stick with mediocrity.

[Philagape]

Because I understand football. Anyone who thinks JP can be a superstar in this league is either dumb, or related to him. Or both.

Or trying to be what he thinks is funny

[YardRat]

He was a top 10 QB in the league in 2006 and on his way to a probowl season in 2007 before he was benched for a california pansy that can't throw a 3 yard pass in the wind because of his weak noodle arm.

Seriously we are going to be worse shape than the dolphins if we don't cut edwards and give losman another chance.

:roflmao:

[JD]

:lolpoint: Buff1, cloudycloud, djjimkelly, Johnny Bugmenot, JPFBillsFan, kgun12, Losman4Life, Wys Guy

[Johnny Bugmenot]

:lolpoint:

Is that the best you have? Loser.

[chernobylwraiths]

I voted write him off just for SAG!

It's hilarious!