so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

[djjimkelly]

and its quite funny all the talk about eli being a joke a so on. hes in the bowl now.

i know another qb who draws similar ridiculing. the big difference is burress smith and toomer are probably a combined 2-3 feet taller then our 3 wrs.


on a side note funny how that press attacking D we used to run is going to the bowl in the NFC and that 3-4 we used to run in going on the AFC. long live the cover 2

[The Jokeman]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

and its quite funny all the talk about eli being a joke a so on. hes in the bowl now.

i know another qb who draws similar ridiculing. the big difference is burress smith and toomer are probably a combined 2-3 feet taller then our 3 wrs.


on a side note funny how that press attacking D we used to run is going to the bowl in the NFC and that 3-4 we used to run in going on the AFC. long live the cover 2

The difference is that maligned QB and his team found ways to win and make the playoffs 3 out of the 4 seasons he played. As much as want to support JP I can't deny that TE found ways to win while in there. Yet while I feel teams win and lose games not purely QBs it's hard to argue that we won more then with TE at helm this year then JP.

[Michael82]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

The difference is that maligned QB and his team found ways to win and make the playoffs 3 out of the 4 seasons he played. As much as want to support JP I can't deny that TE found ways to win while in there. Yet while I feel teams win and lose games not purely QBs it's hard to argue that we won more then with TE at helm this year then JP.

It's also hard to argue that we we would have won the same games with JP at the helm, especially when you consider who they were against and the fact that the team was hot at the time.

[jamze132]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl...

[Mitchy moo]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

Making the SB is great, winning it is what's important.

[HHURRICANE]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

i know another qb who draws similar ridiculing. the big difference is burress smith and toomer are probably a combined 2-3 feet taller then our 3 wrs.

Losman has a NFL MVP brother that he can talk to as well? And a dad that played in the NFL? A winning record? The similarities are scary.

[TacklingDummy]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

It's also hard to argue that we we would have won the same games with JP at the helm, especially when you consider who they were against and the fact that the team was hot at the time.

How many times did JP lead the Bills to victory against a team who finsihed the season with a winning record?

[Mr. Pink]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

These Losman threads get stupider and stupider as they go.

[Novacane]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

Didn't you post that you had moved past the Losman thing DJ??

[realdealryan]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

and its quite funny all the talk about eli being a joke a so on. hes in the bowl now.

i know another qb who draws similar ridiculing. the big difference is burress smith and toomer are probably a combined 2-3 feet taller then our 3 wrs.

And the offensive coordinator is better.
And a running game to worry about, thus opening up the pass game.
And a much better front 7 and blitz scheme.


on a side note funny how that press attacking D we used to run is going to the bowl in the NFC and that 3-4 we used to run in going on the AFC. long live the cover 2

Long live personnel-there are plenty of crappy 3-4 teams in the NFL.

[Bill Cody]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

and its quite funny all the talk about eli being a joke a so on. hes in the bowl now.

i know another qb who draws similar ridiculing. the big difference is burress smith and toomer are probably a combined 2-3 feet taller then our 3 wrs.

I say stay the course with JP. At his present rate of development he'll guide us to the bowl in 2039. Maybe sooner if we can draft some NBA players for receivers.

[Mudflap1]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

And who is that wily guy calling the plays for the Giants? Why, what's that you say? Kevin Gilbride!

Guess he wasn't so bad either... we just didn't have the horses

Jon

[realdealryan]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

And who is that wily guy calling the plays for the Giants? Why, what's that you say? Kevin Gilbride!

Guess he wasn't so bad either... we just didn't have the horses

Jon

I don't think he's that bad. I just hope the Giants don't get ahead 35-3 on the Pats...lol

[Mahdi]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

and its quite funny all the talk about eli being a joke a so on. hes in the bowl now.

i know another qb who draws similar ridiculing. the big difference is burress smith and toomer are probably a combined 2-3 feet taller then our 3 wrs.


on a side note funny how that press attacking D we used to run is going to the bowl in the NFC and that 3-4 we used to run in going on the AFC. long live the cover 2

Im not about to say that JP is better or as good as Eli. However I will say this, Eli has been surrounded with top quality talent from day 1. He was given one of the most dominating receivers in the game Plaxico Burress, a talented and reliable veteran who makes plays Amani Toomer, arguably the best TE in the game, a very good OL and has always had great RB play to rely on as well. On top of that he is supported by an excellent defense. JP has had nothing even remotely similar to what Eli has been given.

[DynaPaul]

Re: so i know a giants QB was ridiculed like someone we all know

Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl...

And Rob Johnson has a ring.