Has anyone considered the possibility....

[Mahdi]

... that Devin Thomas WILL be the best player available by the time the Bills pick?

Its not crazy... What if, both Longs, Dorsey, Ellis, Gholston, McKelvin, Jenkins, Harvey, Rivers and McFadden are all gone by the time we pick? Which is what im betting will happen BTW. At that point we will be left with DRC, Ryan, Brandon Albert, Clady, Mendenhall, Merling etc....

IMO that makes Devin Thomas the BPA and completely justifies our pick. Sure some of you will agrue that DRC is the BPA but the only reason that Devin Thomas isnt seen as a top 10 pick is because he only had 1 year of production. If he had 2 years of 79 receptions, 1200 yards and 8 TDs he would be a top 10 candidate. Now the knock on DRC is that he is a small schooler and hasnt played against top competition. Both players have knocks so you cant argue that DRC is the better prospect especially considering his draft stock only took off after the senior bowl week. And then consider that WR is a much bigger need and Thomas becomes the clear-cut favourite.


Just a thought....

[justasportsfan]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

based on need, he would be the BPA for us.

[EDS]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

Beauty is always in the eye of the beholder. Personally, I think if that scenario did in fact come to fruition then the BPA would, in my mind, be either Clady or Albert.

[Mr. Miyagi]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

You're making the assumption that Thomas is the best WR in this class, over Sweed, Kelly, and Hardy.

[Jan Reimers]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

Beauty is always in the eye of the beholder. Personally, I think if that scenario did in fact come to fruition then the BPA would, in my mind, be either Clady or Albert.

I sure hope they can get downfield and catch the ball.

[raphael120]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I think half the battle is figuring out if a WR is worth the 11th pick...the other half is ---- ok...now that we decided a WR IS worth the 11th round pick...which WR is it??? Sweed, Thomas...i could go on and on.

[Mahdi]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

You're making the assumption that Thomas is the best WR in this class, over Sweed, Kelly, and Hardy.

Yes. I think Thomas' versatility is what puts him ahead of the rest. He has the straigh-line speed, hands, size and leaping ability all in one. What I also like is his short area quickness that gives him an edge over any other receiver in the draft. He's also a returner.

[DraftBoy]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I think he's like 20ish on my big board so thats impossible imo.

[Mahdi]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I think he's like 20ish on my big board so thats impossible imo.

Yeah 20ISH.... which means that a lot of teams probably have him rated either higher or lower. Point is... players like Clady, Albert, DRC, Merling, Mendenhall, Ryan are all players that can easily be selected at 15 or lower. Once you get passed the first 10 I mentionned there is really no consensus 11th pick, it could be anyone and IMO teams will be drafting for need after our pick. If you need OL you will have Clady or Albert, if you need RB you have Mendenhall and Stuart, if you need DL you have Merling and Balmer, CB will have DRC, Talib and Cason and WR will have Sweed, Thomas, Kelly and Hardy. It will all depend on how a team values that player.

[baalworship]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

If he is the best receiver in the draft and there is a big drop on what we could get in the 2nd or 3rd then take him.

That's the question though...how much better is Thomas than the 4th or 5th or 6th receiver...

[EDS]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I sure hope they can get downfield and catch the ball.

Wasn't the topic "who is the best player available"? Obviously need is another factor to consider altogether, and equally obviously the Bills have a dire need for help at wide receiver.

[FlyingDutchman]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I just dont get where all this love for Thomas ever came from. Sure he had a productive year, but come on.....

[Ickybaluky]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I don't even think Thomas is the best WR in the draft. He is a #2 WR with a high risk factor.

If he pans out, he could be another Santonio Holmes (which isn't bad). If not, he will be Robert Meacham. Guys like him are boom or bust. They look the part, but you don't know how they will translate to the NFL.

I can think of a number of guys at other positions who I'd take over Thomas because not only do they rate as high but they are far less risky.

Personally, I think every WR in this draft is risky. I don't see guys who are worthy of top-15/20 status. Ultimately, this will be the kind of draft where some WR picked in the 2nd or later will out-perform the guys picked higher. Teams with needs at WR need to take that into consideration.

[DraftBoy]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

I don't even think Thomas is the best WR in the draft. He is a #2 WR with a high risk factor.

If he pans out, he could be another Santonio Holmes (which isn't bad). If not, he will be Robert Meacham. Guys like him are boom or bust. They look the part, but you don't know how they will translate to the NFL.

I can think of a number of guys at other positions who I'd take over Thomas because not only do they rate as high but they are far less risky.

Personally, I think every WR in this draft is risky. I don't see guys who are worthy of top-15/20 status. Ultimately, this will be the kind of draft where some WR picked in the 2nd or later will out-perform the guys picked higher. Teams with needs at WR need to take that into consideration.

While its still to early to write the book on Meacham, I agree with the sentiment. I like would not take a WR in this class before 25 and I have Thomas as my #1 ranked WR, but thats more by default then by skill.

[patmoran2006]

Re: Has anyone considered the possibility....

... that Devin Thomas WILL be the best player available by the time the Bills pick?

Its not crazy... What if, both Longs, Dorsey, Ellis, Gholston, McKelvin, Jenkins, Harvey, Rivers and McFadden are all gone by the time we pick? Which is what im betting will happen BTW. At that point we will be left with DRC, Ryan, Brandon Albert, Clady, Mendenhall, Merling etc....

IMO that makes Devin Thomas the BPA and completely justifies our pick. Sure some of you will agrue that DRC is the BPA but the only reason that Devin Thomas isnt seen as a top 10 pick is because he only had 1 year of production. If he had 2 years of 79 receptions, 1200 yards and 8 TDs he would be a top 10 candidate. Now the knock on DRC is that he is a small schooler and hasnt played against top competition. Both players have knocks so you cant argue that DRC is the better prospect especially considering his draft stock only took off after the senior bowl week. And then consider that WR is a much bigger need and Thomas becomes the clear-cut favourite.


Just a thought....

if that was the scenario, Albert would CLEARLY be the best player available.