Anquan Boldin or Roy Williams

[Marvelous]

After reading the BuffaloNews rumors i was like "eh, that would be sweet, but highly unlikely etc".. But an hour later i saw Adam Shef on Total Access say something similar & confirm all the Buffalo Bills buzz.. WOOHOO it's exciting to hear us get some national media attention...

-Outta the two Wide-Outs I choose Boldin. Boldin reminds me of my all time favorite Bills WR.. I also just saw a show on NFLN about rookies and Boldin was one of em getting the focus. Man he is a R.A.C. beast !!
-He's 27

-Boldin--
-2003 -16 games- 101 catches- 1377 yards- 8 td's
-2004- 10 games - 56 catches 623- yards 1td
-2005- 14 games- 102 catches- 1402 yards- 7 td's
-2006- 16 games- 83 catches- 1203 yards- 4 td's
-2007- 12 games- 71 catches- 853 yards 9 td's
-His stats back up his elite status.

---Roy Williams ---
-He's 26
-2004- 12 games- 54 catches- 817 yards- 8 td's
-2005- 13 games- 45 catches- 687 yards- 8 td's
-2006- 16 games- 82 catches- 1310 yards- 7 td's
-2007- 12 games- 64 catches- 838 yards- 5 td's

-Both players are on pathetic teams that never do squat.
-Both have had the same type caliber QB's. Kitna -vs- Warner/Leinart(sp)
-Boldin has Edge & Larry Fitz..
-Roy doesn't have anything to compliment him..
--But Boldin didn't have anything his rookie season when he busted out for 100+ catches & 1400 yards!!!

-IMO
-Boldin will most likely cost us more. $ and compensation..
--Both teams have anotehr wide out star player. Fitz & Calvin.

---It makes sense to send#11 for either player but i feel undecided about that. Like i'm losing out or overpaying, when we wouldn't be etc..
--Maybe if we could trade down then pull the trigger :grin:

Just curious on two things
-1- Which wide out do you prefer?
-2- odds of happening?

[Slim]

What did Shefter say? i haven't heard anything.

[Michael82]

I would happily give the #11 overall pick to the Detroit Lions for WR Roy Williams! :drool:

[ublinkwescore]

I'd be happy with either one.

Edge hasn't done crap since he's left Indy.

So technically Boldin only has Fitz.

[bigbub2352]

Boldin, but i wouldnt give the 11 overall pick

[PECKERWOOD]

Boldin any day of the week.

[DrGraves]

Boldin, but i wouldnt give the 11 overall pick

Either of these two guys will be way better than any wr we draft at 11 will ever turn out to be.

[Devin]

Ive never liked Roy Williams, a jackass who is playing for stats and cash. A true "me" player. I hope to god that nutsack never makes it onto a Bills team. He had 1 solid season and a bunch of #2 type numbers.

Boldin to me is the best option for this team. Hes a big physical, fearless, mean bastard. He has hands like glue, and when healthy imo is one of the best WRs in the game at his #2 spot. Is easily a top-end starter on any team. By and large he isnt a mouthy guy, and he has always been content to let his play do the talking. Most importantly I think hes the best team guy out the group.

[gr8slayer]

Boldin is the best all-around WR in the NFL.

Roy Williams is overrated.

[justasportsfan]

Depending on who the qb is. Trent, Roy Williams.

[Michael82]

I'm a little surprised in this one. Sure I like Boldin, but he has one of the best WRs across from him in Larry Fitzgerald. He's also extremely injury prone. Roy Williams is a big tall receiver and a stud. I'd take him anyday. :drool:

[Marvelous]

I'd be happy with either one.

Edge hasn't done crap since he's left Indy.

So technically Boldin only has Fitz.

-I thought the same but have you seen Edge's stats bro? I was like "HUH"..
Edge musta quietly put up 1200 because i thought he was similar to the was Emmitt Smith was in Arizona...

-Boldin would rock but i doubt they deal him for anything less then a 1st rounder. And why would they. He OWNS!... I'd take Shockey for our 2nd though :cheer:

--Also,I always wondered what it would be like if Schobel and JT we're on the same line. Not that the Tuna would ever deal with us but.... :drool:

[Devin]

I'm a little surprised in this one. Sure I like Boldin, but he has one of the best WRs across from him in Larry Fitzgerald. He's also extremely injury prone. Roy Williams is a big tall receiver and a stud. I'd take him anyday. :drool:

Roy Williams in 4 seasons (04 to 07)
Catches: 245
Yards: 3,652
TD's: 28
Games: 55
Avg: 14.9

1 1K+ season.

Anquan Boldin in 4 seasons (04 to 07)
Catches: 312
Yards: 4,081
TD's: 21
Games: 52
Avg: 12.8

2 1K+ seasons (his rookie year 2003, he had 1377 yards and 8 TD's for a total of 3 1K+ seasons)

Roy Williams doesnt hold a candle to Boldin, and he doesnt have half the character Boldin does.