NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

**Don't Panic** · 04-29-2008, 12:20 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

A+ for KC. You know it, baby! Albert and Dorsey is an absolute coup. I think the C for Buffalo is a little bit harsh, though. Maybe B-...

Very nice work, DB.

**madness** · 04-29-2008, 12:22 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

At least our "Huh?" pick was a 7th rounder.

**RockStar36** · 04-29-2008, 01:17 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

I think Pittsburgh's "huh" pick is Mendenhall.

**Mahdi** · 04-29-2008, 01:28 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

DB these are your grades?? WTH?

A C for the Bills is very inaccurate even if we dont know how these players will fare. The Bills got the top CB in the draft and were patient enough to wait for arguably the best WR in the draft at 41, addressing their top 2 needs according to most ppl with their first 2 picks and getting great value on top of that. They follow that up with a solid edge rusher that can really thrive in their scheme. Reggie Corner was a surprise pick sure, but if they had him graded ahead of anyone else on their board and their scouting work tells them he can be a solid CB for them down the road then why not??

I just dont understand how you can give a grade of C. In your last mock you had the Bills taking DRC at #11 and Malcolm Kelly at #41. They end up with the better CB and overall the most productive WR to come out this year who also posesses the size they need.

The least is a B+

**DraftBoy** · 04-29-2008, 02:10 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by Mahdi

DB these are your grades?? WTH?

A C for the Bills is very inaccurate even if we dont know how these players will fare. The Bills got the top CB in the draft and were patient enough to wait for arguably the best WR in the draft at 41, addressing their top 2 needs according to most ppl with their first 2 picks and getting great value on top of that. They follow that up with a solid edge rusher that can really thrive in their scheme. Reggie Corner was a surprise pick sure, but if they had him graded ahead of anyone else on their board and their scouting work tells them he can be a solid CB for them down the road then why not??

I just dont understand how you can give a grade of C. In your last mock you had the Bills taking DRC at #11 and Malcolm Kelly at #41. They end up with the better CB and overall the most productive WR to come out this year who also posesses the size they need.

The least is a B+

I disagree and Ive already gone into great length as to why;

DraftBoy's Draft Review - BillsZone.com - Buffalo Bills Fan Zone

http://www.billszone.com/fanzone/showthread.php?t=151611

The remedy for your Bills fever? The best Buffalo Bills forum on the net.

I dont judge a draft based on the top 3 picks, that doesnt impress me...sorry.

**justasportsfan** · 04-29-2008, 02:15 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

So the bills were one of the losers in this draft

**DraftBoy** · 04-29-2008, 02:16 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by justasportsfan

So the bills were one of the losers in this draft

Yep, pretty brutal Day 2 where the good GMs seperate themselves will do that to you. If our Day 2 doesnt pan out in the pivotal draft year we are in big trouble.

**FlyingDutchman** · 04-29-2008, 02:18 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

In any draft you can hope to get two legit starters. We got that, with the two top people on our board. This draft was definately a success. Definately at least a B. Judging anything after round 3 is rediculous and pointless bc its a crap shoot and you cannot usually accurately judge those players until several years removed.

**justasportsfan** · 04-29-2008, 02:18 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by DraftBoy

Yep, pretty brutal Day 2 where the good GMs seperate themselves will do that to you. If our Day 2 doesnt pan out in the pivotal draft year we are in big trouble.

you know this will be revisited in the future.

**DraftBoy** · 04-29-2008, 02:21 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by FlyingDutchman

In any draft you can hope to get two legit starters. We got that, with the two top people on our board. This draft was definately a success. Definately at least a B. Judging anything after round 3 is rediculous and pointless bc its a crap shoot and you cannot usually accurately judge those players until several years removed.

There is no way you can sit here and tell me that Hardy or even McKelvin are sure fire starters at this point. The positions we know would of gotten starters at OC, and TE we didnt address.

**justasportsfan** · 04-29-2008, 02:23 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by FlyingDutchman

In any draft you can hope to get two legit starters. We got that, with the two top people on our board. This draft was definately a success. Definately at least a B. Judging anything after round 3 is rediculous and pointless bc its a crap shoot and you cannot usually accurately judge those players until several years removed.

I have the bills at B.

As for the late rd. picks, if they just make our ST no. 1 again, My grade may move up to A.

**justasportsfan** · 04-29-2008, 02:24 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by DraftBoy

There is no way you can sit here and tell me that Hardy or even McKelvin are sure fire starters at this point. .

the same goes for every player drafted.

**FlyingDutchman** · 04-29-2008, 02:25 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by DraftBoy

There is no way you can sit here and tell me that Hardy or even McKelvin are sure fire starters at this point. The positions we know would of gotten starters at OC, and TE we didnt address.

Um, I think I just did. How are you going to tell me they're not, but you know OC and TE are? LMAO. This is just like last years draft in which was considered a success. Two solid picks, and a 3rd rounder that may contribute. Everything there after only time will tell.

**DraftBoy** · 04-29-2008, 02:26 PM

Re: NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Originally posted by justasportsfan

you know this will be revisited in the future.

Yea it will, but I dont fear that at all. Kiper gave us a C+ while McShay gave us the #1 grade out of the AFCE, neither guy really talked about Day 2.

NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

NFL Team by Team Picks and Grades

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment