Just did my MLB All-Star Ballot

[DraftBoy]

AL:
C-Joe Maurer-MIN
1B-Justin Morneau-MIN
2B-Ian Kinsley-TEX
SS-Bobby Crosby-OAK
3B-Joe Crede-CWS
OF-Josh Hamilton-TEX
OF-Manny Ramirez-BOS
OF-BJ Upton-TB
DH-Hideki Matsui-NYY
Write in: Casey Kotchman-LAA

NL:
C-Brian McCann-ATL
1B-Lance Berkman-HOU
2B-Chase Utley-PHI
SS-Yunel Escobar-ATL
3B-Chipper Jones-ATL
OF-Nate McCloth-PIT
OF-Ryan Braun-MIL
OF-Aaron Rowand-SF
Write in: Albert Pujols-STL

[hydro]

No Indians players! :mad:

[RockStar36]

Which one would you suggest?

[DraftBoy]

No Indians players! :mad:

Id have voted for Lee but they dont let you vote for pitchers...

[hydro]

Without Grady Sizemore this team would be in last place easily. He is the only steady player on this team right now.

[hydro]

Id have voted for Lee but they dont let you vote for pitchers...

Yeah Lee too! He has been better than Sabathia this year...

[DraftBoy]

Without Grady Sizemore this team would be in last place easily. He is the only steady player on this team right now.

Grady hasnt had a better year than Upton, Ramirez, or Hamilton imo.

[hydro]

Grady's batting average is what hurts him.

[LtFinFan66]

AL:
C-Joe Maurer-MIN
1B-Justin Morneau-MIN
2B-Ian Kinsley-TEX
SS-Bobby Crosby-OAK
3B-Joe Crede-CWS
OF-Josh Hamilton-TEX
OF-Manny Ramirez-BOS
OF-BJ Upton-TB
DH-Hideki Matsui-NYY
Write in: Casey Kotchman-LAA

NL:
C-Brian McCann-ATL
1B-Lance Berkman-HOU
2B-Chase Utley-PHI
SS-Yunel Escobar-ATL
3B-Chipper Jones-ATL
OF-Nate McCloth-PIT
OF-Ryan Braun-MIL
OF-Aaron Rowand-SF
Write in: Albert Pujols-STLGood call on McCloth for Pittsburgh....though I would have given X. Nady consideration if he was on there

[RingofFire]

reyes, wright, beltran

[RingofFire]

and ryan church

[Bling]

F- Chase Utley! Dan UggaUggaUggla!

[BADTHINGSMAN]

You missed the DH in the National League..

[DraftBoy]

You missed the DH in the National League..

No I didnt they dont have a choice there in the NL at least not on MLB.com

[DraftBoy]

Good call on McCloth for Pittsburgh....though I would have given X. Nady consideration if he was on there

I thought about Nady but I didnt think he was better than Braun or Rowand, just because Rowand is the only guy in SF that will go to the ASB.

[DraftBoy]

reyes, wright, beltran

Reyes and Wright may make it as backups to the ASB but neither would be a shock if they weren't named either. They are not the leaders of either of their positions and there is absolutely no way Wright beats out Chipper for the 3B spot, not since Chipper is hitting .418 now and could go 0 for his next 75 and still be hitting above .300

[DraftBoy]

F- Chase Utley! Dan UggaUggaUggla!

Dude Utley is a beast, I think Uggla will be the backup though.

[THATHURMANATOR]

AL:
C-Joe Maurer-MIN
1B-Justin Morneau-MIN
2B-Ian Kinsley-TEX
SS-Bobby Crosby-OAK
3B-Joe Crede-CWS
OF-Josh Hamilton-TEX
OF-Manny Ramirez-BOS
OF-BJ Upton-TB
DH-Hideki Matsui-NYY
Write in: Casey Kotchman-LAA

NL:
C-Brian McCann-ATL
1B-Lance Berkman-HOU
2B-Chase Utley-PHI
SS-Yunel Escobar-ATL
3B-Chipper Jones-ATL
OF-Nate McCloth-PIT
OF-Ryan Braun-MIL
OF-Aaron Rowand-SF
Write in: Albert Pujols-STL
The only one I have a problem with is Bobby Crosby.

[THATHURMANATOR]

F- Chase Utley! Dan UggaUggaUggla!
Are you joking? Uggla is good but Utley is the best player going at any position right now.

[DraftBoy]

The only one I have a problem with is Bobby Crosby.

How and Why?

Crosby has a lower average but he leads at SS in 2B and RBI plus OAK has to have a representative.

[THATHURMANATOR]

How and Why?

Crosby has a lower average but he leads at SS in 2B and RBI plus OAK has to have a representative.
Michael Young is batting 306 and has 1 less RBI.

If you are worrying about representing each team I guess but why would you worry about that.

[DraftBoy]

Michael Young is batting 306 and has 1 less RBI.

If you are worrying about representing each team I guess but why would you worry about that.

Because I like to be realistic in my picks and not just pick the top stat guy.

[BlackMetalNinja]

Each team has to have a representative, but not necesarrily a starter.

[RingofFire]

M. Young will and deserves to start in AL

[DraftBoy]

Each team has to have a representative, but not necesarrily a starter.

No doubt, I didnt pick a starter from every team.

[DraftBoy]

M. Young will and deserves to start in AL

Probably, but I went with Crosby for a little variety.

[BADTHINGSMAN]

No I didnt they dont have a choice there in the NL at least not on MLB.com

Thats odd, seeing how the All Star game is in an American League ballpark, and they gave the AL the DH..

[Bling]

Are you joking? Uggla is good but Utley is the best player going at any position right now.

I never said Utley wasn't better. I'm just rooting for the hometown hero.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Because I like to be realistic in my picks and not just pick the top stat guy.
what is unrealistic about picking better player. Michael Young is twice the player Bobby Crosby is stats or not. :shakeno:

[THATHURMANATOR]

I never said Utley wasn't better. I'm just rooting for the hometown hero.
Oh well that is perfectly fine and Uggla is definitely an Allstar. Just not starting.

[RockStar36]

I never said Utley wasn't better. I'm just rooting for the hometown hero.

Until he gets traded for 7 prospects next off-season.

[RingofFire]

Probably, but I went with Crosby for a little variety. Or just to be different so if you're wrong no big deal it's the popular pick but if correct you can brag i told you so! Ego