The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

[OpIv37]

The answer is "neither."

Not only has Trent failed to protect the ball for the last 3 1/2 games, but he has no timing and he's very JP-like in the way he stays in the pocket.

Seriously, even though I was skeptical about this team during the fast start, I was almost sold on Edwards. But now I feel like we're back in the Johnson/Bledsoe/Losman days. Every time he drops back, I just hope something bad doesn't happen. Incompletions bring a sigh of relief.

The Buffalo Bills: QB-free for 10 years!

[X-Era]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

The answer is "neither."

Not only has Trent failed to protect the ball for the last 3 1/2 games, but he has no timing and he's very JP-like in the way he stays in the pocket.

Seriously, even though I was skeptical about this team during the fast start, I was almost sold on Edwards. But now I feel like we're back in the Johnson/Bledsoe/Losman days. Every time he drops back, I just hope something bad doesn't happen. Incompletions bring a sigh of relief.

The Buffalo Bills: QB-free for 10 years!

I painfully, sadly, agree.

And Im back in the yearf-after-AVP-mode... if not our current QB than whom?

I think our draft just became WAY clearer. We have a big need, and maybe the biggest need of all... QB!

[OpIv37]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

it's frustrating because the two most disrupting changes for a team are coach and QB. And right now, we have question marks at both.

[Chimpanze]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

I disagree!!!

GET OVER IT,,, JP IS DONE with the BILLS!

Trent is NOW! I know he is playing scared but TOO BAD! That is how it is so support him instead of complaining.

[DMBcrew36]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

The verdict is still out on Trent.

But we all know Trent > JP.

[Chimpanze]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Great quote by Dick Jauron...

Trent is young and we are living by his mistakes now!

EXACTLY, about the only good thing from DJ

[Philagape]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Trent is still young. 1 and a half seasons isn't enough to know.
He handled the first phase of his career very well, and he deserves to see if he can take the next step, to get the chance that JP got (and which I supported).

[OpIv37]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Great quote by Dick Jauron...

Trent is young and we are living by his mistakes now!

EXACTLY, about the only good thing from DJ

what if he never gets over the mistakes, like all the QB's the Bills have had for the last decade?

We waste 2 or 3 more seasons on him. Lynch Evans, Peters, McGee, Greer, Jackson, etc all get old or leave via FA, and we're right back where we were 2 years ago.

[Luisito23]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Draft another QB in the 1st. round and let them compete in training camp!

[gr8slayer]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Funny I was saying the same thing all last year.

[Mad Max]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Trent is still young. 1 and a half seasons isn't enough to know.
He handled the first phase of his career very well, and he deserves to see if he can take the next step, to get the chance that JP got (and which I supported).

Maybe he deserves more time. But not much more.

Look no further than todays opposing QB. Who would you rather have for the future? How about Matt Ryan? How much experience does he have?

I personally am not a "he's gotta have a cannon and chuck it deep or I don't want him" kind of fan, BUT if my QB can't EVER chuck it deep, then that's a problem, a huge one. You gotta keep defenses honest.

[Philagape]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Maybe he deserves more time. But not much more.

Look no further than todays opposing QB. Who would you rather have for the future? How about Matt Ryan? How much experience does he have?

I personally am not a "he's gotta have a cannon and chuck it deep or I don't want him" kind of fan, BUT if my QB can't EVER chuck it deep, then that's a problem, a huge one. You gotta keep defenses honest.

He's chucked it deep before.
And maybe Quinn and Ryan are better. I have a feeling they'll have growing pains too

[Historian]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Im regretting not making a serious play for Farve now....

[TacklingDummy]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Funny, JP gets 31 games as starter, Trent only gets 19 before some of you write him off. Pathetic.

[TacklingDummy]

Re: The Losman/Edwards debate is officially over

Im regretting not making a serious play for Farve now....

The Bills need more than just better play from the QB position.

Farve wouldn't help the Bills pass rush.