Worst Bills QB last 10 years?

[hammerbillsfan]

Since Edwards is stinking up the joint right now adding to the decade of QB debacles, which one is the worst to you?

:feedback:

[shelby]

That's like deciding who's the tallest midget.....

[hammerbillsfan]

That's like deciding who's the tallest midget.....

have you won any contests lately? :snicker:

[trapezeus]

need more time before i answer. losman's stretch is more recent and his cost was pretty heavy. Johnson was expensive with one first round pick, but you got the sense that even the team hated him. so it was kind of fun to hate him.

[TacklingDummy]

:monkeyp: Polls that are not public

[RockStar36]

It's a tough call but I'm going with Holcomb. I don't think I ever truly liked that guy and never felt like he was going to take the team anywhere.

[PECKERWOOD]

I'm part of the younger generation of Bills fans, I started watching the Bills play in our first SB against the NYG so I can't speak about any QB's before then but isn't this pretty much a no-brainer? Rob Johnson has to be the most hated player to ever suit up for the Bills. BTW, Bledsoe doesn't belong anywhere near that list, he's been our BEST QB since Kelly retired.

[cocamide]

How could it not be Rob Johnson? He sucked, was an *******, and didn't seem to like Buffalo very much.

[hammerbillsfan]

:monkeyp: Polls that are not public

:cry:

[RockStar36]

I'm not saying RJ was better than Holcomb but I can't draw the conclusion that Holcomb was better either.

[TacklingDummy]

Is there any wonder why the Bills have sucked the past 10 years?

[bigbub2352]

RJ was a loser the moment he arrived here, Losman cost us alot so he is a close second in my book
Holocomb and AVP were suppossed to be backups and they both sucked as well

[RockStar36]

Flutie isn't included on this list. Interesting :scratch:

[Ebenezer]

Compared to some of the QBs of the late 60s and early 80s those guys are all pros.

[Mudflap1]

I said Van Pelt because he was never really starter material at all. The rest are all about the same right now, IMO. However, at least Bledsoe had a Pro Bowl season here, so I don't think anyone should vote for him. Losman's pretty mediocre, Johnson was very mediocre, and Edwards has been pretty mediocre.

Jon

[trapezeus]

RJ was a loser the moment he arrived here, Losman cost us alot so he is a close second in my book
Holocomb and AVP were suppossed to be backups and they both sucked as well

RJ actually played well in the last playoff game the bills were in. he drove them down the field methodically for the go ahead score.

he still sucked and held the ball too long and never embraced the area, but had he won that game, perhaps the flutie/johnson debate that tore the team apart would have been more clear.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Gotta be Van Pelt. He was a great guy but had 0 talent.

[RockStar36]

RJ actually played well in the last playoff game the bills were in. he drove them down the field methodically for the go ahead score.

he still sucked and held the ball too long and never embraced the area, but had he won that game, perhaps the flutie/johnson debate that tore the team apart would have been more clear.

He did part of that drive with one shoe too. For some reason I always remember that drive.

[RockStar36]

Gotta be Van Pelt. He was a great guy but had 0 talent.

Good thing he is a coach now!

[PECKERWOOD]

AVP atleast had some vigor about him! Atleast he could scramble around and avoid pressure, unlike Robosack.

[djjimkelly]

while edwards performance sunday night was worst ive seen in many many years...


kelly homobum is the worst qb we have had to endure

[gr8slayer]

Few have been as over-hyped by the fan base as Edwards and Losman. I have to go with Holcomb, he helped kill what Losman could have been.

[The Jokeman]

I'd have to go with either RJ or JP. I'm leading toward JP as think if RJ was at least able to maintain his health there's was a chance he could of developed into an average/slightly above average QB.

[Mitchell55]

while edwards performance sunday night was worst ive seen in many many years...


kelly homobum is the worst qb we have had to endure



Id say Losman because when holcolmb was here he had over a 79 rating, 67 cpt, and 10 TDs. He was basically a old slow Trent. Id say that JPs game vs the Pats was the worst game ever endured by a bills QB.

[Thurmal]

Do most of you even remember Van Pelt? He ran the most anemic, impotent offense in the world! My God, if that guy scored 20 points in a game (which I'm not sure he ever did), it was borderline miraculous.

[Dozerdog]

That's like deciding who's the tallest midget.....Flutie isn't a selection, Shelb!

[Bert102176]

why is BJ Hobert not on that list that guy was an idiot

[Bert102176]

but out of all those QB's I blame the OL

[SABURZFAN]

That's like deciding who's the tallest midget.....


nobody has topped Flutie in that category.

[mybills]

RJ & Bledsoe

[Mad Bomber]

Since Edwards is stinking up the joint right now adding to the decade of QB debacles, which one is the worst to you?

:feedback:

All of the above.

As Op said in a post earlier this week:

"The Buffalo Bills....QB-free for 10 years."