(1.) Everything. (2.) A total housecleaning.
Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Collapse
X
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Well, the answer is that it wont come cheap and we cant be conservative
QB- Trent may or may not be the answer we dont know. The mere fact that he is so up and down directly leads to wins and losses. If you want to be a playoff team, you cant afford that type of situation.The right move: Draft a QB and sign a vet who can win games for us. A guy like Garcia would be nice. In the draft guys like Harrell, McCoy, maybe StaffordRB- Just fine IMO.
The Bills likely move: Sign a vet like Charlie Fry or Kyle Boller who wont cost them much of anything but who they can try to argue that has upside still. Then probably not draft a QB at all.
WR- Has anyone seen James Hardy? Im just wondering if we didnt screw ourselves yet again with a 2nd round WR (Josh Reed). The really sick part is that Josh Reed actually looks good these days. Well, hes not getting younger and were not getting better at WR. The thought was that we needed an upgrade at #2 WR spot if we all remember. That mission has failed so far.The right move: Sign someone like TJ Houshmazilly. He helps us day one, is a true playmaker, and will demand to be covered.TE- Royal has played better, Schouman has made some plays as has Fine. But none of them is the Antonio Gates type player, nor the Jason Witten type. These type of playmakers force the D to respect them and make everyone elses lives easier.
The Bills Likely move: Probably not do muc of anything at WR feeling that Hardy will get better and Reed is good enough.
The right move: Draft a guy who can play day one, and probably start mid season. Pick your type whether it be the massive blocker who can catch or the speedy, receiver who can sometimes block. Gresham, Pettigrew, Coffman, Cook, all can play and any of them can help us.OL- The have played well and not so well. The current lineup is the best temporary solution with Preston at the C spot. Unfortunately, that still leaves us weak-ish at RG and Preston is set to be a FA.
The likely Bills move- Either to skip the position in the draft all together or to draft someone late or sign the next Courtney Anderson.
The right move: Draft a C in the mid-rounds and probably a G. Guys like Caldwell, Shipley, or Wood would be good. At G finding guys like Herman Johnson would be niceDL- We dont have a single DE that is a true playmaker, not one. We also dont have much depth at DT. We simply cant win playoff games (if we ever get there) without a pass rush. Hell, we probably will never beat the Pats either.
The Bills move: Draft a C in round 7 who will keep that spot mediocre will into the future.
The right move- make it a priority to get the sack artist playmaker at DE that we have needed for a decade. Signing Peppers would be ideal but the draft is more likely. GUys like Selvie, Hardy, Johnson, Brown all could be just what we need.LB- Crowell screwed us hard, thats for sure. Mitchell has been sketchy too often for being such a highly touted FA signee. If we dont get better at LB we will continue to be eaten alive in the 10-20 yard seems and over the middle. Poz is a great you talent, but he cant do it alone.
The Bills move- I think they actually address this in the offseason. It probably will be a draftee and may even be an early pick. But they probably screw it up with some "high motor" type who doesnt have the sacks to go with his motor.
The right move- sign a guy like Terrell Suggs who makes a huge impact at OLB and on the pass rush. Or, draft someone like Curry who looks like he has the potential to be very good. I wouldnt even mind kicking Poz to OLB and drafting a guy like Lauranitis, Brandon Spikes.CB- I think were getting better here even though it looks like were getting worse with Greer out. McKelvin is learning on the field. Weeve seen with Clements, and Winfield that it just takes time and ifthe talent is there, they will become plenty good enough.
The Bills move- They probably go and draft a young guy, and may even gert one that helps us right away.
The right move- Resign Greer, let McKelvin compete with him. I would also resign Youbouty who has shown he about ready to be trusted to make some plays, just not be one of the outside CB's.S- Without Whitner, were hurting. Simpson can play but only sometimes. I still havent seen much from this group in terms of covering the part of the field they are responsible for.
The Bills likely move- Let Greer and Youbouty both walk feeling that Corner and McKelvin will be fine. Then draft a 7th round CB like this years Cox to develop.
The right move- draft guys who can hit like trucks and have the speed to cover lots of ground. Guys like Moore, Harris, Rolle, or Mays make a ton of sense.ST- LIndell has been reliable, but he screwed us this last game. I guess after 53 in a row or whatever, hes entitled to make a few mistakes.
The Bills move- probably nothing. They keep Scott and continue to bank on Simpson. They probably resign Wilson.
The right move- probably stay the course. Add a few speedy guys who can tackle. Consider replacing Neil, adding a LB or two with speed like Casillas.Coaching- IM onthe fence on Jauron. I think he manages to get alot out of his talent for the most part. But he screws up too many game day decisions and he doesnt show the leadership to get his tream to turn it around during games. The OC and DC I wouldnt mind jettisoning. But considering the years it will take to get a new offennse installed and working, Id rather just force our OC to to make better calls.
The Bills move- they probably get it right
The right move- Go get a guy like the chin who will force the team to win and get a winning spirit.Front office- Its a joke IMO. and yes that includes Ralph.
The Bills move- stick with Jauron
The right move- get Golisano, which will only happen if Ralph passes. Get rid of Brandon. Bring in a young, proven GM.
The Bills move- stay the course, which happens to be heading us to end up completely lost.
-
👍 3
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Originally posted by Jan ReimersReally good start.
I can blame players for games
I can blame coaches for a year
I can blame a GM for a few years
But I can only blame an owner for decades
-
👍 2
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
[quote=EdwardsEra]Well, the answer is that it wont come cheap and we cant be conservative
QB- Trent may or may not be the answer we dont know. The mere fact that he is so up and down directly leads to wins and losses. If you want to be a playoff team, you cant afford that type of situation.The right move: Draft a QB and sign a vet who can win games for us. A guy like Garcia would be nice. In the draft guys like Harrell, McCoy, maybe StaffordRB- Just fine IMO.
The Bills likely move: Sign a vet like Charlie Fry or Kyle Boller who wont cost them much of anything but who they can try to argue that has upside still. Then probably not draft a QB at all.
WR- Has anyone seen James Hardy? Im just wondering if we didnt screw ourselves yet again with a 2nd round WR (Josh Reed). The really sick part is that Josh Reed actually looks good these days. Well, hes not getting younger and were not getting better at WR. The thought was that we needed an upgrade at #2 WR spot if we all remember. That mission has failed so far.The right move: Sign someone like TJ Houshmazilly. He helps us day one, is a true playmaker, and will demand to be covered.TE- Royal has played better, Schouman has made some plays as has Fine. But none of them is the Antonio Gates type player, nor the Jason Witten type. These type of playmakers force the D to respect them and make everyone elses lives easier.
The Bills Likely move: Probably not do muc of anything at WR feeling that Hardy will get better and Reed is good enough.
The right move: Draft a guy who can play day one, and probably start mid season. Pick your type whether it be the massive blocker who can catch or the speedy, receiver who can sometimes block. Gresham, Pettigrew, Coffman, Cook, all can play and any of them can help us.
incredible post. good work. best one I've seen in a whileI came.
I saw.
I conquered.
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Good thread Jan, lol, and nice reply edwardsera.
1. Sign Peppers
2. Re-sign Jackson and hopefully Greer.
3. Get me a FS, I'll take Mike Brown
4. Draft me a LB round 1
5. Draft me a TE round 2
6. Draft me a center Round 3
7. Draft me a FB round 4.
8. Oh, and get a real coach.
That's it. I think adding 1 or 2 FA and re-signing a FA or 2 are fairly modest wants. One friggin' guy, one frigging good DE, could make all the difference."Heck, now I am glad his overrated arce made the pro bowl, else we would have only got a 3rd." ~ yordad
"I've just been hit with a piece of sky. " ~ yordad
"Forgive my opinion, but...." ~ yordad
"Warning: I might be hammered." ~ yordad
"I don't care if the word is "your" or "you're", so buzz off. Its (it's) a frickin(') message board." ~ yordad
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Originally posted by yordadGood thread Jan, lol, and nice reply edwardsera.
1. Sign Peppers
2. Re-sign Jackson and hopefully Greer.
3. Get me a FS, I'll take Mike Brown
4. Draft me a LB round 1
5. Draft me a TE round 2
6. Draft me a center Round 3
7. Draft me a FB round 4.
8. Oh, and get a real coach.
That's it. I think adding 1 or 2 FA and re-signing a FA or 2 are fairly modest wants. One friggin' guy, one frigging good DE, could make all the difference.
Anyways, Peppers would be ideal. Hes going toget the tag. Terrell Suggs supposedly isnt. He would fix both the pass rush and fill a OLB spot. Theres draft prospects that might do it but we will have to see.
LB- agree, TE- agree, C- agree, FB? OK maybe. I still would go after a G, a backup ILB, and another CB.
I think the key is to make significant upgrades to the team. Late round draftees are not significant upgrades, thats more of the same. Nor is signing second tier guys.
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Originally posted by jerhwtI'd like to see us go get a guy like James Laurinaitis from Ohio State at LB
I like it but only if we think Poz can play outside or if we switch to the 3-4.
Switching to the 3-4 would make way much more sense. Our O would get a ton of reps against it and learn how to beat it, we could play to the strength of the draft which is at ILB rather than OLB. And we could go after someone like Orakpo
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Yes a FB. It is the 11th position, and ours sees a good amount of time on the field.
I think we have to do something with the 11th position. Either play w 2 TEs, 3 WRs, or 2 half backs every time... or get a FB that is good and versatile.
I mean, who do you want on the field... Schouman, Fred Jackson, Hardy, Johnson, Parrish.... or McIntyre? I would rather see Kirk Chambers as the 11th guy rather then a crappy FB.
We are practicality fielding 10 guys. Mc probably gets in the way more then he paves one.
I would like to see one that is not only an adequate blocker (run and pass), but one who is an adequate dump-pass-catcher and 2-yard-pounder.
I mean, what the heck is Omon doing? If he converted, he wouldn't be the smallest FB in the league. The NFL has to have added some weight to him too.
Anyways, FB has been as neglected as TE. Either stop playing one, or get one."Heck, now I am glad his overrated arce made the pro bowl, else we would have only got a 3rd." ~ yordad
"I've just been hit with a piece of sky. " ~ yordad
"Forgive my opinion, but...." ~ yordad
"Warning: I might be hammered." ~ yordad
"I don't care if the word is "your" or "you're", so buzz off. Its (it's) a frickin(') message board." ~ yordad
-
👍 1
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Originally posted by yordadYes a FB. It is the 11th position, and ours sees a good amount of time on the field.
I think we have to do something with the 11th position. Either play w 2 TEs, 3 WRs, or 2 half backs every time... or get a FB that is good and versatile.
I mean, who do you want on the field... Schouman, Fred Jackson, Hardy/Johnson/Parrish.... or McIntyre? I would rather see Kirk Chambers as the 11th guy rather then a crappy FB.
We are practicality fielding 10 guys. Mc probably get in the way more then he paves one.
I would like to see one that is not only an adequate blocker (run and pass), but one who is an adequate dump-pass-catcher and 2-yard-pounder.
I mean, what the heck is Omon doing? If he converted, he wouldn't be the smallest FB in the league. The NFL has to have added some weight.
Anyways, FB has been as neglected as TE. Either stop playing one, or get one.
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Originally posted by Jan Reimers(1.) Everything. (2.) A total housecleaning.
This may sound REALLY callous, but we need Ralph to die and get new ownership.
New ownership, who completely changes our front office, is the only "housecleaning" that we'll ever get.
I feel bad about the Ralph dying thing, but lets face it....this guy is 2 years younger than my dad. My dad could do a better job with this team than Ralph has....
...trust me....he tells me that all the time.
-
👍 2
Comment
-
-
Re: Whats wrong? How do we fix this?
Originally posted by EdwardsEraI actually tried to post my long text but it got screwed up and never posted the text.
Anyways, Peppers would be ideal. Hes going toget the tag. Terrell Suggs supposedly isnt. He would fix both the pass rush and fill a OLB spot. Theres draft prospects that might do it but we will have to see.
LB- agree, TE- agree, C- agree, FB? OK maybe. I still would go after a G, a backup ILB, and another CB.
I think the key is to make significant upgrades to the team. Late round draftees are not significant upgrades, thats more of the same. Nor is signing second tier guys.
Comment
-
Comment