If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • OpIv37
    Acid Douching Asswipe
    • Sep 2002
    • 101255

    If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

    The best we're going to get is draft picks. We've already cut/failed to resign 4 offensive linemen from last year and only signed one. Trading away a proven, Pro Bowl player for completely unproven draft picks is a sure sign of rebuilding.

    This team isn't even close.
    MiKiDo Facebook
    MiKiDo Website
  • realdealryan
    realdealrex
    • Nov 2005
    • 1838

    #2
    Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

    The Steelers let all of their proven linemen go. They won the Super Bowl. This is a copycat league. lol

    Comment

    • BillsWin
      man amongst boys
      • Oct 2008
      • 6025

      #3
      Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

      We wont win untill Jauron is gone anyways.
      I am The Batman.

      Comment

      • Goobylal
        Registered User
        • Jan 2004
        • 19370

        #4
        Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

        Good post. I was going to ask Op to name the starting LT's for the Steelers and Cards, if not the Eagles and Ravens.

        Comment

        • SeatownBillsFan21
          Registered User
          • Mar 2004
          • 2149

          #5
          Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

          We would be rebuilding our o line i agree to that at least

          Comment

          • X-Era
            What this generation tolerates, the next generation will embrace
            • Feb 2005
            • 27670

            #6
            Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

            Originally posted by OpIv37
            The best we're going to get is draft picks. We've already cut/failed to resign 4 offensive linemen from last year and only signed one. Trading away a proven, Pro Bowl player for completely unproven draft picks is a sure sign of rebuilding.

            This team isn't even close.
            I agree that we get worse the day we make that trade... and to be honest, I would say we are worse than last year BEFORE this move.

            Dockery-cut, no replacement, downgrade
            Fowler/Preston- gone, Hangartner signed, push at this point
            Losman- gone, Fitz signed, likely push
            Crowell- gone, no replacement, downgrade
            TO- signed, upgrade
            Trade Peters- rookie replacement, almost assuredly a downgrade in year one

            That's 3 downgrades, 2 pushes, and one upgrade for next year... We have a TON of work left for the draft and signings if we have any hope of being actually better than last year.

            Comment

            • Goobylal
              Registered User
              • Jan 2004
              • 19370

              #7
              Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

              Originally posted by EdwardsEra
              I agree that we get worse the day we make that trade... and to be honest, I would say we are worse than last year BEFORE this move.

              Dockery-cut, no replacement, downgrade
              Fowler/Preston- gone, Hangartner signed, push at this point
              Losman- gone, Fitz signed, likely push
              Crowell- gone, no replacement, downgrade
              TO- signed, upgrade
              Trade Peters- rookie replacement, almost assuredly a downgrade in year one

              That's 3 downgrades, 2 pushes, and one upgrade for next year... We have a TON of work left for the draft and signings if we have any hope of being actually better than last year.
              Dockery, Preston, and Fowler were scrubs. Getting rid of them was addition by subtraction. And while the Bills have no LG as of yet, they could literally find anyone and he could do as well as Dockery did the past 2 years, for 1/4 the price. And Hangartner is a better player than Preston and Fowler.

              Comment

              • Forward_Lateral
                Registered User
                • Mar 2004
                • 29897

                #8
                Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                Honestly, do you guys remember how bad Peters was last year? Is losing him really going to make this year's oline worse than last years? A 5th round rookie could've played as well as Jason did last season.

                If Philly does something stupid and offers 2 first round picks for Peters, Buffalo would be nuts not to take it.

                Comment

                • Dr. Lecter
                  Zero for Zero!
                  • Mar 2003
                  • 67938

                  #9
                  Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                  It is taking a possible Peters trade to make you realize that the team is rebuilding?
                  Originally posted by mysticsoto
                  Lecter is right in everything he said.

                  Comment

                  • X-Era
                    What this generation tolerates, the next generation will embrace
                    • Feb 2005
                    • 27670

                    #10
                    Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                    Originally posted by Goobylal
                    Dockery, Preston, and Fowler were scrubs. Getting rid of them was addition by subtraction. And while the Bills have no LG as of yet, they could literally find anyone and he could do as well as Dockery did the past 2 years, for 1/4 the price. And Hangartner is a better player than Preston and Fowler.
                    1) Addition and subtraction are polar. Until someone comes in and plays better, we are worse... a crappy body is better than no body.

                    2) If you think that anyone can start at LG for us and play better than Dockery you are sadly mistaken. Maybe you forgot about guys like:

                    Lawrence Smith
                    Tutan Reyes
                    Joe Panos
                    Bennie Anderson

                    EESSHHH!!!

                    Comment

                    • zone
                      No, look. I do mind. The Dude minds.
                      • Oct 2003
                      • 2535

                      #11
                      Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                      Honestly our line played it's best games last year without Peters.

                      The Buffalo Bills made Jason Peters and they can just as quickly give him away.
                      www.blzbus.com

                      Comment

                      • Goobylal
                        Registered User
                        • Jan 2004
                        • 19370

                        #12
                        Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                        Originally posted by EdwardsEra
                        1) Addition and subtraction are polar. Until someone comes in and plays better, we are worse... a crappy body is better than no body.

                        2) If you think that anyone can start at LG for us and play better than Dockery you are sadly mistaken. Maybe you forgot about guys like:

                        Lawrence Smith
                        Tutan Reyes
                        Joe Panos
                        Bennie Anderson

                        EESSHHH!!!
                        Yes I remember them. They were as good (or more precisely, as bad) as Dockery was, which was my point. The Bills haven't had a good LG since Ruben Brown.

                        Comment

                        • OpIv37
                          Acid Douching Asswipe
                          • Sep 2002
                          • 101255

                          #13
                          Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                          Originally posted by Goobylal
                          Good post. I was going to ask Op to name the starting LT's for the Steelers and Cards, if not the Eagles and Ravens.
                          You can't go into a season with ZERO proven linemen. Well, 1- I'll give you Walker.

                          Seriously, what the hell is wrong with this place?

                          Last year, everyone was talking about how the line would be so much better since it was the same and they had time to "gel."

                          Now, they completely broke down the line and you guys are trying to say "Well some other team from some other year with some other players did it, so we can do it too." It's nonsense- you can't have it both ways.

                          BTW- every team you mentioned except the Cards has been consistently good for 10+ years. Translation: their FO's know how to find talent. Ours doesn't.
                          MiKiDo Facebook
                          MiKiDo Website

                          Comment

                          • OpIv37
                            Acid Douching Asswipe
                            • Sep 2002
                            • 101255

                            #14
                            Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                            Originally posted by Forward_Lateral
                            Honestly, do you guys remember how bad Peters was last year? Is losing him really going to make this year's oline worse than last years? A 5th round rookie could've played as well as Jason did last season.

                            If Philly does something stupid and offers 2 first round picks for Peters, Buffalo would be nuts not to take it.
                            Go back and watch the games. Peters struggled in his first few games back, no doubt- but other than that, people point to a handful of plays to say Peters sucked, some of which weren't actually his fault and some of which were meaningless. For example, he shut down Porter for two games except for one garbage time sack (the safety was Dockery's fault).

                            Do you really want Rookie-Question Mark-Hangartner-Butler-Walker protecting Trent? That's insane.
                            MiKiDo Facebook
                            MiKiDo Website

                            Comment

                            • Mad Bomber
                              Registered User
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 12927

                              #15
                              Re: If the Bills trade Peters, it means we're still rebuilding

                              Originally posted by OpIv37
                              Seriously, what the hell is wrong with this place?
                              We're NUMB.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X