Peters trade proposal

[Bmax]

The Bills trade to Philly

Philly gets - Bills 1st (11 th pick )
Jason Peters and a 5th rd pick

From Philly-

Buffalo gets

Eagles two 1st rd picks-21and 28
2nd-53-overall-(Philly)
3rd rd -85 pick overall
and 5th rd pick
157 overall.

we would then have two 1st two 2nd two thirdsa fourth and two fifth's

Thoughts


Bmax

[SeatownBillsFan21]

I would go for that in a heartbeat

[clumping platelets]

They need to add a player like OL Gilles

[SABURZFAN]

The Bills trade to Philly

Philly gets - Bills 1st (11 th pick )
Jason Peters and a 5th rd pick

From Philly-

Buffalo gets

Eagles two 1st rd picks-21and 28
2nd-53-overall-(Philly)
3rd rd -85 pick overall
and 5th rd pick
157 overall.

we would then have two 1st two 2nd two thirdsa fourth and two fifth's

Thoughts


Bmax


no thanks. i don't know what draft value numbers are for 11, 21, and 28 but 21 and 28 have to be near 11. that leaves Peters for a 2nd, 3rd, and 5th. that is nowhere near enough.

[Michael82]

Interesting idea... but that isn't enough for BOTH our 1st rounder and Peters. They better throw in an OL or something.

[clumping platelets]

I want #21 but will settle for #28

conditional 2010 that can be as high as a #2 but no lower than a 5th. 5th is definite and a 4th is easily achieved

I also want a player that can help fill one of the holes on the team. I prefer OLB/DE Cocong (with #28) but want #21 if the player is OL Gilles

[Michael82]

I want a 1st and a 3rd. Or I'd also be happy with a 1st and a good player that can fill one of our many holes.

[jamze132]

Nah. I would give up Peters to Philly for there 1st (21) and 2nd rounders. I would send them Peters and a 5th.

[Canadian'eh!]

The Bills trade to Philly

Philly gets - Bills 1st (11 th pick )
Jason Peters and a 5th rd pick

From Philly-

Buffalo gets

Eagles two 1st rd picks-21and 28
2nd-53-overall-(Philly)
3rd rd -85 pick overall
and 5th rd pick
157 overall.

we would then have two 1st two 2nd two thirdsa fourth and two fifth's

Thoughts


Bmax


pass.

The value chart #'s for #21 and #28 are about 1450.

all 5 of the picks from Philly are worth roughly 2000.

#11 is worth 1250 alone. So it's like trading Peters straight up for the #28 pick basically.

They would have to add a player to that deal to work...

I don't think you get 2 1's for Peters... but 21 and 85 would be close.

I think it's more valuable to hold out for that sort of deal than to give up the #11 just to get the 28 and 53.

[X-Era]

The Bills trade to Philly

Philly gets - Bills 1st (11 th pick )
Jason Peters and a 5th rd pick

From Philly-

Buffalo gets

Eagles two 1st rd picks-21and 28
2nd-53-overall-(Philly)
3rd rd -85 pick overall
and 5th rd pick
157 overall.

we would then have two 1st two 2nd two thirdsa fourth and two fifth's

Thoughts


Bmax

IF we traded Peters, which I dont want, yes... I would do that.

I would do it for less. Peters and our 11 for their 2 1sts and their 2nd would be all I need.

[Yasgur's Farm]

I see it as an 810 value point swing... That's the same as #21.

But... The additional quality picks (3) is huge to a team like Buffalo... We need to fill holes.

[WeAreArthurMoates]

Give me one of there guards and we gotta a deal.

[Pinkerton Security]

idk, im not sure if I wanna give up #11 in the deal, because I personally am hell-bent on getting a pass rusher there, either maybin, orakpo or perhaps brown.

[THATHURMANATOR]

I would go for that in a heartbeat
I wouldn't. Why trade a pro bowl tackle AND the 11th for two late firsts?

[justasportsfan]

no thanks

[Mahdi]

The Bills trade to Philly

Philly gets - Bills 1st (11 th pick )
Jason Peters and a 5th rd pick

From Philly-

Buffalo gets

Eagles two 1st rd picks-21and 28
2nd-53-overall-(Philly)
3rd rd -85 pick overall
and 5th rd pick
157 overall.

we would then have two 1st two 2nd two thirdsa fourth and two fifth's

Thoughts


Bmax
The whole problem with this idea is that we lose out on the Top OTs and the top DEs... Ayers, Brown, Orakpo, Maybin will all be gone by 21. Same for A.Smith and Oher.

[OpIv37]

Stocking up on draft picks is a sure sign of rebuilding, plus this FO sucks at drafting.

Trading Peters is dumb. A trade that doesn't bring a proven player to Buffalo is even more idiotic.

[User Manuel]

The Bills trade to Philly

Philly gets - Bills 1st (11 th pick )
Jason Peters and a 5th rd pick

From Philly-

Buffalo gets

Eagles two 1st rd picks-21and 28
2nd-53-overall-(Philly)
3rd rd -85 pick overall
and 5th rd pick
157 overall.

we would then have two 1st two 2nd two thirdsa fourth and two fifth's

Thoughts


Bmax

I would do it. We would get about the same quality players for much less money in the first at 21 and 28 and the extra picks gives us a ton of flexibility.

[Buffalogic]

How bout we just trade Peters for both of Philly's first rounders. He is a pro bowl left tackle and all. Just do what Denver did and announce he's available, 2 first round minimum, then answer the phone when the eagles call, lol.

[Mike]

"Stocking up on draft picks is a sure sign of rebuilding, plus this FO sucks at drafting.

Trading Peters is dumb. A trade that doesn't bring a proven player to Buffalo is even more idiotic."

I have to agree here! The only way I trade Peters is if: 1. he is in last year and I do not want to resign him b/c I have a potential replacement AND I can get back equal value -at least 2 1st round pick and a 3rd-. If I were the Bills I would sit tight. I would offer he a mid level offer because I promissed him an offer last year and let him finish out this year. If he Plays like the top LT in the league, I would reward him with top money -which will also be very insentive based-. If he still does not want to sigh, I keep him/or trade him (see above) for last year of his contract. At the end it, I can still Franchise him for 2 more years if we can not get the right deal done. I can also trade his right away at any point, and assuming he plays better his proven track record might get me the picks I want. The Bills have all the cards, they do not need to do anything. Peters will not sit out again, and if he does, this time I will keep his fines! For sure, he will not screw himself in the last two years of a contract/ or the last year. If you want to see an example of this See the PATS and Ty Law. He tried pulling the same ****, and Bilichek said NO to a new deal, then they franchised him for two years, at the end of this he had a knee injury and became a second grade corner.

[Mike]

At this point, the BILLS would have to be ******ed to do anything less than what the Pats did with Law! Trading him would be ******ed!

[Yasgur's Farm]

The whole problem with this idea is that we lose out on the Top OTs and the top DEs... Ayers, Brown, Orakpo, Maybin will all be gone by 21. Same for A.Smith and Oher.Maybin and Ayers will both be there at 21.

[Mitchell55]

Maybin and Ayers will both be there at 21.



Ayers is listed as a top 6 player on some boards and Maybin is also listed above Everette. To many teams need someone like Maybin to. GB, Buf, Den, SD...

[Yasgur's Farm]

Ayers is listed as a top 6 player on some boards and Maybin is also listed above Everette. To many teams need someone like Maybin to. GB, Buf, Den, SD...NFLDraftScout.com (http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings/top64.php?draftyear=2009) has Maybin ranked 38th (5th best DE) and Ayers ranked 41st (6th best DE).

DE rankings... (http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings/players.php?genpos=DE&draftyear=2009&sortorder=tsxpos&order=ASC) Orakpo, Brown, Jackson, and Johnson all rank higher.

NFLDraftScout.com is 1 of the very top draft sites around... I don't know what rags you're reading.

[Yasgur's Farm]

I think either Maybin or Ayers may be available to us round 2.

[Michael82]

Stocking up on draft picks is a sure sign of rebuilding, plus this FO sucks at drafting.

Trading Peters is dumb. A trade that doesn't bring a proven player to Buffalo is even more idiotic.
Ummm, do you honestly think that this is a playoff team? Do you think that we currently have the talent and coaching to get us there? If not, then it's a team rebuilding, which is why Jauron should have been fired, IMO.