This is a different discussion than what's going on in the other Vick thread.
If you want to discuss morals or the nature of his crime or if he's paid his debt to society, please go to that thread. There's a pretty good discussion going on in there.
This thread is for discussing football. Let's pretend that Vick is past all his legal troubles and cleared by the NFL to play this season. Whether or not he SHOULD be playing is a different topic. Let's discuss whether or not he can help this team.
I honestly don't think he can. The guy does not have the smarts to be an NFL QB. He's excellent when he can use his athleticism, but that comes at the price of quick decisions and a downfield passing game. Being out of the game for so long certainly won't help his mental progress, and it probably didn't help with his physical abilities either.
I'm not 100% sold on Edwards, but I'm sure Vick isn't the answer. I'd rather give Edwards his shot and hope for the best. The problem with Vick is that we've already seen the peak of what he can accomplish in the NFL. If nothing else, Trent has potential.
If you want to discuss morals or the nature of his crime or if he's paid his debt to society, please go to that thread. There's a pretty good discussion going on in there.
This thread is for discussing football. Let's pretend that Vick is past all his legal troubles and cleared by the NFL to play this season. Whether or not he SHOULD be playing is a different topic. Let's discuss whether or not he can help this team.
I honestly don't think he can. The guy does not have the smarts to be an NFL QB. He's excellent when he can use his athleticism, but that comes at the price of quick decisions and a downfield passing game. Being out of the game for so long certainly won't help his mental progress, and it probably didn't help with his physical abilities either.
I'm not 100% sold on Edwards, but I'm sure Vick isn't the answer. I'd rather give Edwards his shot and hope for the best. The problem with Vick is that we've already seen the peak of what he can accomplish in the NFL. If nothing else, Trent has potential.
Comment