Donte Whitner in the same discussion with Mike Williams, John McCargo, JP Losman and Erik Flowers yet? Overall, I think we got a top 10 defense this year, no joke but I think Whitner is dead weight. Can anybody remember the last time he has made a play? Other than that late tackle in the end zone against Pittsburgh, what has he done? That's his most memorable play as a Bill. To be honest, I think the jury is out on Whitner. In my estimation, we could have Byrd & Scott starting for us and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. I mean, what exactly does Whitner do other than hitting WRs over the middle after they already caught the ball and are 15-20 yards down field? Whitna is a bum. The end.
Can We Include?
Collapse
X
-
Re: Can We Include?
I think you may be referencing the Oakland game where he caught up to that showboater (Higgins i believe) and tackled him in the endzone after the 80 yard TD...yes i also agree that he needs to make more plays. I like better in the SS position, he seems to make a lot of tackles near the line. This is will the decisive year, i wanna see byrd at FS and use his ball hawking ability.
It all starts with the front 4 though...we need consistant pressure on the QB, more pressure=mor ebad throws/rushed throws=more playmaking
Go Bills
-
👍 2
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
Originally posted by Wittman21I think you may be referencing the Oakland game where he caught up to that showboater (Higgins i believe) and tackled him in the endzone after the 80 yard TD...yes i also agree that he needs to make more plays. I like better in the SS position, he seems to make a lot of tackles near the line. This is will the decisive year, i wanna see byrd at FS and use his ball hawking ability.
It all starts with the front 4 though...we need consistant pressure on the QB, more pressure=mor ebad throws/rushed throws=more playmaking
Go Bills
I like the fact that Whitner hits hard, but the clearly has a problem diagnosing the plays. I rarely see him bat down passes or make plays on the ball while it's in the air, that's probably my biggest critique of the guy. I guess it doesn't help that he has a big mouth that he can't back up with solid play either, probably my second biggest critique. My third biggest critique is that we took him 8th overall, but I guess that isn't his fault, haha.Last edited by PECKERWOOD; 09-08-2009, 11:37 AM.
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
there is always a defining moment or play when i go from Homer fan of a player to, "i think the show is over for this player."
Whitner's moment was when he got pancaked by a running back's stiff arm in the last game of the season. Then the gravy was his off field incident and his constant facebooking as a showing that he's a leader. Just get it done on the field. I doubt Ronnie Lott would have facebooked about his guarantees and such. The guy would cut off all his fingers to not facebook.
even though i thought that he showed his true colors of being an average player not worth the first round money, i will give him this year to make us believers. but that being said, he really is going to have to be a difference maker with INT's and big hits in coverage and run support
-
👍 1
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
I like Whitner. he's got a good attitude. I might have waited to pick him until around pick 28-32, but I haven't given up on him becoming a good player yet. he's just one of those players Bills fans love to hate because we picked him ahead of other playmakers. which is understandable, I'm just saying that I didnt HATE the pick. I just would have picked him later, I still like him on the team.I am The Batman.
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
Originally posted by BuffaloFeverDonte Whitner in the same discussion with Mike Williams, John McCargo, JP Losman and Erik Flowers yet? Overall, I think we got a top 10 defense this year, no joke but I think Whitner is dead weight. Can anybody remember the last time he has made a play? Other than that late tackle in the end zone against Pittsburgh, what has he done? That's his most memorable play as a Bill. To be honest, I think the jury is out on Whitner. In my estimation, we could have Byrd & Scott starting for us and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. I mean, what exactly does Whitner do other than hitting WRs over the middle after they already caught the ball and are 15-20 yards down field? Whitna is a bum. The end.
I took a lot of criticism for saying ****ner weas bordering out being an outright BUST. (I always felt he was a MAJOR reach, and Ngata was who I wanted).
I noted his career numbers, which amounted to something like 1FF, 2INT and one an UNBELIEVABLE 6 PD.
Of course las year was even worse 0 INT 1PD 1 FF and his first career sack.
and his tackles dropped to 61.
I was hit with a barage of excuses (including his own tweets) about playing a certain role. But that's total BS. Good players make plays when they are out there. they read the D and be where they can make a play.
****ner doesn't even make tackles anymore, and the drafting of Bird was meant to REPLACE him. not help him out.
I bet this is his last year with the Bills.
-
👍 1
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
Originally posted by Canadian'eh!Welcome to my life this time LAST year.
I took a lot of criticism for saying ****ner weas bordering out being an outright BUST. (I always felt he was a MAJOR reach, and Ngata was who I wanted).
I noted his career numbers, which amounted to something like 1FF, 2INT and one an UNBELIEVABLE 6 PD.
Of course las year was even worse 0 INT 1PD 1 FF and his first career sack.
and his tackles dropped to 61.
I was hit with a barage of excuses (including his own tweets) about playing a certain role. But that's total BS. Good players make plays when they are out there. they read the D and be where they can make a play.
****ner doesn't even make tackles anymore, and the drafting of Bird was meant to REPLACE him. not help him out.
I bet this is his last year with the Bills.
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
as much as i agree with the whitner assessment, he was playing with an injured shoulder for most of the year...he gets a couple games this year to prove to me that he's an outright bust and not just stuck with a bad injury last year.
Comment
-
-
Re: Can We Include?
Originally posted by trapezeusas much as i agree with the whitner assessment, he was playing with an injured shoulder for most of the year...he gets a couple games this year to prove to me that he's an outright bust and not just stuck with a bad injury last year.
I just felt that his performance last night proves my original sentiment.
Whitner is a liability in pass defense, but granted he is good at tackling in the box. Two big TDs over the middle in his general vicinity, he was late on both plays. I cheered last night when Kelsay got injured, I'm hoping that Whitner gets knocked out so Byrd can come in so we may see competent play.
Comment
-
Comment