Fitzpatrick is awesome!!

[HHURRICANE]

Please put Edwards in!!!

[Dr. Lecter]

Odd.

The games that Edwards looked horrid, you blamed everybody but Trent.

[circlethewagons]

Please put Edwards in!!!

Checking down every play is not going to get us back in this game

[hydro]

Edwards is even worse!!! Put in Brohm IMO.

[Commissioner]

Checking down every play is not going to get us back in this game

Can we get a happy medium?

[HHURRICANE]

Completing 35% of your passes is probably not going to win us this game.

[hydro]

Completing 35% of your passes is probably not going to win us this game.

And Edwards would probably be 60% even though all of them would be 5yds or less equaling to the same score.

[raphael120]

**** Edwards, put in Brohm. Hell, put in Moorman.

[HHURRICANE]

And Edwards would probably be 60% even though all of them would be 5yds or less equaling to the same score.

Well that would be more than 98 yards.

[HHURRICANE]

Nice sack. Nice pick.

[Commissioner]

Checkdown wouldn't have been such a bad thing on that interception...

[Novacane]

Can we please end this debate. Both QB's effing suck. Calling for one or the other is pointless.

[TheBrownBear]

Fitz is mediocre. Trent is mediocre. Brohm is likely mediocre too. I don't think any of these guys is as putrid as we sometimes make them out to be. The biggest problems are the O-Line and playcalling. The O-Line especially sucks. They had that one good drive, but other than that it was donkey balls all night long.

No QB will succeed behind this line and with AVP calling the shots. It is time we come to grips with reality.

New GM.
New Coach.
New O-Coordinator.
New & improved O-line
New QB

These are the major priorities - in that order.

[Ingtar33]

Can we please end this debate. Both QB's effing suck. Calling for one or the other is pointless.


yep. I hope Brohm gets to start the last 4 games. we have nothing else to look forward to (might as well find out what we have there)

[Boomstick]

Here's a way to end this debate... This Oline is effing terrible! Fix it or no QB will succeed behind it.

[Typ0]

yep. I hope Brohm gets to start the last 4 games. we have nothing else to look forward to (might as well find out what we have there)


aren't you a little concerned that playing him won't demonstrate what we have with him though? There has got to be a reason he was on a practice squad. That usually indicates there is potential there but too raw to perform right now. I think they are looking at him for the future but going to let this team tank with RF this season.

[hydro]

Well that would be more than 98 yards.

So what if it doesn't amount to points. Which it hasn't for all of Edwards' career.

[Commissioner]

Can we please end this debate. Both QB's effing suck. Calling for one or the other is pointless.
I'm not calling for one over the other.... but why do we have 2 HUGE EXTREMES!!

1 QB just wants to check down every damn time.

The other QB just chucks the ball up for grabs when he's got nothing else....

[Ingtar33]

aren't you a little concerned that playing him won't demonstrate what we have with him though? There has got to be a reason he was on a practice squad. That usually indicates there is potential there but too raw to perform right now. I think they are looking at him for the future but going to let this team tank with RF this season.


I'm not really interested in how the offense does while he's in there. i want to see his feet, his arm, and if he starts to catch up with the speed of the NFL game (which apparently was the problem in GB).

We need to know if there is anything there before the team goes into the off season, so we can prioritize our draft needs.

[Commissioner]

Yeah... lets find out if a guy who was on the practice squad all year is our franchise QB...

more idiocy from Bills fans...

[Typ0]

I'm not really interested in how the offense does while he's in there. i want to see his feet, his arm, and if he starts to catch up with the speed of the NFL game (which apparently was the problem in GB).

We need to know if there is anything there before the team goes into the off season, so we can prioritize our draft needs.

well...he gets to play against our defense in practice. If he can't demonstrate those things well against our defense he certainly won't do it against anyone elses.

[Typ0]

unfortunately, he's stuck with playing with our offense though. Hmm...this is really a problem.

[Ingtar33]

Yeah... lets find out if a guy who was on the practice squad all year is our franchise QB...

more idiocy from Bills fans...


keep putting words in my mouth. I said nothing about him being a franchise QB. I just remember before pre-draft workouts he was in the talk for number one player taken in the Draft... then he had some terrible workouts and fell to the 2nd round.

The Brohm i remember when he was in college was a blue chip outstanding prospect. He looked just like a young Jim Kelly (and that is not an exaggeration).

I don't know what happened to him on the transition to the NFL. I don't know what happened to him in the pre-draft workouts. But i'd certainly like to see what he looks like on the field, and see if there is any glimmer of the guy who was outstanding in college left in him.

for all we know he's a mess, or he might be able to hold down center. I want to know before the offseason, and the only way to "know" is to give him more then 1 game.

[MikeInRoch]

WAIT, I thought you WANTED them to lose? Now you want the better QB in?? What gives?

[Ingtar33]

well...he gets to play against our defense in practice. If he can't demonstrate those things well against our defense he certainly won't do it against anyone elses.


some guys look terrible on the practice field and outstanding on game day. It happens.

[Typ0]

some guys look terrible on the practice field and outstanding on game day. It happens.


OK. I see what you said above too and that make sense. I just worry about putting a guy into an inept offense that can't provide protection who isn't ready. He could get killed. Injured or just destoy him mentally. I think we've already seen that with TE.

[Ingtar33]

OK. I see what you said above too and that make sense. I just worry about putting a guy into an inept offense that can't provide protection who isn't ready. He could get killed. Injured or just destoy him mentally. I think we've already seen that with TE.


you can tell how "good" or "bad" a QB is without a good offense around him... I just would like to see WHY he was on the practice squad.

If his problem, like the people in GB say, is he can't adjust to the speed of the NFL i want to see if playing time HELPS. Give him 4 games, see what happens. Stick with him for them all. The only winnable game with either Edwards or Fitz under center left is against KC. It's not like we've got a chance to do better then 5-11 anyway.

Put Brohm under center for the last 4 games. see what happens. you'll know for sure what your needs are in the off season.

I don't care how out of his depth Brohm will be, i can't imagine him doing much worse then 30% completions, 90 yards an int and no tds (which i think BOTH fitz and Edwards have done this year).

[Mr. Pink]

Play Brohm.

Lets go for having a trifecta of crappy QB play.

[casdhf]

I don't see Fewell playing Brohm to see what the future holds.

[Philagape]

Yeah... lets find out if a guy who was on the practice squad all year is our franchise QB...

more idiocy from Bills fans...

More like to see if he doesn't suck donkeys ... to see if we don't end up wanting to stab ourselves in the eyeballs. That would be nice for a change.

[Griff]

And Edwards would probably be 60% even though all of them would be 5yds or less equaling to the same score.

at least they would keep the defense off the field for more than 2 minutes.

[SABURZFAN]

Can we please end this debate. Both QB's effing suck. Calling for one or the other is pointless.


WE WANT LOSSMAN!!!!!!!!!!! :couch:

[yordad]

at least they would keep the defense off the field for more than 2 minutes.Have you not wanted any of the games this year? WTF are you talking about? 3 completions for 6 yards = a punt.

[SABURZFAN]

:yawn:


:z: