Should Brohm start vs Indy?

[yordad]

Should Brohm start vs Indy?

[BILLSROCK1212]

only other option in my mind is Hammy

[Mr. Pink]

Would it matter if he didn't? Nope.

[Michael82]

IT would piss me off so much if Fitzpatrick starts in that meaningless game!

[BoyILuvLoznStupidly]

IT would piss me off so much if Fitzpatrick starts in that meaningless game!

That is pretty much how I feel as well. Imo saying Brohm is not the answer is the same as calling Maybin a bust.

[PECKERWOOD]

If Fitz is healthy, he should start. Well, on second thought since Brohm sucks donkeys, maybe we should let him play and lose, that way we get the higher pick?

[patmoran2006]

It doesnt matter if he should.

He wont, unless Fitzpatrick can't play.

Fewell would like to go out a winner and I can promise you he will start Fitz if his ankle is good enough to go.

[homeslice5484]

Just let Brohm use the offseason to prepare for next year with an entirely new offense. Forget learning this garbage behind that line.

[DrGraves]

Fewell should not get an interview after punting on 4th and 3 from the 34 yard line. INDOORS none the less.

Just play brohm for the fans sake. no one wants to watch fitz

[TigerJ]

It doesnt matter if he should.

He wont, unless Fitzpatrick can't play.

Fewell would like to go out a winner and I can promise you he will start Fitz if his ankle is good enough to go.Of course, everyone in the country will know the only reason Buffalo could possibly beat Indy is if Indy is resting players for the playoffs.

[Luisito23]

Colts are resting, and getting ready for the post-season, that's the only reason the Jets are beating them right now.

[Mr. Pink]

Brohm vs Painter!!!

I can't wait to see that ineptitude from both sides.

We might see a 6-3 barnburner.

[YardRat]

Yes.

[Oaf]

Hamball?

[trapezeus]

the question should be, "should we even bother having a coach for this game"

All the players look exactly the same. no matter who you plug or play, we get the same effort and same results from every player.

I say, let the players self coach and see if they do better than 31-3. I believe they can.

[Throne Logic]

My only interest in this game is watching Brohm. We already know how bad the rest of this team is. A capable showing by Brohm may dramatically change the off-season roster priorities. No draft pick is going to look significantly better on paper than BB did coming out. Consider this Brohm's updated pro-scouting workout.

[DraftBoy]

Without question. If Fewell goes with Fitz, he should be fired before the game.

[mikemac2001]

i hope ralph "meddle's" and forces a brohm start

[MikeInRoch]

Is this the most lopsided poll in the history of the zone??

[Nighthawk]

IT would piss me off so much if Fitzpatrick starts in that meaningless game!

What will piss me off is if they win this game against the freakin' Colts backup. Then again, it would be typical Buffalo to do so.

[yordad]

Is this the most lopsided poll in the history of the zone??I think once upon a time there was a B.O.B. thread as lopsided. Kate Beckinsale perhaps. :idunno:

[M]

According to Chris Brown, the starting QB is still undecided. :wtf:


The situation at quarterback for the Bills in preparation for their season finale is no different than it was last week. It’s up in the air until the coaching staff can get a look at starter <NOBR jQuery1262030986825="3" sizset="109" sizcache="228">Ryan Fitzpatrickhttp://www.buffalobills.com/assets/nflimg/icon-article-link.gif (http://www.buffalobills.com/team/roster/ryan-fitzpatrick/d260ac2d-12f2-4322-b794-02830c8319c8/)</NOBR> on the practice field later this week, and Fitzpatrick is expected to participate.

http://www.buffalobills.com/news/article-3/Starter-at-QB-to-be-determined/ba36e364-ecfd-44ce-9be3-dbdb1176576e

[Demon]

If Fewell plays Fitzpatrick, it may be one of the dumbest things i've ever seen done by Bills coaches. They need to give Brohm a full week's work with the first team unit and put him out there vs. the Colts at home. Even if he struggles early on, it won't matter much because soon he will face the Colts backups. Playing Fitzpatrick would just be stupid.

I don't think anyone is that stupid, so i'm going into our finale thinking Brohm will play QB.

[hydro]

70 votes? Holy ****!

[elltrain22]

I'd love to see Brohm get another shot. IMO, I think he did well, all things considered, at Atlanta. I think Indy is gonna play there 2nd & 3rd teamers mostly, so this gives a very nice chance to play well, and give him the confidence he needs moving forward.

[snow1989]

Why not let him play....might as well find out if he is going to be a serviceable back-up...and then start looking for a starting QB because frankly none of the 3 they've put on the field appear ready

[Typ0]

My only interest in this game is watching Brohm. We already know how bad the rest of this team is. A capable showing by Brohm may dramatically change the off-season roster priorities. No draft pick is going to look significantly better on paper than BB did coming out. Consider this Brohm's updated pro-scouting workout.


don't take this personal throne because a lot of people have your attitude and I'm writing this to everyone....this attitude is backwards and speaks to how knee jerk fans are. And the problem with this organization is it runs around trying to appease fans with unhealthy attitudes through the marketing maching. The end results are we perpetually stink. If only the fans were smart enough not to be this way maybe OBD would be better too. What is the problem here? The idea that one football game against a bunch of scrubs changes anything about what this team needs to do over the offseason. Let's just say Brohm goes out and gets our first 300 yard passer game in forever along with 4 TDs. OK, we're all set! Where does that leave us next year if he stinks or gets hurt in training camp?

[Jan Reimers]

We know what Fitz can do. And It ain't much. Give Brohm another look, and another game under his belt to prepare for next year.

Fitz has no upside. Brohm is an unknown, but he showed some promise in his debut.

[mybills]

I'll go with the 3rd option...I don't care who plays.

[Typ0]

We know what Fitz can do. And It ain't much. Give Brohm another look, and another game under his belt to prepare for next year.

Fitz has no upside. Brohm is an unknown, but he showed some promise in his debut.


What promise did he show? He did just about nothing which is exactly what TE does and everyone *****es about. I was happy with Brohm's performance he throws a nice pass and he didn't make any bad decisions. I can live with a few screw ups from a young guy like him. However, he really showed nothing and to think he has promise based in his performance last sunday is grasping at straws from desparate fans IMO. Fitz gives the team a better chance to win because he's better right now if he doesn't screw it up. And you have to take the chance that he'll have a good game and not screw it up and try and get another win. From a bunch of people who complain about a fabricated "play not to lose" philosophy people sure do enjoy losing.

[madness]

Start Brohm. If Fitz is healthy, have him replace Kirk Chambers.

[yordad]

What promise did he show? He did just about nothing which is exactly what TE does and everyone *****es about. I was happy with Brohm's performance he throws a nice pass and he didn't make any bad decisions. I can live with a few screw ups from a young guy like him. However, he really showed nothing and to think he has promise based in his performance last sunday is grasping at straws from desparate fans IMO. Fitz gives the team a better chance to win because he's better right now if he doesn't screw it up. And you have to take the chance that he'll have a good game and not screw it up and try and get another win. From a bunch of people who complain about a fabricated "play not to lose" philosophy people sure do enjoy losing.He played as well as Fitz did, and it was his first game after 4 days with the starting unit. Planning to win now is assinine.

[The Natrix]

Fitz has reached his potential.

And I don't buy the argument to not start Brohm because his long term confidence may get damaged due to a rough outing. This isn't because I don't think it can get damaged, but if it does then I don't want an emotionally frail QB on the Bills anyway.

I like what I saw from Brohm in his first outing.

Fitz only starts if Fewell is doing it to help his own image.

Brohm realizes that the offense around him (o-line in particular) is bad and the coaching is bad/not going to be here next year, so I doubt his psyche is all that in jeopardy.

[The Natrix]

Fitz only starts if Fewell is doing it to help his own image.




The fact that it is 79-2 pretty much proves this point.

F you Fewell if you start Fitz.

[Michael82]

The fact that it is 79-2 pretty much proves this point.

F you Fewell if you start Fitz.

EXACTLY! :hi5:

[paladin warrior]

YES Of COURSE. Bills Must Lose this sunday . Because Bills need to stay 1st round and in 7 place of 2010 draft.