Time to play everyones favorite game

[ddaryl]

		G	Att	Comp	Pct	Att/G	Yds	Avg	Yds/G	TD	TD%	Int	Int%	Lng	20+	40+	Sck	SckY	Rate
		8	183	110	60	22.9	1,169	6.4	146.1	6	3.3	7	3.8	46	14	2	23	139	73.8
		14	374	245	66	26.7	2,699	7.2	192.8	11	2.9	10	2.7	65	35	5	23	143	85.4
		10	269	151	56	26.9	1,630	6.1	163	7	2.6	8	3	70T	21	4	12	105	70.4
TOTAL		32	826	506	61	25.8	5,498	6.7	171.8	24	2.9	25	3	70	70	11	58	387	77.9
		11	356	205	58	32.4	2,108	5.9	191.6	11	3.1	15	4.2	68T	28	5	21	178	67.5
		16	526	320	61	32.9	3,284	6.2	205.2	17	3.2	16	3	52T	40	4	24	180	76.9
		1	27	15	56	27	221	8.2	221	1	3.7	0	0	40	4	1	2	12	94.8
TOTAL		28	909	540	58	30.8	5,613	6.77	205.9	29	3.33	31	3.6	68	72	10	47	370	79.3

Who are these 2 QB's ?????

[justasportsfan]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Trent and JP

[hydro]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Losman and Edwards

[THATHURMANATOR]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Top one is Edwards

[ddaryl]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Trent and JP

50% correct

[justasportsfan]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

50% correct

then it's not exactly "everyones favorite". more like half.

[Prov401]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Trent and Drew Brees.

[Syderick]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

First one is Trent Edwards.

[ddaryl]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Trent and Drew Brees.

Yep the bottom stats are Drew Brees' 1st 3 years in the league...

Not trying to say Edwards deserves to be the QB but in this case we can argue that San Diego had better FO, a better Coaching staff and a better OL during Brees 1st 3 years comapred to what Edwards has had in his 1st 3 years.


In 2004 San Diego drafted Rivers. That same year Brees started to come into his own... In 2006 he was traded to New Orleans.

Brees is now the MVP of a Superbowl winner, and San Diego still hasn't been able to win the big one..


Just a little fire for a debate. I admit I've lost hope in Edwards too... but the question begs can he get it together with better coaching and a stronger OL ?

Do we keep him on the roster and let him compete or do we just cut bait...

[Throne Logic]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

He stays on the roster and competes for a job.

Why in the world would the new coaching staff cut him without putting Trent through their own off-season program and subsequent training camp? Then they can evaluate what they have on their own terms.

Same goes for Brohm.

I consider Edwards and Brohm to be untapped potential with the new regime. With non-Jauron inspired coaching, Edwards could very easily turn out to be what we all hoped last off-season.

[Prov401]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Yep the bottom stats are Drew Brees' 1st 3 years in the league...

Not trying to say Edwards deserves to be the QB but in this case we can argue that San Diego had better FO, a better Coaching staff and a better OL during Brees 1st 3 years comapred to what Edwards has had in his 1st 3 years.


In 2004 San Diego drafted Rivers. That same year Brees started to come into his own... In 2006 he was traded to New Orleans.

Brees is now the MVP of a Superbowl winner, and San Diego still hasn't been able to win the big one..


Just a little fire for a debate. I admit I've lost hope in Edwards too... but the question begs can he get it together with better coaching and a stronger OL ?

Do we keep him on the roster and let him compete or do we just cut bait...

Ive always made this comparison to Edwards.

San Diego and their fans were fed up with Brees, and were ecstatic when they drafted Eli and made the swap with NY for Rivers. Then out of nowhere, something clicked for Brees. There was a point where the Chargers were actually thinking about trading Rivers and keeping Brees, but nobody was going to come forward and trade a number 1 for an unproven QB, which Rivers was at the time.

Edwards is a smart QB. He's showed flashes of being a good QB in this leauge. I don't think he's had the help of a good offensive coordinator in this leauge at all. Actually, all OC's he's worked with belong coaching in the UFL. The no huddle was an epic disaster, and the guy has absolutley no trust in his O-Line.

We definitely have to test Trent this year, and see what happens in the preseason. My biggest concern on Trent is his ability to stay healthy. Many doctors suggest retirement after a 3rd concussion. He's already had two, and the last one looked like a relatively weak hit.

[Mudflap1]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

There's one difference... Brees was good in college.

[Joe Fo Sho]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Brees isn't a pansy

[ddaryl]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

I would add that Trent has also not proven to be a leader who his teammates believe in

[EDS]

Re: Time to play everyones favorite game

Some of the percentages listed in the total column at the bottom for each athlete don't add up.