Lee Evans for Jason Campbell

[Stewie]

Straight up. Would you do it?

[buffalobillsfan95]

yah, lets trade our only good, proven, WR so we can make more holes for the draft, makes perfect sense

[Jamiezzz]

Is this some kinda joke?

[Jaybird]

NOOOOOOOOO

[malvado78]

wait for poll...

[THATHURMANATOR]

**** no. Why?

[DaBillzAhDaShiznit]

No thanks. The ONLY hope we would have for Campbell to have some success is to have a guy like Lee and at least one more good receiver on the field.
Now if you wanna talk Lynch for Campbell, I am all ears.
Portis is aging.....

[Italian Stallion]

wow. just wow.

[Michael82]

:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: Are you ****ing high or something? Campbell is an RFA and no one has even sniffed him for a 1st round tender. I guarantee that they are willing to take whatever they can get for him. We could probably get him right now for a 5th round pick or later. And I would do that. If not, I wouldn't be surprised if they remove the tender and let him become a UFA.

[Mad Bomber]

NO. WAY. PERIOD.

[trapezeus]

i'm not even sold that Evans is all that great, and i still wouldn't do that trade.

[The Spaz]

You wouldn't by chance own a waterspoon would you?

[tampabay25690]

Straight up. Would you do it?

Thats real stupid

[clumping platelets]

:no:

[clumping platelets]

How aboot Youboty for Campbell?

[THRILLHO]

Hmmm, should we throw in our second rounder too?

[Michael82]

Donte Whitner straight up for Campbell!

[OpIv37]

Lee Evans is the only decent WR on the roster right now.

If we traded him for Campbell, we'd have a QB with no OL and ZERO talent at WR.

Yeah, there's a recipe for success :rolleyes:

[Jan Reimers]

Straight up. Would you do it?
God no. We would have a mediocre QB with no receivers.

[Jan Reimers]

Lee Evans is the only decent WR on the roster right now.

If we traded him for Campbell, we'd have a QB with no OL and ZERO talent at WR.

Yeah, there's a recipe for success :rolleyes:
Sorry, OP, didn't see your post.

[EDS]

No.

[Mr. Pink]

I don't even think Washington would take that trade.

Lee Evans is nowhere near as good as some people make him out to be on this board.

[Stewie]

I'd make the trade and here's why. I'm assuming the goal is to win the superbowl within 3-4 years.

Lee is a one trick pony, as far as I'm concerned. It's a good trick, but it's one that declines with age for even the best athletes. He is not a legit #1, and when he's consistently doubled he gets shut down.

Campbell is a serviceable QB. He isn't flashy, but he isn't terrible, and he hasn't exactly had the most stable situation in his career. He plays best when his running game is rolling.

They are the same age. Campbell could play another 7 or 8 years. Lee isn't going to be productive for that long.

In the short term, Lee could have a couple explosive years with McNabb throwing to him. He isn't going to put those numbers up for us with a rookie QB. And by the time a rookie is 3 years in, Lee is 32 years old and still tryin to outrun 22 year olds.

If we have Campbell at QB, it lets us select a QB later in the draft that can use some bench time. And we can go BPA at 9, pick up an OT or Dez, and a FA or rookie WR in the later rounds.

[ddaryl]

LOL!

rediculous

[TigerJ]

No freakin way. Make it Whitner, or Youboty and a low draft pick and we have a deal.

[Bert102176]

stay away from drugs, they cause you to make stupid posts like this one

[Bert102176]

jason campbell sucks just say no

[justasportsfan]

Lee is a one trick pony, as far as I'm concerned. . Is Campbell any sort of a trick pony?


It's a good trick, but it's one that declines with age for even the best athletes. He is not a legit #1, and when he's consistently doubled he gets shut down. .
And Campbell doesn't get shut down with crappy OL?


and he hasn't exactly had the most stable situation in his career . And Lee has?



He plays best when his running game is rolling. . And Lee has had a great season when he's had a qb that can get him the ball.




If we have Campbell at QB, it lets us select a QB later in the draft that can use some bench time. And we can go BPA at 9, pick up an OT or Dez, and a FA or rookie WR in the later rounds.

Who are they going to throw to? Trade a player thats proven to be able to catch for 1300 yards and draft a rookie who supposedly has attitude problems?

Getting rid of our best player for someone who hasn't even proven to be decent consistently?

Crazy talk.

[Bill Cody]

wait for poll...

lol

[Stewie]

I don't think Lee Evans is our best player. I think he's a talented but aging WR on a bad team. Which makes him perfect trade bait.

I think I'm on to the right track, but according to all you armchair GM's maybe I need to toss in a low round pick with Campbell to equalize the deal.

"ESPN 980 in Washington reports there are five teams already interested (http://twitter.com/ESPNRadio980/status/11640261100): Buffalo, Carolina, Oakland, Jacksonville & an unknown team."

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2010/04/05/report-five-teams-interested-in-jason-campbell/

And I'd be willing to bet zone bucks or real bucks that if Campbell is given a chance to start with his next team, he has more "productive years" than Evans, as much as you can compare the two positions.

[psubills62]

I don't even think Washington would take that trade.

Lee Evans is nowhere near as good as some people make him out to be on this board.

Whether or not Evans is as good as most people on here think, he's still worth a lot more than Campbell is now.

[justasportsfan]

I don't think Lee Evans is our best player. I think he's a talented but aging WR on a bad team. Which makes him perfect trade bait.

I think I'm on to the right track, but according to all you armchair GM's maybe I need to toss in a low round pick with Campbell to equalize the deal.

"ESPN 980 in Washington reports there are five teams already interested (http://twitter.com/ESPNRadio980/status/11640261100): Buffalo, Carolina, Oakland, Jacksonville & an unknown team."

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2010/04/05/report-five-teams-interested-in-jason-campbell/

And I'd be willing to bet zone bucks or real bucks that if Campbell is given a chance to start with his next team, he has more "productive years" than Evans, as much as you can compare the two positions.


Why do you have to trade Lee Evans to get Campbell? Bring in Campbell and take away his only proven weapon? Might as well go back to dinking and dunking.


If Campbell can be had for a 3rd, Lee is worth more than a 3rd.

[justasportsfan]

I don't even think Washington would take that trade.

Lee Evans is nowhere near as good as some people make him out to be on this board.
and he's not nearly as bad as some people here make him out to be either.

[HHURRICANE]

Evans sucks but this isn't even in the realm of realistic.

Ask the Redskins how valuable Campbell is.

[TMu11]

NIe Nie Nie Nie Nie!

[kelly2reed4six]

Straight up. Would you do it?


HELL NO! If I were the skins, Hell yes.

[TrEd FTW]

Would you trade filet mignon for a half-eaten ham sandwich?

[THATHURMANATOR]

I don't even think Washington would take that trade.

Lee Evans is nowhere near as good as some people make him out to be on this board.
I think they would in a heartbeat.

[TMu11]

Would you trade filet mignon for a half-eaten ham sandwich?

How good is the ham sandwich?

[BillsWin]

Straight up. Would you do it?

Did someone drop you as a child?

[djjimkelly]

i dont get the love on here for campbell the last 3 seasons the redskins have been trying to replace this guy.

but.......

we need him

jason campbell is heading str8 for a lifetime of clipboards in this league

[DraftBoy]

Not that I think that much about Evans, he's worth more than Campbell right now.

So the trade doesnt make sense. Now if it were Campbell and Thomas for Evans Id had pause for far longer before making a decision.

[TacklingDummy]

Donte Whitner straight up for Campbell!
I wouldn't even trade Whitner for Campbell.

I want the Bills to get rid of their garbage, not bring some more in.

[TacklingDummy]

i dont get the love on here for campbell the last 3 seasons the redskins have been trying to replace this guy.


Some fans love being mediocre and losing.

[JCBills]

I didn't see a poll, so I'm totally lost on how to answer this question without one.

[mrbojanglezs]

This sums this thread up (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZpmIBJ_MKas)

[SquishDaFish]

I cant even respond to this crap. Oh wait I just did. :lol:

[PECKERWOOD]

Add in a 2nd + a black hole and I'd still do it.

[Nighthawk]

Wow, ton of stupidity on this site today!

[BertSquirtgum]

i would cry from anger if this happened

[New Ro's Greatest]

April fools.............GO BILLS:refuse:

[SABURZFAN]

Straight up. Would you do it?


were we bored today or something? what a horrible thread. :down:

[The Natrix]

haha, thanks for the laugh, buddy.

[Stewie]

I firmly believe Jason Campbell has a more productive career ahead of him than Lee Evans.

We'll find out.