Draft Nasty's Final Grades

[DraftBoy]

http://draftnasty.com/insider_blogs/john/how-well-did-your-team-do-in-2010/

Bills: A-
Miami: C
New England: B
New York Jets: B+

[jamze132]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

This isn't biased at all is it...

[psubills62]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

Was this just you grading the teams, DB, or was it the whole DN staff?

[patmoran2006]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

I do not think the Bills deserve a higher grade than the Patriots after what they did (in getting a bunch of players and more draft picks)

I also don't believe in grades period until a few years after the draft. But still

[DraftBoy]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

Was this just you grading the teams, DB, or was it the whole DN staff?

Whole staff.

[DraftBoy]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

I do not think the Bills deserve a higher grade than the Patriots after what they did (in getting a bunch of players and more draft picks)

I also don't believe in grades period until a few years after the draft. But still

And I think your wrong about grades as they are not meant to show or perdict anything about how a player will do in the future.

Why do you think the Pats drafted better? They added great depth but not great starters. Of all their picks how many wil start? 1 maybe 2 barring injuries.

[Mike13]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

So it looks like its just you and Kiper who thinks the Dolphins did not have a good draft.

Awesome company to be in.

[DraftBoy]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

So it looks like its just you and Kiper who thinks the Dolphins did not have a good draft.

Awesome company to be in.

Not just I, again.

Draft Nasty DOES NOT Equal DB.

I am only one part of Draft Nasty

[The last buffalo fan]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

So it looks like its just you and Kiper who thinks the Dolphins did not have a good draft.

Awesome company to be in.

M13

[OpIv37]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

And I think your wrong about grades as they are not meant to show or perdict anything about how a player will do in the future.

Why do you think the Pats drafted better? They added great depth but not great starters. Of all their picks how many wil start? 1 maybe 2 barring injuries.

They're the friggin Pats- how many starters did they actually need? They're not like Buffalo- they don't go into every draft in need of 7-8 starters.

[DraftBoy]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

They're the friggin Pats- how many starters did they actually need? They're not like Buffalo- they don't go into every draft in need of 7-8 starters.

Yes which is my point...Their draft gade gets hurt because they took guys that they wont use now.

Its the same principle as Pat will use in 3 years when he grades this draft;

Player A is a RB who went to a crap team and started Day 1, and has had 1000+ yard seasons.

Player B is alos a RB who went to the defending SB champs started as their #3 back, was #2 two years ago and is a one year starter.

Which player will get a higher grade? Players who are of good value and fill immediate needs for teams always get higher grades than teams that draft for depth.

[mysticsoto]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

Yes which is my point...Their draft gade gets hurt because they took guys that they wont use now.

Its the same principle as Pat will use in 3 years when he grades this draft;

Player A is a RB who went to a crap team and started Day 1, and has had 1000+ yard seasons.

Player B is alos a RB who went to the defending SB champs started as their #3 back, was #2 two years ago and is a one year starter.

Which player will get a higher grade? Players who are of good value and fill immediate needs for teams always get higher grades than teams that draft for depth.

I agree with you completely and it's funny that you (and your guys at Draft Nasty) gave them the same grade I did...an A-.

[ddaryl]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

They're the friggin Pats- how many starters did they actually need? They're not like Buffalo- they don't go into every draft in need of 7-8 starters.

But there level of depth and the shuffling they've done over the years seems to be catching up to them... IMO they're moving backwards slowly

It almost appears The Patriots are more interested in more picks then the actual players. At some point they need to use those extra picks to move up and draft impact players

[ParanoidAndroid]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

The grades seem awfully arbitrary.

[OpIv37]

Re: Draft Nasty's Final Grades

But there level of depth and the shuffling they've done over the years seems to be catching up to them... IMO they're moving backwards slowly

on paper I would agree with that. On the field, though, they've shown no signs of slowing down.