QB rankings

[Mindbender]

Not too surprised at this.


32. Buffalo Bills (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/teams/buf/): Coach Chan Gailey is a clever man who has done a lot over the years with flawed quarterbacks. Be it Kordell Stewart or Jay Fiedler (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/3012/)(notes) (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/3012/news), Gailey somehow made it work in the past. At least his quarterbacks are bright (Trent Edwards (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/8346/)(notes) (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/8346/news) went to Stanford and backup Ryan Fitzpatrick (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/7426/)(notes) (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/7426/news) is from Harvard). That said, Edwards regressed badly last year and a concussion didn’t help. Fitzpatrick has the look of a JAG (Just A Guy). Maybe Brian Brohm (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/8833/)(notes) (http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/players/8833/news) has something to add, but that certainly wasn’t the case when he was in Green Bay.


http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/news?slug=jc-qbrankings051810

[sdbillsfan2]

Quick question. ???????

Where does the sports writer rank among other sports writers ?

He may be right , but ........using his own words ,,,,,He's the JAG ( just another guy )

"Those who can do !!!!....Those who can't become sportswriters "

[TacklingDummy]

32?

Shocker.

[psubills62]

From that list, it seems to me that the only possible argument would be to switch Cleveland and Buffalo. At this point, I'd have a hard time saying Jake Delhomme is better than any QB we have, but it's a matter of perspective. 32 or 31...it really doesn't matter.

[Don't Panic]

32... great place to start because:

A. This guy has no idea what will happen when the games are actually played

B. There's only one direction to go!

[Novacane]

32 is not so bad. He could have put some teams back ups ahead of our garbage.

[ServoBillieves]

AJ Feeley, Josh Freeman, Jason Campbell and Mark Sanchez are better than what we have as proven starters?

That says a lot about this organization... or who actually cares what 1 guy feels?

[psubills62]

AJ Feeley, Josh Freeman, Jason Campbell and Mark Sanchez are better than what we have as proven starters?

That says a lot about this organization... or who actually cares what 1 guy feels?

I wouldn't say Feeley is, but with Bradford as the 1a in St. Louis, it's a better situation than we have. Freeman is better (more potential to get better). Jason Campbell is better by far - just look at his stats compared to any of our QB's. Sanchez...is arguable, imo. I don't think he's very good, but he's got more potential than any of our guys.

[ServoBillieves]

I wouldn't say Feeley is, but with Bradford as the 1a in St. Louis, it's a better situation than we have. Freeman is better (more potential to get better). Jason Campbell is better by far - just look at his stats compared to any of our QB's. Sanchez...is arguable, imo. I don't think he's very good, but he's got more potential than any of our guys.

I point the Campbell argument to the people who said he wasn't worth any pick for the Bills... Freeman is a 2nd year guy, who knows what he'll do. Feeley is worthless, and Sanchez will thrive yet again on a running game. Edwards/Fitzpatrick/Brohm/Brown, who knows what they'll do, but damn, to put them dead last is fine by me, let's see which one prevails in the regular season and gets us to 25!

[psubills62]

I point the Campbell argument to the people who said he wasn't worth any pick for the Bills... Freeman is a 2nd year guy, who knows what he'll do. Feeley is worthless, and Sanchez will thrive yet again on a running game. Edwards/Fitzpatrick/Brohm/Brown, who knows what they'll do, but damn, to put them dead last is fine by me, let's see which one prevails in the regular season and gets us to 25!

Haha, well I did want Campbell, so I guess it wasn't directed at me.

I think guys like Sanchez (despite having the benefit of a GREAT defense and GREAT running game) and Freeman simply get the benefit of the doubt ahead of our guys. I believe our team as a whole will get us to a 5-11 or 6-10 record (obviously not a good one, but better than some teams). But I do think our QB situation overall and for the future is right near last place, from what we currently know.

[TacklingDummy]

Campbell sucked and is a rAIDER. Get over it.

[ServoBillieves]

Haha, well I did want Campbell, so I guess it wasn't directed at me.

I think guys like Sanchez (despite having the benefit of a GREAT defense and GREAT running game) and Freeman simply get the benefit of the doubt ahead of our guys. I believe our team as a whole will get us to a 5-11 or 6-10 record (obviously not a good one, but better than some teams). But I do think our QB situation overall and for the future is right near last place, from what we currently know.

Perfect wording. FROM WHAT WE KNOW, then most certainly we should be considered last place.

Fitzy can manage the game but seems like one of the mentally slower QB's in the league when it comes to decision making.

Edwards, as long as he doesn't get slammed to the ground prior to it, seems like a game controller, but has that little sissy on his shoulder screaming "DUCK!" "RUN FOR COVER!"

Brohm, with 3rd string reps (AKA very little reps in the season) was a robot, simple system QB and his performance should reflect very small if whatsoever on his ability. It's tough to show potential when you're tossed in to an NFL role after getting an eighth of the snaps in practice to no names.

Levi Brown = Rookie. That's all I got.

More power to the dude in wasting time picking who is the best QB class among 32 teams and getting paid for it, but we will see who prevails. Do I predict the Bills? No way. But journalists like him are amazingly lucky.

[BILLSROCK1212]

look, we belong around there...but i dont get how Sanchez is any better

[ServoBillieves]

look, we belong around there...but i dont get how Sanchez is any better

He's not.

6 picks against the preseason rated 31st team in the NFL apparently makes him the worst QB in the NFL according to 3 guys who think so.

Oh ****! Now it makes sense. He's mediocre.

[TheBrownBear]

Why is Arizona four spots ahead of us. Their situation is just as bad, imo.

[blln4lyf]

Fitzy can manage the game but seems like one of the mentally slower QB's in the league when it comes to decision making.


LOL no. Fitz can make quick decisions, but he does not seem talented enough. Has everything you want but the skill.

[billz83]

our QBz are real bad..they couldnt get over 20 TDz if they livez depended on it..i am a lil suprised they got AJ Feely higher..i guess everyone knows the bills have bad QBz except for this organization..

[jamze132]

32a. JP Losman (Seattle Seahawks)

32b. Buffalo Bills.

[Thief]

32a. JP Losman (Seattle Seahawks)

32b. Buffalo Bills.If 2 teams were ranked last...
a. They would be tied for 31st
b. I don't think Seattle's third stringer would effect the rank

[Mr. Miyagi]

Oh puuleeeeeeeeeeeez.

Kevin Kolb hasn't done **** in this league.
Chad Henne hasn't proven a thing.
Josh Freeman? Are you ****** kidding me?
AJ Feeley and Sam Bradford?
Matt ****** Leinhert? Matt Moore????

All these people are ranked higher than us?

What a terrible Bills-bashing piece of garbage this article is.

:down::down:

[jamze132]

If 2 teams were ranked last...
a. They would be tied for 31st
b. I don't think Seattle's third stringer would effect the rank

Way to over analyze my attempt at humor.

[Mindbender]

Way to over analyze my attempt at humor.

:rofl:

[Griff]

Oh puuleeeeeeeeeeeez.

Kevin Kolb hasn't done **** in this league.
Chad Henne hasn't proven a thing.
Josh Freeman? Are you ****** kidding me?
AJ Feeley and Sam Bradford?
Matt ****** Leinhert? Matt Moore????

All these people are ranked higher than us?

What a terrible Bills-bashing piece of garbage this article is.

:down::down:

Trent's been off but jeeze at least we have some potential players at QB.

[YardRat]

Can't wait for him to rank left tackles....we'll probably drop down into the 40's.

[DMBcrew36]

I don't really know how anyone can argue with this ranking, just as with the Bills being #31 in power rankings.

[Johnny Bugmenot]

Well, at least they're ahead of the Florida Tuskers... though Brooks Bollinger is looking awfully tempting.