The QB Debate

[DraftBoy]

Arguably the top 5 QB's for the next draft (assuming all come out) so let's track them all season.

Ponder-
23-42, 54.8%, 280 yds, 4 TD, 3 INT (v. Oklahoma, and Samford)

Mallett-
49-67, 73.1%, 701 yards, 6TD, 2 INT (v.TN Tech, and ULM)

Luck-
28-47, 59.6%, 467 yards, 6 TD, 0 INT (v. Sac St, UCLA)

Locker-
42-70, 60.0%, 555 yards, 5 TD, 0 INT (v. BYU, Syracuse)

Johnson-
53-78, 67.9%, 671 yards, 6 TD, 0 INT (v. SFA, Louis Tech)

Let the great debate begin!!

[YardRat]

Re: The QB Debate

Mallett
Luck
Johnson
Locker
Ponder

[DraftBoy]

Re: The QB Debate

I will say this while Im not a big Ryan Mallett fan the two games Ive seen of him so far have shown some growth in going through his progressions and making reads on the fly. Now I want to see him against some SEC defenses though.

[psubills62]

Re: The QB Debate

Obviously there are things you can take away from games against crappy opponents, but I have a hard time taking guys like Johnson and Mallett seriously until they play someone decent.

[X-Era]

Re: The QB Debate

My top 3, for the Bills are:

Luck
Mallett
Gabbert

[Crisis]

Re: The QB Debate

where do you see keenum going?

[Crisis]

Re: The QB Debate

and weren't you big on that devlin kid from delaware? whats the word with him?

[DraftBoy]

Re: The QB Debate

where do you see keenum going?

Round 4 or 5 at this point.

[DraftBoy]

Re: The QB Debate

and weren't you big on that devlin kid from delaware? whats the word with him?

Very big on him, but he's not really going to be a first round pick at this point. So I left him out of this discussion.

[tampabay25690]

Re: The QB Debate

Mallett
Luck
Johnson
Locker
Ponder

WOW

[tampabay25690]

Re: The QB Debate

LOCKER
LUCK

[X-Era]

Re: The QB Debate

Im agreeing with Db and Ing... Locker hasnt shown the decision making and poise to be a 1st round QB.

[psubills62]

Re: The QB Debate

I have to say...one guy I'm interested in is McElroy from Bama. Smart, accurate, and he's never lost a game going back to 8th grade!? I'm interested to hear what his positives/negatives are. Didn't really notice if he was too short...he seemed to be about 6'1", but that's a rough guess-timation from memory.

[Crisis]

Re: The QB Debate

mcelroy = ken dorsey

actually dorsey was probably a better college QB

[X-Era]

Re: The QB Debate

Here's Gabbert's line:

60-79, 75.9%, 501 yards, 3 TD's, 0 INT's (Illinois, McNeese St.)

They run the spread so the completion percentage is inflated with all the short throws, but he probably has the strongest arm Ive seen and usually makes very good decisions.