Rank the Big 5 QB's

[BuffaloBlitz83]

Mine.

Luck


Newton
Mallet
Locker
Gabbert

I could switch Mallet and Newton cause I'm scared of his off field issues. I hope he isn't another V Young

[ServoBillieves]

Haven't we done this 8 times in the past 2 days?

[tampabay25690]

Mine.

Luck


Newton
Mallet
Locker
Gabbert

I could switch Mallet and Newton cause I'm scared of his off field issues. I hope he isn't another V Young

LUCK
NEWTON
LOCKER
GABBERT
MALLETT

Newton is better then Young was.
He has better personality he wants people to like him.....

[BuffaloBlitz83]

LUCK
NEWTON
LOCKER
GABBERT
MALLETT

Newton is better then Young was.
He has better personality he wants people to like him.....

without being bias. I know you liked tebow. you think Newton has better tools and skillset to be a better QB than Tim in NFL?

[Mr. Pink]

Luck
Locker
Gabbert
Mallet/Newton are interchangeable, both are overhyped and won't be successful at the NFL level.

Actually outside of Luck this entire QB class is very weak.

[BuffaloBlitz83]

Luck
Locker
Gabbert
Mallet/Newton are interchangeable, both are overhyped and won't be successful at the NFL level.

Actually outside of Luck this entire QB class is very weak.

People sai that bout the ryan, flacco class. They said last year that that class sucked including Bradford. Bradford has been great and Tebow and mccoy have played well for rookies

[DraftBoy]

Luck
Gabbert
Devlin
Mallett
Newton/Locker

[BuffaloBlitz83]

How do you rate Barkley to the 5 guys had he been eligible to come out?

[tampabay25690]

without being bias. I know you liked tebow. you think Newton has better tools and skillset to be a better QB than Tim in NFL?

Good ?????
Cam has a better arm then TIM, but Tim has better leadership qualities then Cam....
The thing you get with Tim Tebow is a guy that will not let you down. You don't have to worry about him rapping girls or out at the bars all nite.....Not saying Cam is that way at all.....
Both players play vs the best in college ball in the SEC so that helps....

I honestly thought the Bills were going to draft Tebow instead of Spiller.

I think Cam will be special in the NFL....
Cam put up great numbers this year but Tebow still put up better numbers his heisman year.

[DraftBoy]

How do you rate Barkley to the 5 guys had he been eligible to come out?
Just above Mallett.

[tampabay25690]

How do you rate Barkley to the 5 guys had he been eligible to come out?

Hard to say yet.....
Good pospect but hard to rate him.
I want to see him do something 1st....

[BuffaloBlitz83]

Good ?????
Cam has a better arm then TIM, but Tim has better leadership qualities then Cam....
The thing you get with Tim Tebow is a guy that will not let you down. You don't have to worry about him rapping girls or out at the bars all nite.....Not saying Cam is that way at all.....
Both players play vs the best in college ball in the SEC so that helps....

I honestly thought the Bills were going to draft Tebow instead of Spiller.

I think Cam will be special in the NFL....
Cam put up great numbers this year but Tebow still put up better numbers his heisman year.

I'm asking who will be a better QB on the field

[tampabay25690]

I'm asking who will be a better QB on the field

Oh god.....
Probably Tebow......
He will just work for it....

[BuffaloBlitz83]

Oh god.....
Probably Tebow......
He will just work for it....

Are you being bias :)?

[tampabay25690]

Are you being bias :)?

Just being truthful.....
hey Cam should have been the next QB at FL after TIM....

[X-Era]

Luck
Gabbert
Newton
Mallett
Locker

[Commissioner]

Luck
Gabbert
Mallett


Don't give a crap about the rest.

[TacklingDummy]

Newton
Mallet
Gabbert
Locker
Stanzi

[jamze132]

Luck
Gabbert
Devlin
Mallett
Newton/Locker/Joique Bell


Fixed