Luck vs Griffen vs Barkley

[Mike]

What's your opinion of each? Will all 3 be good? Who would you compare them to in NFL?

[Skooby]

Bark it out loud.

[Extremebillsfan247]

Whether anyone of them will be good or not will depend on which team drafts them and the men who will be coaching them. I think comparisons are overrated. I have no opinion on any of them, and probably wont until they are drafted.

[kingJofNYC]

Not a Barkley fan.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Isnt Barkley staying at USC?

[hydro]

Isnt Barkley staying at USC?

Don't think it is official but most think he will seeing as a good friend/teammate Kalil is staying.

[The Natrix]

Leinart mixed with Jimmy Clausen = Barkley

I like Luck and RGIII a lot and would be pissed if the Bills passed on either if they were there. Doubt either will be though.

[TigerJ]

I think of the three Luck is the safest pick. It's quite possible all will do well in the NFL. Barkley is smart, but has the weakest arm of the three, and I heard that he might have small hands, one criticism that was made concerning Claussen, and we know how that turned out. Griffin may be shorter than his listed height, but I still think he can be a terrific QB. He's not shorter than Drew Brees.

[jimbohastle51]

if we have a top 10 pick and griffen comes out, you can almost certainly pencil him in for us. they will not pass on him. we will have no chance at luck but griffen is a extremely interesting player for the team. especially with this new rookie wage scale cause he won't cost what a top 10 qb did in years past.

[Mike13]

Don't think it is official but most think he will seeing as a good friend/teammate Kalil is staying.


That rumor was false. (http://www.nfl.com/news/story/09000d5d824da5ea/article/usc-offensive-tackle-kalil-reportedly-staying-in-college?module=HP11_headline_stack)

[Ed]

I'm all aboard the RGIII bandwagon. I would love it if the Bills got him, but I think he ends up being the 2nd qb taken overall and doesn't fall out of the top 5. The stock of qb's like Griffin only rise as the draft approaches. Even if the Bills lose out, they won't be picking in the top 5.

[DraftBoy]

That rumor was false. (http://www.nfl.com/news/story/09000d5d824da5ea/article/usc-offensive-tackle-kalil-reportedly-staying-in-college?module=HP11_headline_stack)

Not false, simply still a rumor.

[DraftBoy]

To answer the question I'd take any of the three.

I think Luck and Barkley are extremely similar prospects. I think Luck is the most NFL ready with Barkley not far behind but RGIII has the highest potential.

[Mike]

To give an idea of how Great the Bills are at marketing just look at the sellouts. They are selling out more games now than they did in the 1990s! In the 1994 the Greatest Comeback ever was not televised as a result of not selling out. In the past 10years or so, they have had no problems selling tickets to a team that can't manage to win more than 7 games on average

Can you give me a little overview of each?

[Mski]

I think all three will be good, with all the hype behind Luck it may be dificult for him to be considered "great" even if he does play great. I think Barkley is also very similar to Luck, but lacks some of the "polish" that Luck has. RGIII posibly has the most "potential" of the three, he could be the next Newton or V Young, hard to tell.