What 1st round picks were reaches?

[TacklingDummy]

I'd have to go with 1. Alba, 3, Kim K., 7. Eva Mendes, and 15. Hendricks.

Alba only because she was #1, right now I'd say she's not top 10 material anymore.

Kim K. because of who she is. People will hold that against her even though she is hot.

Hendricks because she's just plain chubby.

Mendes because she's hot but not top 10 hot.

[YardRat]

If you were to compare them, individually, to Maybin, Whitner, JP Losman and CJ Spiller how would you match them up?

[TacklingDummy]

If you were to compare them, individually, to Maybin, Whitner, JP Losman and CJ Spiller how would you match them up?

Maybin: Biggest bust Hendricks
CJ = Alba
JP= Kim
Whitner= Mendes

[BLeonard]

Christina Hendricks and Rachel McAdams are the two that jump out at me...

I would add Kim Kardashian to that list, but IIRC, Chern said that if she fell to his spot, he would have picked her.

-Bill

[EricStratton]

I’d say Kristen Bell but as a late first rounder she’s on the border of a reach. I also think Megan Fox and Katy Perry are a bit overrated for a first round pick.

[BLeonard]

I’d say Kristen Bell but as a late first rounder she’s on the border of a reach. I also think Megan Fox and Katy Perry are a bit overrated for a first round pick.

Personally, I had Bell pretty high on my list and was debating taking her in Round 1.

What stopped me was the fact that FL was right behind me in the draft and I'm 99% sure had I not taken Katy Perry, he would have.

Figured I had a better shot of getting Bell in Round 2 then I did of getting Perry, which was why I went with Katy.

-Bill

[Forward_Lateral]

I would've taken Perry, yes. You made a good pick.

[EricStratton]

One plus with Katy is the divorce. I think she will come on strong in 2012 to get the stink of her marriage off her.

[chernobylwraiths]

I'd have to go with 1. Alba, 3, Kim K., 7. Eva Mendes, and 15. Hendricks.

Alba only because she was #1, right now I'd say she's not top 10 material anymore.

Kim K. because of who she is. People will hold that against her even though she is hot.

Hendricks because she's just plain chubby.

Mendes because she's hot but not top 10 hot.

Who cares about top 10? You do realize that there were 25 first round picks, right?

[TacklingDummy]

Who cares about top 10? You do realize that there were 25 first round picks, right?

Point? Like I said, Hendricks was a reach at 15. Hell she was a reach in the entire 1st round.

I could see everyone else who made the 1st round as 1st round pick but her.

[ServoBillieves]

-_- my team needed a decent lineman, I went Mike Williams. WHO ELSE was a reach.

[The Jokeman]

-_- my team needed a decent lineman, I went Mike Williams. WHO ELSE was a reach.
but Tight Ends are more valuable in this league :D