Dawson, Doleman, Kennedy, Martin, Roaf

[YardRat]

The five finalists

Bull****

[YardRat]

What a frickin' joke.

Dawson and Roaf definitely.
Martin...maybe.
Doleman and Kennedy over all of the three WR's? No way in hell.

[methos4ever]

What a frickin' joke.

Dawson and Roaf definitely.
Martin...maybe.
Doleman and Kennedy over all of the three WR's? No way in hell.
Once you're in the top 10 of RBs, you make it in. Pretty much the rule of thumb they've followed.

[NOT THE DUDE...]

doleman and kennedy?? wtf?

[YardRat]

True, but he could've waited another year in lieu of a WR.

Bettis is sixth (Martin 4th), and he didn't make the top 10 finalists. 8 of current top 10 rushers are in (LT being the other not in and he's still active)

Out of top ten WR's for receptions, only 1 is in (Rice), and for yards only two (Rice and Lofton). Some aren't eligible yet, granted, but if top 10 RB is 'automatic' than the same should hold true for WR's.

[methos4ever]

True, but he could've waited another year in lieu of a WR.

Bettis is sixth (Martin 4th), and he didn't make the top 10 finalists. 8 of current top 10 rushers are in (LT being the other not in and he's still active)

Out of top ten WR's for receptions, only 1 is in (Rice), and for yards only two (Rice and Lofton). Some aren't eligible yet, granted, but if top 10 RB is 'automatic' than the same should hold true for WR's.
Larry Allen, Morten Andersen, Priest Holmes, Steve McNair, Jonathan Ogden, Warren Sapp, Michael Strahan, Bryant Young are all due in 2013. So that means he doesn't have a fair shot til 14...Lame!

[NOT THE DUDE...]

Larry Allen, Morten Andersen, Priest Holmes, Steve McNair, Jonathan Ogden, Warren Sapp, Michael Strahan, Bryant Young are all due in 2013. So that means he doesn't have a fair shot til 14...Lame!

larry allen, ogden, sapp, strahan, are all in....

sucks... maybe reed makes that 5th spot...

looks like 14 or 15 until reed gets in...

[Mr. Pink]

larry allen, ogden, sapp, strahan, are all in....

sucks... maybe reed makes that 5th spot...

looks like 14 or 15 until reed gets in...


Still saying Brown and Carter both make it before Reed does. And it honestly wouldn't surprise me if he never made it. Never thought of Reed as a HOF player then again I never thought of Tez as a HOF player either.

[Night Train]

I thought Cortez Kennedy was a dominant DT and very deserving.

Electors are struggling with WR stats from the past. Todays WR's have such inflated numbers. That hurts Reed,Carter & Brown.

[Johnny Bugmenot]

Andre Reed will never make the Hall of Fame. Too many good WRs in the same era; he's a product of his time. His window came and went a few years ago.

[NOT THE DUDE...]

Andre Reed will never make the Hall of Fame. Too many good WRs in the same era; he's a product of his time. His window came and went a few years ago.

they said the same thing about monk and swann

[Bert102176]

everything about the NFL is F'n BS now a days, and this is an outrage that they f'ed him over again