PDA

View Full Version : Forked Thread: Was it worth it?



better days
03-05-2012, 07:48 PM
Was it worth it? This is a question that Colts fans will have to answer after the next season is over about drafting Luck & letting Manning walk for NOTHING.

The Rams are said to be asking for as much as three #1 draft picks for the 2nd pick in the draft. Imagine how much the Colts could get for the 1st pick if they traded it & kept Manning.

The Colts have grown OLD & are in decline. Even if Luck proves to be the next Manning, that entire team needs to be rebuilt. It could be YEARS before that city sees a winning team again.

On the other hand, if the Colts kept Manning & he were even 75% of his former self imagine how much the trade of the 1st pick in the draft could do to rebuild that team.

Worst case for the Colts & their fans is Luck being a bust while Peyton has another good three or four years in him & the Colts draft Luck. On the other hand even if Peyton did not have any more magic left, at least the Colts could have rebuilt the team by trading the #1 pick.

Don't Panic
03-05-2012, 08:26 PM
If Manning checks out, I have always been a fan of redoing his deal in some way and dealing the pick. I am a huge fan of Luck's, but they could completely retool with three #1s and still make another run at a Super Bowl with Manning still there.