Hypothetical question. If Manning signed here........

[blackonyx89]

I know, I know, Fitz is here and there's no way on Earth would Peyton come here, but what if he did? How many games would the Bills win with the offensive talent they have now? Feel free to discuss, I think they would win 9 or 10 games and get a Wildcard spot. Hmmm.........

[ThunderGun]

Re: Hypothetical question. If Manning signed here........

well if they could win 6 with Fitz, I think they could definitely win 9-10 with Peyton. We have a good running game. Our defense stinks though. And I don't think our OLine could protect him good enough.

Peyton is probably my favorite player ever, but I hope he goes to a decent team. I'd hate for him to get Bledsoe'd.

[stuckincincy]

Re: Hypothetical question. If Manning signed here........

Dallas Clark, Reggie Wayne, and Pierre Garcon do not play for the Bills.

[trapezeus]

Re: Hypothetical question. If Manning signed here........

he'd win 6 games with the bills team as is. Because you will have the same line that isn't deep enough to handle injuries. and we saw how fast and furious people came after the line started to undergo major changes. fitz is a lot mroe mobile that manning and he still ended up with broken ribs.

Manning is a bad investment for a team in desperate need for OL and DL upgrades.

i think fitz can get to 9-10 wins if the rest of the team is fortified with pass rushers and OL players who don't have to be shuffled out of position.

[ThunderGun]

Re: Hypothetical question. If Manning signed here........

Dallas Clark, Reggie Wayne, and Pierre Garcon do not play for the Bills.

Honestly, I think Reggie Wayne = Lee Evans (not saying much). I don't think any of those guys would be worth much without Peyton. Garcon is pretty good.

But I don't think Peyton would be too successful here, because the team has so many holes.

[Cali512]

Re: Hypothetical question. If Manning signed here........

Dallas Clark, Reggie Wayne, and Pierre Garcon do not play for the Bills.

You act like these are the best WRs in the NFL. Johnson is as good if not better than Wayne and Garcon is a solid number 2. The bills should be able to get a 2nd WR in FA or draft that can get 800-900 yds and 5-7 TDs. Meanwhile Clark doesnt count. We use our tight ends totally differently. Clark is only a recieving threat, Indi doesnt use there TEs to block. Clark has soo many more chances to catch passes then Chandler does. Gailey uses TEs to block wayyy more than catch, also Chandler was injured 3 games, and he still had 350 yds and 6 TDs. Thats impressive for a non WR threat. People say that Chandler disapeared, but i believe it was the games that he "disapeared" were games that he had to run block more