Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

[blackonyx89]

I like Barkley, but I've heard a number of shortcomings in his game. EJ may possibly
be a more well rounded QB than Barkley. Who would you pick between the two?

[Novacane]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

I'd be happy with either one

[kishoph]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

I like Barkley, but I've heard a number of shortcomings in his game. EJ may possibly
be a more well rounded QB than Barkley. Who would you pick between the two?

I would think just the opposite, Barkley is ready to play in the NFL, Manuel is more of a project IMO

[hemi13]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

neither !

[SquishDaFish]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

I like both and think Barkley is more ready to step in now and Manuel is the higher ceiling player

[justasportsfan]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Although EJ is raw , he's got more upside. I'd take him.

[tampabay25690]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

I would think just the opposite, Barkley is ready to play in the NFL, Manuel is more of a project IMO

Agreed

[justasportsfan]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Phil Savage says Marrone likes EJ over Nassib . Nassib is supposedly limited and with EJ , Hackett and Marrone can run the read option.

[blackonyx89]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Just seen highlights of both and EJ play is better. Heart says Nassib, but brain says EJ. Hmmmmmm......

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYRCkpnnlIs

[Guest]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Manuel.

We could not start him on Opening Day, but when we are 2-9 or 1-10 by our Bye Week, we can start him for our last 5 games.

He will take some time but unlike the other QBs, he can be truly elite rather than merely good.

He may bust however.

I just think in this draft if we want a real franchise QB we need to swing for the fence.

[justasportsfan]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Manuel.

We could not start him on Opening Day, but when we are 2-9 or 1-10 by our Bye Week, we can start him for our last 5 games.

He will take some time but unlike the other QBs, he can be truly elite rather than merely good.

He may bust however.

I just think in this draft if we want a real franchise QB we need to swing for the fence.

He's not starting which is why we have Kolb.

[Mouldsie]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Manuel but that's not saying much

[Lone Stranger]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Either , but not at #1.

[The Natrix]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

Barkley is Leinart 2.0. Manuel intrigues me a bit, but I'd rather pass on him at #8.

[JediMindPowers]

Re: Barkley vs. EJ Manuel

If you think Barkley is better than Manuel then you're braindead.