CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

[NOT THE DUDE...]

can we franchise him an unlimited amount of times? what if the bills don't let him play come week 10 if he sits out? is he still a ufa next year, or does he lose a year?

- - - Updated - - -

I thought the new cba had franchise tag rules

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1...u-need-to-know here we go. so yeah, we can franchise him multiple times. but the cost gets crazy. imo, with the addition of duke Williams, and jonathan meeks, along with aaron Williams playing great in otas, I think we are going to trade him

- - - Updated - - -

mana silva and Dominique ellis are decent camp prospects too, been with the team for two years

I just hope we at least get a 1st. I know jerry jones needs a safety, and the lions might too with delmas being hurt so much

[GingerP]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

I just hope we at least get a 1st. I know jerry jones needs a safety, and the lions might too with delmas being hurt so much

Here is one rule: You can't trade a player not under contract, and Byrd is not under contract. Unless he signs the tender, you can't trade him. The Bills maintain his rights, so no other team can negotiate with him. Plus, Dallas isn't an option, they have been struggling to say under the cap all offseason.

Another rule: The Bills have until mid-July to sign him to an extension. After that, he can only play on the 1-year deal. Thus, people are getting worried a little early, since there is another month to negotiate and nothing is likely to get done until closer to the deadline.

If the deadline passes and the Bills fail to extend him, he most likely signs the tender before the season. Yeah, he will miss a lot of offseason work, but $6.9M works out to over $400K per week and that is a lot of give up. Byrd has made about $4M over his career, before taxes, so earning 10% of that each week isn't a bad option. He could, if he chooses, wait until week 10 to sign and still get credit for playing the year, but he would be giving up the equivalent of what he has made in the NFL thus far. That isn't happening.

If he does play out the year and earn the $6.9M, he will be an UFA again. The Bills can franchise him again if they wish, but it will cost them 120% of this year's tender, about $8.3M. If they are willing to pay him over $15M in the next 2 years seems to me they should just sign him long-term.

They could franchise him again a 3rd time, but that isn't happening. His tender would be based on the top-5 players in the NFL regardless of position, and the Bills aren't paying him QB money.

[NOT THE DUDE...]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

Here is one rule: You can't trade a player not under contract, and Byrd is not under contract. Unless he signs the tender, you can't trade him. The Bills maintain his rights, so no other team can negotiate with him. Plus, Dallas isn't an option, they have been struggling to say under the cap all offseason.

Another rule: The Bills have until mid-July to sign him to an extension. After that, he can only play on the 1-year deal. Thus, people are getting worried a little early, since there is another month to negotiate and nothing is likely to get done until closer to the deadline.

If the deadline passes and the Bills fail to extend him, he most likely signs the tender before the season. Yeah, he will miss a lot of offseason work, but $6.9M works out to over $400K per week and that is a lot of give up. Byrd has made about $4M over his career, before taxes, so earning 10% of that each week isn't a bad option. He could, if he chooses, wait until week 10 to sign and still get credit for playing the year, but he would be giving up the equivalent of what he has made in the NFL thus far. That isn't happening.

If he does play out the year and earn the $6.9M, he will be an UFA again. The Bills can franchise him again if they wish, but it will cost them 120% of this year's tender, about $8.3M. If they are willing to pay him over $15M in the next 2 years seems to me they should just sign him long-term.

They could franchise him again a 3rd time, but that isn't happening. His tender would be based on the top-5 players in the NFL regardless of position, and the Bills aren't paying him QB money.

but what if he chooses to sit out the whole year? the bills still hold his rights under the 1st year franchise rule, correct?

- - - Updated - - -

I just think we should trade him. I like him, hes really good, but hes not a premium pass rusher, wr, lt, qb... idk

[GingerP]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

but what if he chooses to sit out the whole year? the bills still hold his rights under the 1st year franchise rule, correct?

- - - Updated - - -

I just think we should trade him. I like him, hes really good, but hes not a premium pass rusher, wr, lt, qb... idk

If he stays out beyond week 10 he does not get credit for a year in the league. So yes, his tender would be the same as this year. He also would get a year less credit toward the league retirement benefits, which would mean he gets less when he is done playing.

He isn't sitting out the year, it would be monumentally stupid. In fact, he isn't going to miss any games in a practical sense. A guy who has only earned $4M thus far in his career (pre-tax) is going to take every penny of the almost $7M he will be paid for this year. Yeah, he would like a long term deal, but he still gets a lot more money for this year.

Again, they can't trade him until he signs the tender. If he waits until late in training camp to sign, it is unlikely a team is going to give up big compensation for him once the season starts.

[NOT THE DUDE...]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

If he stays out beyond week 10 he does not get credit for a year in the league. So yes, his tender would be the same as this year. He also would get a year less credit toward the league retirement benefits, which would mean he gets less when he is done playing.

He isn't sitting out the year, it would be monumentally stupid. In fact, he isn't going to miss any games in a practical sense. A guy who has only earned $4M thus far in his career (pre-tax) is going to take every penny of the almost $7M he will be paid for this year. Yeah, he would like a long term deal, but he still gets a lot more money for this year.

Again, they can't trade him until he signs the tender. If he waits until late in training camp to sign, it is unlikely a team is going to give up big compensation for him once the season starts.

so hes going to pretty much play the year on a 1 year deal. not really any choice... but if that's the case, and im sure the bills don't want to franchise him again, wouldn't they just trade him? but that cant happen until he signs. why doesn't he just sign then, its actually hurting him

- - - Updated - - -

I know its otas, but still. the better aaron Williams and duke Williams played, the less leverage he has

[SquishDaFish]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

If he signs his tender and the Bills dont franchise him again he walks free. He will sign his tender right before the season and prob play final preseason game and then play out the year. BUT I still think he might sign longterm before then

[Skooby]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

Here is one rule: You can't trade a player not under contract, and Byrd is not under contract. Unless he signs the tender, you can't trade him. The Bills maintain his rights, so no other team can negotiate with him.

Just imagine the exact opposite of this, then you'd be right.

[IlluminatusUIUC]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

The Bills maintain his rights, so no other team can negotiate with him.

You are incorrect. Byrd received the non-exclusive tender, which means that other teams can indeed negotiate with him. However if they actually signed him to an offer sheet, the Bills would get to match or take two first rounders, which means it will never happen.

http://blogs.buffalonews.com/press-coverage/2013/03/with-non-exclusive-tag-jairus-byrd-still-may-sign-offer-sheet.html

[NOT THE DUDE...]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

im guessing we can probably get a 2nd and 4th... just being realistic. that's not bad

- - - Updated - - -

the raiders are dumb though

[BertSquirtgum]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

Byrd is a being a ***** just like Peters. It's not a coincidence that they have the same agent. Eugene Parker is a worthless human being. I say good riddance. Trade him. This team doesn't need me me me players.

[GingerP]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

You are incorrect. Byrd received the non-exclusive tender, which means that other teams can indeed negotiate with him. However if they actually signed him to an offer sheet, the Bills would get to match or take two first rounders, which means it will never happen.
http://blogs.buffalonews.com/press-c...fer-sheet.html

That ship has sailed. Like RFA, any player on a tender can only negotiate with other teams during the signing period. Like RFA, the signing period ends the week before the draft.

Thus, at this point, he can't negotiate with anyone but the Bills. With the Bills, he can only negotiate a long-term deal up to July 15th. After that, he can only play on the 1-year contract tendered at the start of FA.

The Bills can only trade him if he signs his tender and it becomes a contract. You need a contract to trade a player, you can't trade a tender. That means any deal made would require the Bills to grant another team the right to negotiate a contract, said team agreeing to a long-term deal with Byrd, and then for the Bills and that team to agree on compensation. At that point, Byrd could sign his tender and be traded. It is doubtful to happen at this point, and it isn't an easy process. Byrd needs to agree to sign the tender, until he does he has come control over if he is traded.

There is still another month for the Bills and Byrd to work out a long-term deal. Let's see what happens. If they can't agree, Byrd likely reports before the season starts, although in theory he could hold out until week 10 and still get credited with a year of service. I doubt he does that, he isn't going to leave $4M on the table.

One other possibility is the Bills can pull the tender, making him a FA. It isn't guaranteed until he signs it. It is doubtful the Bills would just give up rights to him, but that is the other possibility.

[IlluminatusUIUC]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

That ship has sailed. Like RFA, any player on a tender can only negotiate with other teams during the signing period. Like RFA, the signing period ends the week before the draft.

Thus, at this point, he can't negotiate with anyone but the Bills. With the Bills, he can only negotiate a long-term deal up to July 15th. After that, he can only play on the 1-year contract tendered at the start of FA.

The Bills can only trade him if he signs his tender and it becomes a contract. You need a contract to trade a player, you can't trade a tender. That means any deal made would require the Bills to grant another team the right to negotiate a contract, said team agreeing to a long-term deal with Byrd, and then for the Bills and that team to agree on compensation. At that point, Byrd could sign his tender and be traded. It is doubtful to happen at this point, and it isn't an easy process. Byrd needs to agree to sign the tender, until he does he has come control over if he is traded.

There is still another month for the Bills and Byrd to work out a long-term deal. Let's see what happens. If they can't agree, Byrd likely reports before the season starts, although in theory he could hold out until week 10 and still get credited with a year of service. I doubt he does that, he isn't going to leave $4M on the table.

One other possibility is the Bills can pull the tender, making him a FA. It isn't guaranteed until he signs it. It is doubtful the Bills would just give up rights to him, but that is the other possibility.

Right, I always forget that period ends in april

[NOT THE DUDE...]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

Just trade him. I don't know why byrd is even doing this, its hurting him. the only thing I can think of is he doesn't want to risk injury until he signs a tender or new long term deal... but he would have said that... idk...

[Extremebillsfan247]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

Here is one rule: You can't trade a player not under contract, and Byrd is not under contract. Unless he signs the tender, you can't trade him. The Bills maintain his rights, so no other team can negotiate with him. Plus, Dallas isn't an option, they have been struggling to say under the cap all offseason. Another rule: The Bills have until mid-July to sign him to an extension. After that, he can only play on the 1-year deal. Thus, people are getting worried a little early, since there is another month to negotiate and nothing is likely to get done until closer to the deadline. If the deadline passes and the Bills fail to extend him, he most likely signs the tender before the season. Yeah, he will miss a lot of offseason work, but $6.9M works out to over $400K per week and that is a lot of give up. Byrd has made about $4M over his career, before taxes, so earning 10% of that each week isn't a bad option. He could, if he chooses, wait until week 10 to sign and still get credit for playing the year, but he would be giving up the equivalent of what he has made in the NFL thus far. That isn't happening. If he does play out the year and earn the $6.9M, he will be an UFA again. The Bills can franchise him again if they wish, but it will cost them 120% of this year's tender, about $8.3M. If they are willing to pay him over $15M in the next 2 years seems to me they should just sign him long-term. They could franchise him again a 3rd time, but that isn't happening. His tender would be based on the top-5 players in the NFL regardless of position, and the Bills aren't paying him QB money.

I was going to enter with a similar response until I read this one. Good post.

[tatersalad]

Re: CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE RULES ON THE BYRD HOLDOUT?

[QUOTE=GingerP;3806603]Here is one rule: You can't trade a player not under contract, and Byrd is not under contract. Unless he signs the tender, you can't trade him. The Bills maintain his rights, so no other team can negotiate with him. Plus, Dallas isn't an option, they have been struggling to say under the cap all offseason.

Another rule: The Bills have until mid-July to sign him to an extension. After that, he can only play on the 1-year deal. Thus, people are getting worried a little early, since there is another month to negotiate and nothing is likely to get done until closer to the deadline.

If the deadline passes and the Bills fail to extend him, he most likely signs the tender before the season. Yeah, he will miss a lot of offseason work, but $6.9M works out to over $400K per week and that is a lot of give up. Byrd has made about $4M over his career, before taxes, so earning 10% of that each week isn't a bad option. He could, if he chooses, wait until week 10 to sign and still get credit for playing the year, but he would be giving up the equivalent of what he has made in the NFL thus far. That isn't happening.

If he does play out the year and earn the $6.9M, he will be an UFA again. The Bills can franchise him again if they wish, but it will cost them 120% of this year's tender, about $8.3M. If they are willing to pay him over $15M in the next 2 years seems to me they should just sign him long-term.

They could franchise him again a 3rd time, but that isn't happening. His tender would be based on the top-5 players in the NFL regardless of position, and the Bills aren't paying him QB money.[/QU

the cost to franchise him this yr and next yr is still a million and a half cheaper than what he is asking the Bills would be right to do it both times, he really has no leverage he holdouts loses millions in a game as violebt as football? not gonna happen Parker is smart not dumb on any scale he will get done this yr