Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

[DetDannyWilliams]

simple does Andre Reed get into the Hall of Fame this year?

[imbondz]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

Yes

- - - Updated - - -

What day/time do they announce it?

[The Jokeman]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

simple does Andre Reed get into the Hall of Fame this year?

I'm not sure there are guys like Derrick Brooks and Michael Strahan to me are sure fire guys. Then there's a guy like Walter Jones and Charles Haley who I feel deserve in over Reed and think Jerome Bettis has some sentimental ties to make it. Toss in Morten Anderson who is arguably the best Kicker ever. I have a feeling the answer will once again be no because there are better players in this class than Reed. Yet if there was a time to get in it might be this year since many of these guys have a few more years they can be nominated and eventual make it but ultimately if I was to place a bet I say no he'll get looked over again.

[sudzy]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

Toss in Morten Anderson who is arguably the best Kicker ever.

Why does Morten Anderson deserve to get in when the undisputed best Special Teams player ever (Steve Tasker) still isn't in?

[The Jokeman]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

Why does Morten Anderson deserve to get in when the undisputed best Special Teams player ever (Steve Tasker) still isn't in?

Because Anderson as a K had a much bigger impact on games than Tasker did. Tasker is to me is like a pinch hitter in baseball. You recognize him when hits the HR but when he hits a sack fly or a single meh not really an impact. At least with a K you can see points that they actually produced on the scoreboard toss in he played 25 years whereas Tasker played a little more than half of that with 13 seasons. Toss in it's debatable if he was the best ST ever. Maybe best coverage player but you could argue that return men are more valuable than coverage guys. As to me a guy like Devin Hester is worth more than a Tasker all things considered. Yet I wouldn't call Hester a Hall of Famer either.

[sudzy]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

25 YEARS!?!? WOW!!! How did he do it? Oh yeah, he was a kicker. More to the point, how did Tasker last 13 years? Running head first into a wedge a dozen plays a game. Anderson may very well be the best kicker ever. What does that mean to me? Wait for a down year and I'd think about adding the 2nd kicker ever (Stenerud). But, to Tasker's defense, he change a part of the game. They made a spot in the Pro-Bowl just for him. Every team started to look for a Tasker of their own.

[gr8slayer]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

He won't make it this year.

[YardRat]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

Tasker revolutionized the game, that's why he should be in. So did Ray Guy, and he should be a shoo-in this year as a senior candidate. About time.

Would love to see Reed get in, but Tim Brown or Marvin Harrison will probably bump him.

[Skooby]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

You betcha !

[The last buffalo fan]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

Si.

[TacklingDummy]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

No, will be awhile before he gets in.

[Meathead]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

im starting to worry andre might go postal one of these years

[Mr. Pink]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

He might get in...as an eventual senior candidate.

Won't happen anytime soon.

[coastal]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

2:1 odds.

same as thurm falling off the wagon.

[capitolneal]

Re: Does Reed make NFL PFHOF this year?

yes he will