March Madness - Elite 8: #1 Jim Kelly vs #2 Bruce Smith

[The King]

http://www.billszone.com/wp-content/uploads/e8jimvsbruce.jpg

[Topas]

Wow, did not expect the vote to be that one-sided.
But Bruce was arguably the best DE ever. Jim was not the best QB ever. But I would love for Kelly to win that thing. There is no-one more "Buffalo" than him.

[casdhf]

If this is based upon only what happened on the field, it's hard not to vote Bruce. If it's in total, Kelly has to be the vote.

[sudzy]

Winner of this wins the whole thing. Might as well stop playing after this.

[WagonCircler]

Personalities and "greatest of all time" at their position notwithstanding, QBs are more valuable than Defensive Ends.

It's not even arguable.

[Meathead]

true but bruce is probably best of all time or at least number two. jimbo is barely in the discussion of top ten greatest qbs

if i could only pick one of the two to start a team i guess id probably take kelly since qb is so vital. but bruce was the better baller so i went with him

[Skooby]

If off-field behavior was any consideration then it's Jim. Bruce would of been suspended several times in today's world.

[WagonCircler]

if i could only pick one of the two to start a team i guess id probably take kelly since qb is so vital.

Case closed.