If you could guarantee that any 5 players would not get injured this season, which 5

[WG]

...would it be? Why?

I'll say:

Spikes, since he'll be the biggest single impact player on D IMO. Plus he's the only outstanding LB and the toughest one to replace.

Moulds, since w/o him, our air game drops several notches.

Pat Williams since he's the biggest factor on the DL.

Schobel, not b/c he's stellar, but b/c w/o him we'd really be hurtin'.

Drew, b/c...

Nah, jk!

Reuben Brown, again, not b/c I think he's as good as those who continually vote him to the PB, but b/c he'd be the most difficult to replace on our interior line, and the biggest player for whom the marginal difference between him and the backup would be the greatest. We could weather an injury to MW or JJ w/ Price for a while, IMO.

[casdhf]

I'd have to go with Travis Henry, Takeo Spikes, Drew Bledsoe, Nate Clements and Brian Moorman

[WG]

Why?

Moorman. Interesting.

[THATHURMANATOR]

Bledsoe
Moulds
Williams
Clements
mwilliams/Jennings

[LtBillsFan66]

Bledsoe
Moulds
Spikes
Clements
Winfield

[lordofgun]

Pat Williams
Sam Adams
Takeo Spikes
Antoine Winfield
Nate Clements

[LtBillsFan66]

No one gets hurt.

[JefftheBillsfan]

hmm good question...

Pat Williams
Ruben Brown (no depth)
Eric Moulds
Takeo Spikes
Aaron Shobel

[Tatonka]

tko
henry
e mo
p willy
j reed

[lordofgun]

I picked all defense. If our D is as good as it can be this year, we'll need it to stay healthy. If our D stays healthy and plays great, we could even endure the loss of a Henry or Bledsoe. But without a good D, the offense will not be able to get it done consistently....just look at last year.

BTW, good thread, wys.

[Dozerdog]

Ray Lucas

[WG]

Originally posted by lordofgun
I picked all defense. If our D is as good as it can be this year, we'll need it to stay healthy. If our D stays healthy and plays great, we could even endure the loss of a Henry or Bledsoe. But without a good D, the offense will not be able to get it done consistently....just look at last year.

BTW, good thread, wys.

XXX
OOO

[Halbert]

Originally posted by THATHURMANATOR
mwilliams/Jennings

Cheater

1. Drew - AVP just can't do what he does
2. Adams - yes, I think he'll make that big an impact overall
3. Moulds - Big-Plays-R-Us
4. Spikes - Forgive me, London, he's the best backer on the team
5. Gash - Maybe I'm giving him too much credit but he's a proven vet who knows how to make the key plays that win games. Whether he starts or not, he will play and you just can't lead like that as effectively in street clothes.

[shadowfax]

i was just having this conversation

with a friend of mine during a 1 hour drive. Although it was 10 guys, not five.

I'd go with:

Bledsoe (the dropoff would be deadly to this team's chances)
Travis (With WM not ready, the dropoff would be palpable)
EMoulds (obviously)
Sam Adams (I don't think Pat Williams *gets* hurt)
Nate Clements

*spikes has never missed a game
*fletch is always healthy

I'd like to see all of our OLinemen stay healthy, but you said 5 guys. Those are mine.

[RUDEbyallMEANS]

For Miami:
1. Ricky Williams.. Most valuable player on the team, Top 2-3 RB in NFL, if not the best..
2. Jason Taylor.. TOP 2 DE in NFL enough said..
3. Mark Dixon.. Miami would then need to start a rookie 3rd rounder at LT
4. Chris Chambers.. Another Big play WR that is poised for a breakout year, superior to any WR on Miami roster..
5. Junior Seau.. Miami would have to play rookie 2nd rounder Eddie Moore

These IMO are Miami most valuable players.. The rest could be replaced with capable starters.. If Zach got injured, Seau play MLB and Eddie/Greenwood play outside.. I Madison or Surtain got injured, Buckley fills in.. If Marion is injured, Freeman plays his natural position (FS) and Sammy stays at SS.. Fiedler could be replaced by Griese.. McMike replaced by Don Lee.. Timbo or Chester replaced by Zgonina.. That was my reasoning...

HURRAH:drinker: