trade proposal .. advice needed asap

[TypicalBill]

he gives me:

Antowain Smith
David Boston




I give him:

Michael Vick
Anthony Thomas



i need advice quick cuz it will get deleted soon if i dont respond.. its been up there for 2 days..




im leaning towards declining since Vick wont be out too long like pennington.




Thanks in advance

[Earthquake Enyart]

You guys are just swapping garbage cans. Boston already has gimpy ankles. Read the ESPN Mag story about that guy...

No way Vick comes back as fast as they say.

The A train and Smith are both busters.

[lordofgun]

Depends what your roster looks like.

[TypicalBill]

QB Rich Gannon
RB Travis Henry
RB/WR Ahman Green
WR Joe Horn
WR Isaac Bruce
TE Bubba Franks
K Jeff Reed
D Atlanta Falcons

ROSTER: BENCH

Bench Michael Vick
Bench Correll Buckhalter
Bench Warrick Dunn
Bench Anthony Thomas
Bench LaMont Jordan
Bench Jake Plummer
Bench Reggie Wayne
Bench Doug Johnson

[Novacane]

Don't do it TB.

[TypicalBill]

i declined :up:

[lordofgun]

You can get more for Vick once he returns. I'd try to deal him when he gets back from the injury because how much more is he going to score than gannon?

[TypicalBill]

yep, thats what ive done in that draft ... strange but wortha try ... i decided since the QB position got thin, i was gonna grab 3 or 4 QB's that could have an impact and then trade 1 or 2 later in the season for a player than would fill a weakness in my team... i also took more than a few young RB's hoping that one of them really emerges and would turn into good trade bait too...

[Earthquake Enyart]

I disagree. No way Vick comes back and plays worth a damn after a broken leg. Dump him now.

[TypicalBill]

i get what you're saying EE, its a risk ... but id rather dump him for someone who'll help my team than nothing...

[Earthquake Enyart]

I hear ya, but I don't like Boston....

He sure looks like he's on the juice....plus he has Drew Brees throwing him the ball. :eek:

[Sabre Ally]

Would you like him better if Jim Miller was throwing to him? :snicker:

[TypicalBill]

Originally posted by Earthquake Enyart
I hear ya, but I don't like Boston....

He sure looks like he's on the juice....plus he has Drew Brees throwing him the ball. :eek:


yep, thats why i declined... Vick might be injured but Boston is an injury waiting to happen.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Originally posted by Sabre Ally
Would you like him better if Jim Miller was throwing to him? :snicker:


Obviously. Jim Miller throws a nice deep ball. :up:

[TypicalBill]

disagreed :up: