Reed or Shaw? Who will have the better year?

[salarycap]

Trying to get a handle on the Bills #2 WR. Who's better and why?

[Novacane]

Reed...........no question IMO.

[Halbert]

Shaw is like Hakim - great 3rd, weak 2nd. Reed has more upside so even if he lags at first I suspect he'll come on later.

[Ð]

Pshaw....Reed in a heartbeat

[Demon]

I definetly think Reed will be better then Shaw, esspicially in the first few weeks, because defenses will double cover Moulds and leave Reed one on one with a weaker CB and Bledsoe will look for Reed alot more.

[BigMike68]

Reed gonna be the Keenan McCardell type reciver (back when he was in Jax with Jimmy Smith) He will get like 70-80 receptions and just over 1,000 yards. Shaw will be alot like Ahsley Lelie was last year as a 3rd option around 50 catches with 600-800 yeards.

[BigMike68]

And Salary Cap welcome to the board.

[StillLurkin]

no doubt-Reed

[bernielivsey_1]

Reed might be shakey for the first few games but he'll settle down later. Shaw is what he is and thats not a # 2.

[Drewpac]

I saw Shaw play alot in college when he was with Cal. I think he's a pretty good receiver who hasn't been given a real shot in the pros yet. I think Shaw and Reed are about equal in talent and at this point I give the edge to Shaw based on his experience. Either way, we can't go wrong because they are both good receivers.

[robeezy]

Reed is the better reciever, Shaw is just faster and a little brighter.

[BillsOwnAll]

Reed is more of a playmaker........you know what i mean.