Winfield or Ty Law?

[Pride]

It may come down to this at the end of this season. What do you think?

[DBam]

Law is a better pure cover corner, while Winfield is a better open field tackler. Can't go wrong with either one.

[Pride]

Then answer me this.

Answer Coverage or Tackler to all of the following:

Winfield -
Clements -
Milloy -
Wire -
Preliou -

My personal opinion is of the bunch, Clements is the only solid cover player we have. I would rather have Law, a premier cover corner, than another tackler.

Begs the question, if you have a shut down corner, does he really need to tackle that often? And if he does need to tackle, is he not a very good CB? See Deion Sanders (ignoring his stupid personality)

[TedMock]

I'd rather see Winfield here for chemistry. He's as good overall as most corners and why let him go only to pay the same money to one of the other big name free agent corners? Having said that, here are a few of next year's free agent corners I wouldn't mind us having...

Antoine Winfield
Ty Law
Chris McCalister
Champ Bailey
Charles Woodson

Good crop, but for chemistry and "laying wood" I'll take Winfield.

[Pride]

I see what you guys are saying about "laying wood", but I would rather never see my CB make a hit... meaning he was never thrown to, or his receiver never caught the ball.

Other than INT's in a game, you should never hear a great CB's name.

[TedMock]

See, I believe that Winfield is a solid cover guy. I think Clements is the better cover guy although he was the one beat last week for the only good Pats pass play. Winfield is a solid cover guy who comes up for run support better than most. Deion was a great cover guy who hurt his team in run support at times. I think Antoine is highly underrated for his coverage skills.

[Billsbabee]

Could you post their pics to help me make my decision? :D

:jk:

[EM Bills Fan 80]

Originally posted by TedMock
I'd rather see Winfield here for chemistry. He's as good overall as most corners and why let him go only to pay the same money to one of the other big name free agent corners? Having said that, here are a few of next year's free agent corners I wouldn't mind us having...

Antoine Winfield
Ty Law
Chris McCalister
Champ Bailey
Charles Woodson

Good crop, but for chemistry and "laying wood" I'll take Winfield.

Dont forget about Shawn Springs

[ryven]

Winfield did not have many balls thrown his way last year which is one hint to me that he is an above average cover corner. I believe he is a very solid cover CB and it's nice to have a guy who can come up and make the takle if god forbid the RB makes it that far. I think we will hear Winfield's name more often this and not because he got burned.

[Mr. Miyagi]

Originally posted by Billsbabee
Could you post their pics to help me make my decision? :D

:jk:
http://images.nfl.com/images/players/60x80/133453.jpg
Winfield

http://images.nfl.com/images/players/60x80/3820.jpg
Law

http://images.nfl.com/images/players/60x80/133350.jpg
McAlister

http://images.nfl.com/images/players/60x80/133217.jpg
Bailey

http://images.nfl.com/images/players/60x80/12841.jpg
Woodson

http://images.nfl.com/images/players/60x80/4602.jpg
Springs

Looks like Winfield is here to stay. :D

[Gunzlingr]

Originally posted by EM Bills Fan 80
Dont forget about Shawn Springs

He seems to be hurt all the damn time.

[Billsbabee]

:fabulous: Thank you Mr Miyagi :laughter:

I will go with Winfield at this time. I agree with ryven that Winfield does seem to be avoided and that tells me he is feared. (However the same can be said of Law.) TedMock makes a good point too- "I'd rather see Winfield here for chemistry. He's as good overall as most corners and why let him go only to pay the same money to one of the other big name free agent corners?"

[Drewpac]

I'd rather have Winfield. Also, I think he's three or four years younger than Ty Law. This is only Winfield's fifth season in the league.

[Mr. Miyagi]

And the fact that Winfield and Clements have that Ohio State connection...

[Pride]

Originally posted by Mr. Miyagi
And the fact that Winfield and Clements have that Ohio State connection...


ummm...... ok....... how does that help?

[ryven]

They played to gether in college for a year or to and know there playing to gether on the bills they know each others strengths and weaknesses.

[The_Philster]

I'd take Winfield because he knows the system better as well as the players around him...especially Nate


Originally posted by ryven
They played to gether in college for a year or to and know there playing to gether on the bills they know each others strengths and weaknesses.
Exactly....they've developed a chemistry over all these years.

[Ron C.]

With our 5 Mil wasted on Fina's dead money, I would target CBs in the following order:

1: Bailey
2: Law
3: Winfield
4: McAlister
5: Woodsen
6: Springs

[ublinkwescore]

I'd go:

1. Winfield
2. Bailey
3. Woodson (provided he can stay healthy all year long this year)
4. Law (only to get into BB's head again)

The rest are all afterthoughts if we should fail to pick up one of the above.

[e-bill 00]

:patriot: