Who's over/under performing now?

[WG]

Based on salary, expectations, experience, reliance by the team, etc., who is over-performing, under-performing, or playing where they should? Doesn't mean it's their fault as in the case of the TEs for example.

Include coaching. Starters primarily as well.

Over:

DREEEWWWWW!!!
Schobel
Wire
Reed


On or about where they should be:

Moulds
Price
Mike Williams
Jennings
Centers
Pat Williams
Prioleau
Clements
Newman
Ahanotu
Sullivan
Rogers
Gilbride


Under:

Brown
Winfield
Fletcher
Robinson
Teague
Henry
JR
Jerry Gray

[LtBillsFan66]

Why Winfield?

The only one I'm real unhappy with is Robinson.

[Creemoredrinker]

Excellent Thread

I would move Price up one category and Prioleau done one if he is on his new contract already.

I would also move Fletcher up one category.

I would put Gred Williams in the middle category and put Tom in the first.

Otherwise you have once again done an excellent job.

[Phins054]

I think Drew is playing the way he always has been capable of. I think the issue with him over the last few years (other than health) has been staying motivated. It seemed that if a game or two fot away or he played poorly...it carried over into the next game. I am sure that at some point this season Drew will be in a lull. It will be interesting to see how he responds to it.

[SoCalBillsFan]

Underachieving:

Fletcher
Watson
Clements
Robinson

I know putting clements here will upset people, but I think he has not played as well as he could, therefor is underachieving. He has allowed several big pass plays, and has no picks, I haven't seen him make too many plays. He has been good in run support however. I'd like to see him play better.

[SoCalBillsFan]

Originally posted by Phins054
I am sure that at some point this season Drew will be in a lull. It will be interesting to see how he responds to it.

Phins I agree completely. I definately think there will be a two or three game span where he hits the wall for a bit, and I am very interested in seeing how he and the fans will respond.

[Creemoredrinker]

Are You a Bills Fan?

Originally posted by SoCalBillsFan


Phins I agree completely. I definately think there will be a two or three game span where he hits the wall for a bit, and I am very interested in seeing how he and the fans will respond.

Or are you under the influence of stickin' rotting dead fish smell?

Who says he will hit a wall? Previous year's patterns mean nothing this year.

[WG]

Yeah, as one of Drew's formerly harshest critics, and as one who has watched him very, very much while he was on the Pats, I agree w/ Cree. Like all QBs, he'll have an off game or two, but I don't see the QB who used to go into 3-5 game slumps. He's playing far better than he ever has and much of that has to do w/ his mentals and lack of key errors.

He'll have tough games v. the Phins as he always does, but he'll have better games v. them than he has in the past. I see 2 or 3 non-consecutive games in which he doesn't perform well. If you look over the past couple of seasons, you'll notice like 4-6 games per year in which he tossed 0 TDs. I see that happening maybe once this year in a bad-game scenario. I see only a few 1 TD games too. 1 or 2 perhaps.


BFO,

I put Winfield on that list b/c he's been getting burned a lot lately in pass coverage. His run coverage is outstanding. Especially this past week. He's a better CB against the run than he is against the pass.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Under:

Watson
Danny Smith
Mean Sharks

[BillsNYC]

over - our entire offense ( i never thought we'd be this good!)

under - linebackers (been way too quiet)
special teams (i don't have to explain)

[LtBillsFan66]

Originally posted by Wys Guy
BFO,

I put Winfield on that list b/c he's been getting burned a lot lately in pass coverage. His run coverage is outstanding. Especially this past week. He's a better CB against the run than he is against the pass.

I guess he has been less than stellar. And since we all think he can do better, it's a fair rank.

[Creemoredrinker]

You Agree with Little O' Me?

Originally posted by Wys Guy
..., I agree w/ Cree.

I'm honoUred that U agree with me O'Wise One.

[Earthquake Enyart]

Originally posted by Wys Guy
Yeah, as one of Drew's formerly harshest critics,

[Ingtar33]

Wys...
Have you noticed how Drew has only thrown one or two passes off his back foot this year (both in week one)? That use to be his trademark INT throw. Have you also noticed how he has settled down over the last 4 weeks and is playing more confident that he did at the beginning of the season? All of his bad habits (repetitive patting of the ball, indecisiveness, "happy feet", ect...) which developed when he was getting pummeled by a bad O-line seem to be going away... is that coaching or just confidence?

[SoCalBillsFan]

Originally posted by Wys Guy
Like all QBs, he'll have an off game or two, but I don't see the QB who used to go into 3-5 game slumps. He's playing far better than he ever has and much of that has to do w/ his mentals and lack of key errors.

I didn't say 3-5 game slumps, I said 2 or 3 games where he may not play well. Maybe they wont be back to back even. I just think we need to be prepared that he might not be amazing every time out, and i'm interested in seeing how he responds to those games.