AFC and NFC Rookie of the Year???

[Phins054]

Who do you think should be the ROY on offense and defense for the AFC and NFC???

AFC
Offensive- Randy McMichael (Clinton Portis is doing well too)

Defensive- Phillip Buchanon

NFC
Offensive- Dante Stallworth (Patrick Ramsey could challenge)

Defensive- Julius Peppers

[Novacane]

Do I sense a little bias there on AFC offensive ROY.


Deon Branch has twice as many catches. He's my choice so far.

Agree with the rest.

[WCoastFin]

Its still early but, I agree with your choices so far....except for C.Portis.....dont get me wrong, hes good, but I think part of his success is based on the fact that he shares time.

[Novacane]

That does not make sense WCF. Would he not have even better stats if he did not share time?

[WCoastFin]

Originally posted by BledsoeTOreedfor6
That does not make sense WCF. Would he not have even better stats if he did not share time?

he probably would.....but "probably" doesnt count....becuz then we can also say he would "probably" commit more mistakes...he would "probably" be more tired....he would "probabaly" fumble alot.....you know what im saying?

[Phins054]

You're right BTR...I forgot about Branch. He and McMichael are fairly close statwise too. But I got to play the homer and vote Randy...

[Bruce is Loose]

plus McMichael is a TE and will by nature of the position get worse stats.

I imagine he is in the top few TEs in recieveing stats.

[RedEyE]

It's presently too tight of a race for me to determine.