Who are the top 13?

[hintexas]

Since the Bills have pick #13 I thought we should try to make a list of the top 13 players that fill a Bills need position. I am assuming that the Bills are getting Drew Henson so I don't have a QB as a need.

This list may change with free agency but my top 13 not in any order are;
1. Mike Williams, 2. Larry Fitsgerald, 3. Roy Williams, 4. Robert Gallery, 5. Sean Taylor, 6. Shawn Andrews, 7. Kenechi Udeze, 8. Kellen Winslow, 9. Reggie Wiliams, 10. Will Smith, 11. Michael Clayton, 12. DeAngelo Hall, 13. Chris Gamble


I would be happy to have any of them added to the Bills.

[elltrain22]

Here goes: mine are in order

1. Eli Manning
2. Larry Fitzgerald
3. Ben Rothlesberger
4. Rob Gallery
5. Kellen Winslow
6. Sean Taylor
7. Chris Gamble
8. Mike Williams
9. Shane Andrews
10. DeAngelo Hall
11. Kenechi Udeze
12. Roy Williams
13. Philip Rivers

[Dozerdog]

Originally posted by hintexas
Since the Bills have pick #13 I thought we should try to make a list of the top 13 players that fill a Bills need position. I am assuming that the Bills are getting Drew Henson so I don't have a QB as a need.

This list may change with free agency but my top 13 not in any order are;
1. Mike Williams, 2. Larry Fitsgerald, 3. Roy Williams, 4. Robert Gallery, 5. Sean Taylor, 6. Shawn Andrews, 7. Kenechi Udeze, 8. Kellen Winslow, 9. Reggie Wiliams, 10. Will Smith, 11. Michael Clayton, 12. DeAngelo Hall, 13. Chris Gamble


I would be happy to have any of them added to the Bills.


No QBs????

[hintexas]

As I stated I was assuming that the Bills are going to sign Drew Henson so I left him off my list but if they dont get Henson I would put Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger on the list and probable Rivers too. But the Bills dont need 3 starting QB's before they adress other issues

[mypoorfriendme]

fitzgerald and roy williams are better than mike

[SoCalBillsFan]

Originally posted by mypoorfriendme
fitzgerald and roy williams are better than mike

Fitzgerald maybe, but Roy? No way.

Roy will run a better 40, you can take that the bank. But he isnt the player mike is. Just watch both of their highlight reels.

[mypoorfriendme]

i would consider your argument.....but then i realized who it was coming from

[mypoorfriendme]

is colbert better than reggie, too? :jk:

[SoCalBillsFan]

well by that logic, everyone on this site isn't allowed to evaluate bills players, because they are all biased....


Roy Williams-70 Rec, 1049 yards, 9 TD
Mike Williams 95 Rec, 1314 yards, 16 TD.

but stats aren't everything. ROy williams takes plays off. I watched him in the holiday bowl, he didn't care half the time. I think Mike will be a better player, though Roy wil have better workouts.

tell me why I am wrong, don't just dismiss it as biased. (by the way, i think carson palmer will flop in the NFL, if that means anything to you...)

[kill4bills]

mike williams is the best receiver ive seen in years. probably since randy moss and im not joking he is the real deal

[mypoorfriendme]

i think mike williams may have the most reliable hands in this years class, but i dont see him being more than a keyshawn johnson in the nfl which is good, but larry fitzgerald might be the next marvin harrison and roy williams the next eric moulds. usc had a great offense last year where as pitt and texas didnt have so many weapons to spread the defense out. roy williams has slowly been recovering from injuries and played without a qb this season and a strugging offense. larry on the other hand, had a desent qb, but defenses could get away with triple teaming him and he still produced. id put mike williams in between reggie and roy williams

[mypoorfriendme]

and i know youre not biased, im just kidding. another reason for my reasons is just a gut feeling and if anything im biased against USC

[TheGhostofJimKelly]

My top 20:

1. Sean Tayler, S, Miami
2. Larry Fitzgerald, WR, Pitt
3. Mike Williams, WR, USC
4. Robert Gallery, T, Iowa
5. Ben Roethlisberger, QB, Miami (Oh)
6. Roy Williams, WR, Texas
7. Reggie Williams, WR, Washington
8. Kellen Winlsow Jr, TE, Miami
9. Eli Manning, QB, Miss
10. Kenechi Udezi, DE, USC
11. Tommie Harris, DT, Okl
12. Shawn Andrews, T, Ark
13. Chris Gamble, CB, Ohio St
14. DeAngelo Hall, CB, Virg. Tech
15. Michael Clayton, WR, LSU
16. Will Smith, DE, Ohio St
16. DJ Williams, LB, Miami
17. Kevin Jones, RB, Virg Tech
18. Vince Wolfork, DT, Miami
19. Karlos Dansby, LB, Auburn
20. Derrick Straight, CB, Oklahoma

[Ingtar33]

Roy had no-one throwing him the ball

here's a stat for you, Roy Williams 30 TD receptions last two years.

doesn't really mater, Roy/Mike/Fitz are all better than Rogers or Johnson last season.

[TheGhostofJimKelly]

Oh, I didn't put Mike Williams in my list, I say he is #7. I just wrote out my list and posted. I could have missed a few others.

[tampabay25690]

1. Eli Manning
2. Big Ben
3. Larry Fitzgerald
4. Mike Williams
5. Robert Gallery
6. Sean TAylor
7. Kellen Winslow Jr
8. Roy Williams
9. Tommie Harris
10. Reggie Williams
11. Shawn Andrews
12. Kenechi Udezi
13. Will Smith
14. Kevin Jones
15. Stephen Jackson
16. Denangelo Hall
17. Chris Gamble
18. Michael Clayton
19. Will Wolfork
20. Ben Troupe

[elltrain22]

Mike Williams is the complete package. Hands, speed, size, and a national champion. This guy may even be better than Fitz', and thats saying a whole lot.

[TheGhostofJimKelly]

Originally posted by elltrain22
Mike Williams is the complete package. Hands, speed, size, and a national champion. This guy may even be better than Fitz', and thats saying a whole lot.

You know, you are right. I have seen a few places that have him as high as 4. He is a great player. OK, you convinced me to do some research now. I will put him #5 on my list.

[eyedog]

Best receivers in order:

1. Mike Williams
2. Fitzgerald
3. Roy Williams
4. Reggie Williams.

Then there is a drop off to Clayton, Evans, Woods, Wilford

[The Spaz]

Wilford ran a 4.7 and a 4.8 at the combine.

[SoCalBillsFan]

Originally posted by Ingtar33
Roy had no-one throwing him the ball

here's a stat for you, Roy Williams 30 TD receptions last two years.



Ing, it was Mike Williams who had 30 TDs the last 2 years. Roy williams scored 28 in his entire 3 year career...

[eyedog]

Wilford is dropping to rd. 3 if he ran those times.
It might have been an Ing typo on the williams td's.