Rivers or Rothlisberger

[schobelisdaman]

If both are available........who would you take. Rothlisberger has the workout numbers.. Rivers has the experience.

[Devin]

well for a running team, with the possibility of a starter needed this season or next Rivers. His short/midfield game is unmatched.

Ben is more mobile and has a strong arm...tough call really.

For me Rivers.

[juice]

Give me the Big Kid with the Cannon.. You cant coach size and armstrength.

I'd play Rivers year #1 every chance I got.

[chernobylwraiths]

Big Ben.

[toughluck]

Going on the fact that we are probably going to need a QB within a year or two, Rivers

[ryjam282]

Rivers...He will be a star.

[mypoorfriendme]

i like rivers more, but im giong to have to say ben simply because he is regaurded by most one of the top 3 players in the draft, while rivers is usually around 10 or so. ben is quick, mobile, smart, and has a CANNON for an arm and throws wonderfully off the run and out of the pocket. reminds me a lot of daunte culpepper whereas rivers is more of a tom brady.

[schobelisdaman]

Thats why Rivers would be better for this team earlier....comparing Big Ben to Daunte Culpepper makes sense(more mistakes earlier).....for a team that is going to be set up to run, avoiding mistakes is key....thats why Rivers would give us the most stability the quickest.......even though both will probably be good NFL starting quarterbacks.

[mypoorfriendme]

the truth of the matter is...half of the first rounders will probably be busts and i gurentee you atleast one of the top three qb's will be

[STAMPY]

you guys need to pass me that crack your smoking Rivers isn't in BIG BEN'S league!!!

My answer is Big Ben nuff said... stronger arm, better release, and can ran better. Ben Nuff Said

[mypoorfriendme]

Originally posted by BuffaloBillsSTAMPEDE
you guys need to pass me that crack your smoking Rivers isn't in BIG BEN'S league!!!

My answer is Big Ben nuff said... stronger arm, better release, and can ran better. Ben Nuff Said

i pretty much agree. remember in the beginning of the offseason everyone thouht rivers was a second rounder at best. he has improved his draft stock a ton, but people kind of feed off of eachother too much and now he has more hype than he deserves. i am the original rivers fan, but still i dont think he deserves the 13th overall ESPECIALLY if its over roethlesburger

[STAMPY]

Originally posted by mypoorfriendme
i pretty much agree. remember in the beginning of the offseason everyone thouht rivers was a second rounder at best. he has improved his draft stock a ton, but people kind of feed off of eachother too much and now he has more hype than he deserves. i am the original rivers fan, but still i dont think he deserves the 13th overall ESPECIALLY if its over roethlesburger

Big Ben... BELIEVE THE HYPE

[Tatonka]

i like rivers better.. as a fan..

i would pick big ben if i was TD.

[mypoorfriendme]

Originally posted by Tatonka
i like rivers better.. as a fan..

i would pick big ben if i was TD.

THATS what i was trying to say

[juice]

Originally posted by juice
Give me the Big Kid with the Cannon.. You cant coach size and armstrength.

I'd play Rivers year #1 every chance I got.

You'd have to take the Better athlete.